In this methodologically, conceptually, and politically daring text, Tyrell Haberkorn analyses northern Thai farmers' struggles around land tenancy, between the 1950 failed implementation of the Land Rent Control Act (LRCA) and the silencing of farmers' and students' dissident voices, which culminated with the 6 October 1976 violence. The book is based on several years (2001–08) of field research in both Chiang Mai and Bangkok and mostly revolves around textual sources. Interviews — the traditional tool of inquiry for an anthropologist like Haberkorn — are present in the text as supplements to archival materials. Consistently with Haberkorn's position as an ‘activist scholar’, the book operates on two interlacing and mutually supportive registers: one scholarly oriented, the other motivated by activist concerns.
On the scholarship level, Haberkorn analyses, in the first three chapters of the book, the farmers' initial failure (1951) and later success (1974) in using the LRCA as a tool of struggle which posed both political and epistemological challenges to landowners' depictions of exploitative relations as benevolent patron–client interactions. In so doing, Haberkorn argues, the farmers emerged as subjects, not just objects, of the law and in collaborating with emerging student activists posed a revolutionary challenge to ‘the system of domination using its own terms and strategies’ (p. 51). Here resides the first major contribution of this book. Arguing that the farmers' revolutionary potential resides precisely in their adoption of the masters' tools — namely the law — and not the gun, the author expands scholarly conceptualisation of revolution and provides a compelling addition to critical peasant studies beyond prevalent categories of anti-state peasant revolts or ‘weapons of the weak’ forms of resistance.
To prove the ‘importance and revolutionary potential of the tenancy struggle’ (p. 114), Haberkorn dedicates the remaining chapters to exploring counterrevolutionary practices adopted after 1974 — most notably assassinations — and the often inconclusive investigations of these crimes. She presents them as ‘symptoms of crisis’ in the Gramscian sense, elites' responses to a state of siege. Challenged and cornered, reframed as greedy capitalists in judiciary courts and popular media, the landowners adopted, together with a variety of state actors, armed forces, and parastate groups, violent methods to interrupt the ongoing revolution: illegal means to keep the law at work. This paradox, she argues, expanded fragmentation and disunity inside the Thai state and created the condition for the erosion of the ‘boundary between law and extrajudicial violence’ (p. 131) which fully revealed itself in the 6 October 1976 massacre. In this analysis, the author offers her second major conceptual contribution. Building on Philip Abrams' theory of the state (‘Notes on the difficulty of studying the state’, Journal of Historical Sociology, 1, 1 [1988]: 15–21), Haberkorn reveals, through an extended analysis of the period between the killing of farmers' leader Intha Sribunruang in late July 1974 and the sacking of the Prime Minister Kukrit Pramoj's house by police officers on 19 August 1975, the Thai state was ‘a site, not only an actor, of the struggle’ (p. 131). In so doing, she offers an important reminder of the risks of adopting a monolithic conception of the state apparatus and the analytical mileage granted by a multi-vocal theory of state.
The merits of this book, however, do not just lie in its conceptual interventions. Parallel to this line of investigation, in fact, rests a more directly political project. Here the author sets out to remember, recount, and actualise the voices, stories, and violent ends of farmers' leaders who encountered death by hands that remain up-to-now unknown. Haberkorn retells and investigates these violent acts, which have been silenced by a vague and eerily familiar call to national reconciliation, with the purpose of not just breaking this silence but also of exploring the ‘conditions under which these things become unnamable and unspeakable’ (p. 153). Haberkorn applies the same approach — of searching for the conditions which create a failure and potentially configure a success — to the suppression of the farmers' and students' revolution. These apparently failed struggles are re-conceptualised as ‘interrupted revolutions’, a suspended yet resumable political and social practice. Here Haberkorn projects the historical into the contemporary and frames the present as a moment of suspension of revolution. In doing so, she opens a space for exploring the conditions under which the transformations of Thai political and social life may be resumed.
Reading Haberkorn's Revolution interrupted, one rests assured of the validity of the author's approach not just for intellectual inquiry but also for politically meaningful interventions. Following Haberkorn's thoroughly researched text, one hopes that her analysis is correct and, unleashed from a momentary impasse, the full revolutionary potential of Thai struggles for social equality may, once again, flourish.
