Two recent works add to our understanding of the relationship between gender and theatre during the First Wave feminist era. Judith E. Barlow's Women Writers of the Provincetown Players: A Collection of Short Works is the most comprehensive collection to date of Provincetown plays by women (excepting collections devoted exclusively to Susan Glaspell). Of the thirty-five plays authored or coauthored by women for the Provincetown Players, Barlow has selected twelve short plays, one example from each female playwright who had a short play produced by the Players. Barlow provides a general introduction, placing the works within their historical and cultural context, as well as a brief introduction to each individual play that offers details on its authorship, production history, and critical reception, plus notes on the texts explaining minor distinctions among alternative published or typescript versions.
Space does not allow for summaries of all the plays, which represent a wide range of genres and styles but are united by their focus on female experience. Together, they offer some of the era's sharpest critiques of sexual and gender relations within the context of other topical issues including war, labor unrest, and the immigrant experience. Standouts include Neith Boyce's Winter's Night, which evokes Susan Glaspell's Trifles in its isolated, rural location and Eugene O'Neill's Beyond the Horizon in its depiction of a man's tortured desire for his brother's wife; Susan Glaspell's Woman's Honor, which integrates allegory and satire to expose the absurdity of masculine “chivalry” (read “chauvinism”); Alice L. Rostetter's delightfully subversive The Widow's Veil, which portrays a hopeful would-be widow's disappointment at her ailing husband's unexpected recovery; Edna St. Vincent Millay's Aria da Capo, an antiwar fable ironically and metatheatrically visualized as a Harlequinade; and Djuna Barnes's whimsical Kurzy of the Sea, set in her inimically imagined Irish universe and depicting an encounter between a dimwitted, moony lad and the free-spirited mer/barmaid who jolts him into reality. The remaining plays include Louise Bryant's The Game, Rita Wellman's The Rib-Person, Rita Creighton Smith's The Rescue, Edna Ferber's The Eldest, Bosworth Crocker's The Baby Carriage, Mary Foster Barber's The Squealer, and Mary Carolyn Davies's The Slave with Two Faces.
The historical significance of this collection is greatly enhanced by the inclusion, in an appendix, of Rita Wellman's The Horrors of War, which Barlow, in a master coup of detective work, discovered at the Library of Congress, copyrighted in 1915 under the pseudonym Rita Leo. All existing evidence supports Barlow's conviction that The Horrors of War is “without doubt an early version of Barbarians, staged by the Players in 1917” (6–7). Evoking both Shaw's Arms and the Man and Chekhov's The Three Sisters, and critiquing gender roles as well as wartime nationalist propaganda, Wellman's comedy features three sisters who anticipate the impending invasion of enemy soldiers (“barbarians”) with anything but fear. This intriguing baker's dozen of plays supports the author's argument that “Several of these plays remain stageworthy today, and all are important literary, cultural, and social documents that fuse theatrical originality with contemporary concerns” (12). Although a number of other scholars have offered summaries and brief critical comments, few of these plays have been readily available (out of print, unpublished, or lost). This new edition, which includes three previously unpublished works, is therefore especially welcome and is sure to spark further scholarship.
The feminist dramaturgy of Provincetown's women playwrights is one of five topics addressed in Pamela Cobrin's From Winning the Vote to Directing on Broadway: The Emergence of Women on the New York Stage, 1880–1927, which examines how “[w]omen at the turn of the twentieth century, finding themselves at a turning point of self-definition, used performance as a means to radically disrupt the status quo, both intentionally and unwittingly” (13). Cobrin locates a wide range of theatrical and theatricalized performances by women along a feminist-theatre continuum, from the “explicit feminist performance” of suffrage parades, in Chapter 1, to the “implicit feminist performance” (19) of mainstream women stage directors examined in her final chapter.
Cobrin's first chapter reveals how suffragist attitudes changed from Victorian aversion to “‘parading ourselves’” (23) as an undignified display, to full exploitation of elaborately staged, public performance as a rhetorical strategy. Her second chapter, on the Gamut Club, whose activities during its heyday (1913–20) encompassed antiwar marches, feminist lectures, and the presentation of suffrage and other feminist plays, examines important yet largely neglected performance genres. The evolution of suffrage performance is a fascinating and vivid illustration of at least one aspect of “true” womanhood transitioning into “new” womanhood, and Cobrin's conclusion that the Gamut Club, led by actress-playwright-activist Mary Shaw, “deserves a respected place” (92) within both the women's movement and theatre history seems amply justified.
As Cobrin acknowledges, the relationship between First Wave feminism and the Provincetown Players, the subject of her third chapter, has been discussed in a number of recent works. Her point, however, that this organization is “impossible to ignore when considering feminist performance of this time” (96) is well taken, and its inclusion seems crucial in juxtaposition to the other, interestingly related performance genres. I must admit, however, I found Cobrin's characterization of a few of the plays mystifying, such as her identification of Djuna Barnes's droll revelation of pragmatic adultery, An Irish Triangle, as “the story about two women's struggle with independence and the need for love” (119).
Chapter 4 explores the feminist impact of the female-led Neighborhood Playhouse (fl. 1915–20), which presented perhaps the widest range of performance genres among the groups surveyed. Originating in the Henry Street Settlement, where “the feminine art of maternal domesticity was merged with socialist political beliefs” (125) and funded by philanthropists Alice and Irene Lewisohn with the primary aim of bringing artistic expression to the Lower East Side, Playhouse performances included ritual cycles, folk dances, nōh drama, puppetry, and the New York premiere of Angelina Weld Grimké's antilynching drama Rachel. More overtly political performances from its female leadership include marching in a suffragist parade and sponsoring benefits for the Women's Trade Union and the Women's Suffrage Party. Initially dedicated to collectivity, in 1920 the Playhouse decided to professionalize the theatre, a decision Cobrin marks as leading to an increasingly hierarchical and sexist practice and to the decline of the company's influence as a feminist organization (154–5).
Cobrin's fifth chapter reveals the unwitting feminist impact of the careers of four women who directed professionally during this era: Rachel Crothers, Lillian Trimble Bradley, Edith Ellis, and Minnie Maddern Fiske. Despite their ambivalent attitudes toward feminism and lack of expressed political aims, their impact arises from the extensive attention the press gave to their gender in reviewing their productions, a practice that highlights how subversive and potentially transformational the mere presence of a woman in power was at this time.
Cobrin's noteworthy and engaging study is slightly marred by a considerable number of errors and copyediting oversights. For example, Cobrin credits Edith Ellis with coining the term “directress” (158), which has been in use since at least the mid-nineteenth century (to describe women like Laura Keene, for example). The Provincetown Players was created in 1915, not 1914 (93); Aline Bernstein was not a Provincetown designer (94); Susan Glaspell's The People was first produced by the Provincetown Players, not the Neighborhood Playhouse (149); the author of Salvation Nell is Edward Sheldon, not Ibsen (172). The book also contains a puzzling number of spelling errors throughout and incorrect or partial book titles in the notes and bibliography.
