There is an old joke about having kids. Parents who have just one child are absolutely convinced that it is they who are making all of the running in the development of that child – happy or sad, confident or shy, bright or dull. Parents who have two or more children are absolutely convinced that they have no role whatsoever in the development of the child. Some kids are happy by nature, some sad; some kids are confident by nature, some shy; some kids are bright and alert by nature, some dull and uninterested.
So who is right? Is what we are a matter of our nurture, of our environment and of the things and people that surround us as we grow up? Or is it a matter of our nature, our genes, that determines pretty much everything that we become, in thought and action? The joke seems to imply that it is truly nature. But is this really so? The historian of science Frank Sulloway argues that birth order is the determining factor. The oldest child tends to strive, to be a conformist, to work hard all day long. The second child tends to be more of a non-conformist, resisting authority and instructions, more likely to laze and let life pass by. Yet the second child is often the one who is truly creative.
There is surely truth to this. I am an oldest child, with all of the retentive features predicted. My sister is a second child, with still a bit of a chip on her shoulder at not being first, and inclined to push against authority. I would only add the third child (my wife!), who is happy as the day is long, glad to be out of the conflict between first and second. So it seems that it is really all nurture. But obviously this cannot be so. If we were radishes rather than humans I doubt very much whether it would matter if we were seeded first, second or third.
Perhaps we should give up the whole debate about nature and nurture and I think that this is really what the distinguished historian of science Evelyn Fox Keller would like us to do. In her spritely little book The Mirage of a Space between Nature and Nurture she takes apart systematically just about all of the attempts to make sense of the distinction. It is not just that she thinks that we often make some pretty fundamental mistakes on the topic, although we certainly do that. (She makes much of the fact that often we confuse the heritability of a trait – humans versus radishes – as such with the heritability of differences between possessors of the trait – me versus my sister or wife.) But somehow she feels that the distinction is fundamentally confused in the first place.
Obviously underlying much of her concern are the moral issues. Fox Keller mentions the notorious comments by the sometime president of Harvard University Larry Summers about the possibility of women being simply not biologically up to mathematics and the like. It is pretty obvious that this was not simply a gender-neutral observation about abilities but a moral or social statement about the natural order and rightfulness of things. I am not sure, however, that Fox Keller is quite as disinterested about issues of these sorts as she might be. Take sexual orientation, for instance. A good case can be made for the claim that finding sexual orientation to be more a matter of nature than of nurture has good moral consequences. There is little point in kicking a teacher out of a classroom on the grounds that he or she might influence the children unduly. (Although going the other way and showing the complexities that thread through the whole issue, a case could be made that if orientation is biological then perhaps one could practice prenatal testing and selective abortion.)
Often the only way that difficult problems get solved is if people give up through exhaustion – Northern Ireland is perhaps an instance of this – or if new technology makes the old squabbles otiose – as soon as the pill came along, the debate about contraception was pretty much over. I think this is basically Fox Keller's position on the nature–nurture debate. With the advent of molecular biology, and particularly with the new field of evolutionary development (evo-devo), we are learning so much more than we ever knew before about the interactions of the genes – specifically the DNA molecules – and the environment during the growth of organisms. It is so complex (and interesting) that old categories like ‘nature’ and ‘nurture’ seem just too crude to capture what is going on. Perhaps a hundred years from now people will look back on the debate as being as distant and unimportant as we today consider debates about the importance of empire or the plausibility of spiritualism. If so, Evelyn Fox Keller's excellent little book will deserve credit for its role in making this mind-change.
