This book represents a great contribution to Latin American urban studies and particularly to the role of public space in the construction of recent Latin American urban history. Clara Irazábal puts together a multidisciplinary approach with case studies of significant public spaces in nine Latin American cities that help the reader expand the notion of the public sphere to the spatiality of the physical urban space. The role of space in politics of culture is analysed in depth through the ‘extraordinary events’ that have constructed a collective significance around these urban elements.
An introduction and opening chapter by Clara Irazábal sets the political and cultural framework of the book and clarifies the definitions of citizenship, democracy and public space in Latin America with diverse and contemporary theoretical perspectives. The contributors – architects, planners and sociologists – explore the dynamics and development of democracy and citizenship in significant physical urban spaces in the cities of Mexico City, São Paulo, Santiago, Lima, Bogotá, Caracas, Buenos Aires, Havana and Santo Domingo. These well-assembled studies provide the reader with the opportunity to compare these cities with similar cultural and political trajectories on the common premise that urban spaces can be envisioned as a palimpsest of historical layers where significant history-making events consolidate or transform them.
The historical evolution of public space and the public sphere related to the extraordinary political or social events that have transformed them is encountered in the analysis of open spaces in Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Colombia and Peru in the first part of the book. Tamayo and Xóchitl Cruz-Guzmán's study of the Zócalo – the main square in Mexico City – explores the political and social impact of the 2000 electoral campaign and the Zapatista March of 2001 on this urban landmark, reinforcing the concept that political appropriation is an essential condition for the construction of the public sphere. An excellent reflection on how urban space is intimately related to the exercise of democracy is found in Zeuler R. Lima and Vera M. Pallamin's discussion of Trianon Terrace – a plaza beneath the emblematic Museum of Art in São Paulo – and the Avenida Paulista. The authors examine these urban spaces through an understanding that the genealogy of their meaning is intertwined with the genealogy of conflicts, and conclude that the struggle over collective urban spaces is a fundamental element for the advancement and spatialisation of democracy. Despite almost complete physical transformation and functional changes, public spaces maintain their role as collective urban spaces if the collective memory, identity and spatial representation of their city's history are alive in them. Rodrigo Vidal and Hans Fox's study of the Plaza of the Central Station in Santiago and Alberto Saldarriaga's chapter on the Plaza Bolivar in Bogotá confirm this with a historical overview of the meaning and use of these principal ordering elements of their respective cities' built environment. Along the same lines, but broadening the focus to Lima's historic centre, Miriam Chion and Wiley Ludeña Urquizo explore this significant place with a central role in both local and national history as a ‘spatial capital’, a novel concept that recognises the impact of the significant cultural-political events that have taken place in the area as well as the quality of the sites' physical setting. This concept enforces the vision that historic centres not only serve as a window on history as a deteriorated museum artefact, but also create history.
The second part of the book includes another set of profound contributions that scrutinise how places of identity can define the aesthetic of a city and the imagination of a nation. In a region of economies undergoing structural transformations that are accentuating social and spatial polarisation, the chosen examples of appropriations and representations of public space by different groups through social, cultural or political struggles clearly illustrate the creation of new forms and ideas of citizenship and nationhood. Clara Irazábal and John Foley analyse in depth the influence of political events on the role of urban space and architecture prior to and during the April 2002 coup d'état and 2004 referendum in Caracas. The authors celebrate the way in which these political encounters enhanced public spaces and challenged the construction of history. The essay is an eye-opener to the ongoing processes of reterritorialisation and deterritorialisation of the street and public spaces in Latin America.
Human rights struggles and forms of participation over the last three decades in public spaces in Argentina are the common thread in Susana Kaiser's study. The essay reaches the interesting conclusion that social movements have defined a new style of demonstration and use of the public places of Buenos Aires in which streets – traditionally seen as elements of ordinary public space – are transformed by these national events. The relationship between public space, social life and ideology is examined by Roberto Segre in the city of Havana and Alexander González in Santo Domingo. Both authors coincide in their expression of the need for a new collective memory and new urban spaces to replace, in the case of Havana, the fading of the ideological euphoria that constructed the streets and plazas of the Cuban Revolution, and in Santo Domingo the decades of controls on public behaviour and the absence of a collective history during Trujillo's dictatorship. These studies demonstrate the undeniable need for an interdisciplinary approach in order to reach a profound understanding and design of public spaces.
This book establishes the rarely studied link between physical public spaces and the construction of citizenship and democracy as a two-way road where the transformation and use of space brings about a transformation in power, knowledge and subjectivities. Due to its diverse theoretical perspectives and case studies it is a useful book not only for architects, urban designers and planners but also for those with an interest in politics, culture and Latin American studies.
