Inasmuch as neither Turco-Mongolian nor Islamic traditions offered firm rules for political succession, the empire created by Temür (Tamerlane) (r. 1370–1405) figured as a prize to be fought over or carved up when the great nomad conqueror died leading his army to attack Ming China. Shahrukh (r. 1409–47) was fortunate in that his rivals, his brother Amiranshah and Temür's several grandsons, were reckless and incompetent. Exhausting themselves by infighting and battling nomad powers of the region (the Jalayir and Qaraqoyunlo Turkmen), they left the way clear for Shahrukh to consolidate power at the age of twenty-seven and to rule for the next forty years. In Power, Politics and Religion in Timurid Iran, Beatrice Forbes Manz analyzes the political, military, and religious foundations of Shahrukh's reign. As in her earlier work, The Rise and Rule of Tamerlane (1989), the focus is on exhaustive analysis, not the romance of empire and conquest.
In her account, the founder of the Timurid dynasty bears little resemblance to Christopher Marlowe's Tamburlaine the Great (c. 1587), the demonic hero whose “looks do menace heaven and dare the gods.” A cautious ruler, Shahrukh did not have his father's talent or zeal for battle; he was far more interested in cultural patronage. As a result, he recedes even further than did Temür into the background of Manz's work. What the latter lacks in color and drama, however, is compensated by shrewd judgment and meticulous detail. Manz has mined all available sources, which are “fragmentary, repetitious and tendentious” (p. 49), with consummate skill. The result is a book that is essential reading for all students of medieval and early modern Islamic societies.
Manz intends to answer two questions: “How did a society with diffuse power structures and few legal corporate entities remain stable despite frequent breakdowns of order? How could a government without the monopoly of force control a large and heterogeneous society over wide territories?” (p. 276). Her answers are subtle and perceptive, even counterintuitive: stability arose from the multiple affiliations and conflicting allegiances that comprised the kingdom; central government exerted itself through working within and manipulating the shifting factions that shared power. In short, what at first glance looks like inherent weakness—dispersed power in a large, diverse society—turns out to be a strength, even providing the basis for a post-Timurid dynasty to create a cohesive state after the succession struggles that followed the death of Shahrukh.
According to Manz, no sharp lines set off major social groups—urban notables, government ministers, amirs, shaykhs, and ʿulamaʾ. City authorities had links to central authority, viziers acted as military commanders, amirs married into municipal aristocracies, religious scholars collaborated with generals and bureaucrats, and Sufi sages discreetly gave counsel and comfort to politicians. Given the informality of institutions and the resulting uncertainty of individual power, all parties engaged in persistent efforts to reach across social and political barriers: “This was a society exceptionally active politically at many levels—from the artisans of the city to members of the dynasty” (p. 282). Contestants for central power relied on support from their own provinces while clever rulers aimed to combat centrifugal forces by adapting to the strategies of men who held regional power. Above all, “[t]owns from which the Timurids ruled their dominions were rather like an archipelago within a sea of semi-independent regions, over which control was a matter of luck, alliance and an occasional punitive expedition” (p. 2). One of the strengths of the book is Manz's demonstration of how crucial urban notables were to the general political scene, always ready to grasp their chance for an hour of glory in times of peril. How this local opportunism all played out in practice is nicely seen in Manz's case study of the political fortunes of the Marʿashi dynasty of the Manzandaran region, located at the southern border of the Caspian Sea (pp. 136–42).
Manz's emphasis throughout is straightforwardly political, and her method is dauntingly prosopographical. Her chapter on religious associations (“Political Dynamics of the Supernatural,” pp. 178–207) touches upon subjects of considerable intrinsic interest, such as Sufi lineages, the diversity of religious authority, supernatural powers seen in holy sites, and the charismatic authority of sultans. Her fascinating discussion of grave-visitation manuals suggests that the topic deserves a book of its own. These themes, however, are raised entirely in the context of explaining the internal political dynamics of the Timurid realm.
Manz's book, then, is directed to the specialist. This is evident from the chapter devoted to “Issues of Sources and Historiography” (pp. 49–78) as well as from the chapter on “Shahrukh's Diwan and its Personnel” (pp. 79–110). The following passage from the latter is typical: “In the next generation, we once more find Khwafi viziers in important positions. Pir Ahmad's son, Majd al-Din Muhammad, had a distinguished career and another member of the same family was known for his skill in jurisprudence and served as sadr: this was Mawlana Qutb al-Din Muhammad Khwafi, who served under both Sultan Abu Saʿid and Sultan Husayn. He is identified by Khwandamir as a member of the family of Majd al-Din Muhammad b. Pir Ahmad, who took charge of his funeral celebration” (p. 99). Page after page of this may tire even the most dedicated specialist. Further obstacles are placed in the way of the general reader inasmuch as Manz fails to define many key terms, such as ṣadr, ṭarīqa, khanaqa, and futuwwa, apparently confident that the context in which she uses the terms will supply the meanings. Such drawbacks will limit the purview of her book. This is unfortunate because Power, Politics and Religion in Timurid Iran, with its superlative, nuanced analysis of the compensating strengths and debilities of Shahrukh's reign, the delicate equipoise that the sovereign had to achieve between peace and war, central authority and local allegiance, and prosperity and disaster has considerable relevance for the understanding of other contemporary Eurasian regimes.
