For almost 20 years, Israel Gershoni and James Jankowski have been collaborating on the theme of nationalism. They have cowritten two books on the development of Egyptian nationalism and coedited a book on Arab nationalism. Their latest joint endeavor is yet another exploration of modern Egyptian history. This time they employ the lens of memory studies, the field that explores how historical memory is continually reshaped for each generation by such forces as holidays, museums, state funerals, works of art, academic analysis, and newspapers.
The problem that Gershoni and Jankowski set for themselves is the analysis of how the meaning and significance of several icons of the Egyptian nationalist movement have been reinterpreted over time. They examine the evolution of the public commemoration of six major symbols of Egyptian nationalism: three of Mahmud Mukhtar's monumental sculptures, the nationalist heroes Mustafa Kamil and Muhammad Farid, and the July Revolution.
The results of the study are illuminating. The authors demonstrate that, from the very beginning, deep controversy embroiled the unveiling of all three of Mukhtar's most famous sculptures—Nahdat Misr and the statues of Sa

d Zaghlul in Alexandria and Cairo—and that their significance is still in dispute among Egyptians. The most intriguing section is their exploration of the eventual fate of Nahdat Misr. By the end of World War II, a consensus had emerged among intellectuals of various political persuasions that the statue was no longer an adequate expression of the Egyptian national revival. The revolution of 1952 sealed this verdict, and in 1955 the new government moved the statue from its high-profile location in Railway Station Square to its present site near the campus of Cairo University. It was replaced by the gigantic statue of Ramses II that still stands there, and the square was renamed Maydan Ramsis. The action continues to perplex analysts: a regime that sought popular support replaced a statue that exalted the nation as a whole with one that would have served well as the inspiration for Shelley's “Ozymandias.”
Kamil (1874–1908) and Farid (1868–1919) were among Egypt's best known and most revered public figures in the early 20th century. Their huge, public funerals were the prototypes for future memorials to fallen national heroes. Their followers' attempts to erect memorials in their memory, however, were stymied for decades due to British repression and jealousies among Egyptian political parties. Gershoni and Jankowski demonstrate how quickly Kamil and Farid disappeared from public awareness until

Abd al-Rahman al-Rafi

i almost single-handedly rehabilitated their image during the 1930s through his series on modern Egyptian history. In 1953, the Free Officers sponsored two huge funerals to rebury both men in the mausoleum that had been built for the purpose by the despised ancien regime. By doing so, the new government deflected attention away from the monarchy that it would soon abolish, and it simultaneously associated itself with the spirit of these heroes' nationalist struggle. The authors also shed considerable light on the evolution of the Egyptian national holiday. During Nasser's presidency, 23 July was the occasion for the government to inspire and instruct the nation on the meaning of its past and its vision for the future. Even in the Nasser period, however, the holiday took on different meanings. The period of the union with Syria, the malaise of the early 1960s, and the aftermath of the 1967 military debacle caused both the regime and the public to alter their interpretations of the holiday. After the October War, Sadat audaciously shifted the importance once given to 23 July to 6 October. Ignoring the loss of a war and focusing on an opening-day victory, he transformed the entire set of values that the Nasser regime had stood for.
Commemorating the Nation is a book that any historian of modern Egypt can read with profit, and, if it is ever issued in paperback, it would be an outstanding choice for courses in historiography.
