Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T19:31:53.669Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Effect of thermal fluctuations on spectra and predictability in compressible decaying isotropic turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 May 2024

Qihan Ma
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautic Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Chunxin Yang
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautic Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Song Chen
Affiliation:
Sino-French Engineer School/School of General Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Kaikai Feng
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautic Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Ziqi Cui
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautic Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Jun Zhang*
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautic Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: jun.zhang@buaa.edu.cn

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of molecular thermal fluctuations on compressible decaying isotropic turbulence using the unified stochastic particle (USP) method, encompassing both two-dimensional (2-D) and three-dimensional (3-D) scenarios. The findings reveal that the turbulent spectra of velocity and thermodynamic variables follow the wavenumber (k) scaling law of ${k}^{(d-1)}$ for different spatial dimensions $d$ within the high wavenumber range, indicating the impact of thermal fluctuations on small-scale turbulent statistics. With the application of Helmholtz decomposition, it is found that the thermal fluctuation spectra of solenoidal and compressible velocity components (${\boldsymbol {u}}_{s}$ and ${\boldsymbol {u}}_{c}$) follow an energy ratio of 1 : 1 for 2-D cases, while the ratio changes to 2 : 1 for 3-D cases. Comparisons between 3-D turbulent spectra obtained through USP simulations and direct numerical simulations of the Navier–Stokes equations demonstrate that thermal fluctuations dominate the spectra at length scales comparable to the Kolmogorov length scale. Additionally, the effect of thermal fluctuations on the spectrum of ${\boldsymbol {u}}_{c}$ is significantly influenced by variations in the turbulent Mach number. We further study the impact of thermal fluctuations on the predictability of turbulence. With initial differences caused by thermal fluctuations, different flow realizations display significant disparities in velocity and thermodynamic fields at larger scales after a certain period of time, which can be characterized by ‘inverse error cascades’. Moreover, the results suggest a strong correlation between the predictabilities of thermodynamic fields and the predictability of ${\boldsymbol {u}}_{c}$.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch (in wavenumber space) showing the decomposition of the fluctuating velocity field ${{\boldsymbol {u}}_{k}}=( {{u}_{k,i}} )$ into the solenoidal component ${{\boldsymbol {u}}_{sk}}$ and the compressible component ${{\boldsymbol {u}}_{ck}}$, for 2-D (a) and 3-D (b) cases. In (b), ${{\boldsymbol {u}}_{sk}}$ lies in the plane $G$, which is perpendicular to $\boldsymbol {k}$.

Figure 1

Table 1.Simulated parameters for 2-D decaying isotropic turbulence. All the simulations are performed with the initial conditions of ${{T}_{0}}=300\,\textrm {K}$, ${{P}_{0}}=1\,\textrm {bar}$, ${{M}_{t0}}=1$ and $R{{e}_{\lambda 0}}=23.4$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Energy spectra $E(k)$ and thermodynamic spectra (${{E}_{T}}(k)$, ${{E}_{n}}(k)$, ${{E}_{P}}(k)$) of 2-D decaying turbulence at $t=7.3{T}_{e0}$ (a,c,e,g) and $t=21.8{T}_{e0}$ (b,d,f,h). The spectra of thermal fluctuations calculated from (2.11) and (2.12) are also displayed with $F$ = 1549.

Figure 3

Figure 3.(a) Two-dimensional energy spectra for the velocity field and its two components obtained by DSMC and USP ($1024^2$) at $t=7.3{T}_{e0}$. The theoretical spectrum of thermal fluctuations is also displayed with $F = 1549$. (b) Two-dimensional energy spectra for the velocity field and its two components obtained by DNS and USP ($1024^2$) at $t=7.3{T}_{e0}$.

Figure 4

Table 2.The USP simulation parameters for 3-D decaying isotropic turbulence. All the simulations are performed with the initial conditions of ${{T}_{0}}=273.15\,\textrm {K}$ and ${{P}_{0}}=1\,\textrm {bar}$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Time evolution of (a) normalized turbulent kinetic energy, and (b) normalized mean square value of pressure fluctuations, for the case with $R{{e}_{\lambda 0}}= 103.3$ and ${{M}_{t0}}= 0.9$.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Panels (a–c) display the time evolutions of normalized turbulent kinetic energy, normalized mean square pressure fluctuations and turbulent Mach number, respectively. Panel (d) displays the PDFs of the local Mach number at $t=1.4{{T}_{e0}}$. All the USP results are obtained based on the short-time average flow field without thermal fluctuations.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Energy spectra for the velocity field and its two components obtained from USP and DNS simulations at $t=1.4{{T}_{e0}}$, for the case of $R{{e}_{\lambda 0}}= 103.3$ and ${{M}_{t0}}= 0.9$. The inset shows the relationship between $E(k)$, ${{E}_{c}}(k)$ and ${{E}_{s}}(k)$ obtained from USP simulations at large wavenumbers.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Values of $E(k)$ (a), ${{E}_{s}}(k)$ (b) and ${{E}_{c}}(k)$ (c) obtained from USP and DNS simulations at $t=1.4{{T}_{e0}}$, for cases with different ${{M}_{t0}}$. The thermal fluctuation spectra with $F$ = 1 are also shown for comparison. The insets are the enlarged views showing the intersection points between thermal fluctuation spectra and DNS spectra (i.e. the cross-over wavenumbers for the real gases).

Figure 9

Figure 8.Values of ${{E}_{T}}(k)$ (a), ${{E}_{n}}(k)$ (b) and ${{E}_{P}}(k)$ (c) obtained from USP and DNS simulations at $t=1.4{{T}_{e0}}$, for cases with different ${{M}_{t0}}$. The thermal fluctuation spectra with $F = 1$ are also shown for comparison. The insets are the enlarged views showing the intersection points between thermal fluctuation spectra and DNS spectra (i.e. the cross-over wavenumbers for the real gases).

Figure 10

Figure 9.Normalized USP spectra of the compressible velocity component, solenoidal velocity component, number density, temperature and pressure at $t=1.4{{T}_{e0}}$, for cases with ${{M}_{t0}}=0.6$ (a) and ${{M}_{t0}}=0.9$ (b).

Figure 11

Table 3.The USP simulation parameters for the study of turbulence predictability.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Temporal evolution of the vorticity field for 2-D decaying turbulence with $R{{e}_{0}}=1590$ and ${{M}_{t0}}=1$. Panels (a–c) and (d–f) correspond to two realizations. The contours are plotted based on coarse-grained cells with a lower resolution (${N}_{g}^{2}$).

Figure 13

Figure 11.Temporal evolution of the velocity field for 3-D decaying turbulence with $R{{e}_{0}}=954$ and ${{M}_{t0}}=1.2$. Panels (a–c) and (d–f) correspond to two realizations. The contours are plotted based on coarse-grained cells with a lower resolution (${N}_{g}^{3}$).

Figure 14

Figure 12.Energy spectra of the original velocity field and the error velocity field at different time points, for 2-D case with $R{{e}_{0}}=1590$ (a) and 3-D case with $R{{e}_{0}}=954$ (b).

Figure 15

Table 4.Ratios of different length scales for the 2-D case presented in figure 12(a). Here, ${\eta }_{\varOmega }$, ${\lambda }$ and ${l}_{c,err}$ represent the enstrophy dissipation length scale, molecular mean free path and cross-over length scale for ${{E}_{err}}$, respectively.

Figure 16

Table 5.Ratios of different length scales for the 3-D case presented in figure 12(b). Here, ${\eta }$, ${\lambda }$ and ${l}_{c,err}$ represent the Kolmogorov length scale, molecular mean free path and cross-over length scale for ${{E}_{err}}$, respectively.

Figure 17

Figure 13.(a) Displays the temporal evolution of error kinetic energy $K_{error}$ and thermal fluctuation energy ${{K}^{th}}$ for 2-D cases with different $Re_{0}$, and (b) displays the corresponding results of relative error energy $r={{{K}_{error}}}/{K}$. The $y$-axis of the figure is plotted on a logarithmic scale.

Figure 18

Figure 14.Energy spectra of the original velocity field and the error velocity field at $t=27T_{e0}$, for the 2-D cases with different $Re_0$.

Figure 19

Figure 15.Spectra of the original temperature field and the error temperature field at different time points, for 2-D case with $R{{e}_{0}}=1590$ (a) and 3-D case with $R{{e}_{0}}=954$ (b).

Figure 20

Figure 16.Temperature, number density and pressure fields for 2-D decaying turbulence with $R{{e}_{0}}=1590$ and ${{M}_{t0}}=1$, at $t=34.6{{T}_{e0}}$. Panels (a–c) and (d–f) correspond to two realizations.

Figure 21

Figure 17.Temperature, number density and pressure fields for 3-D decaying turbulence with $R{{e}_{0}}=954$ and ${{M}_{t0}}=1.2$, at $t=16.9{{T}_{e0}}$. Panels (a–c) and (d–f) correspond to two realizations.

Figure 22

Figure 18.(a) Normalized error spectra of compressible velocity component, solenoidal velocity component, temperature, number density and pressure for 2-D decaying turbulence ($R{{e}_{0}}=954$) at $t=34.6{{T}_{e0}}$. (b) The error spectra corresponding to the 3-D decaying turbulence at $t = 16.9{{T}_{e0}}$.