This book contains Miguel A. Badía Cabrera’s transcription of the full manuscript of the Scottish Enlightenment thinker and clergyman Robert Wallace’s essay, A Letter from a Moderate Freethinker to David Hume Esquire Concerning the Profession of the Clergy. The essay was composed in the 1740s in response to some remarks in David Hume’s “Of National Characters,” in which Hume controversially claims that the profession of the clergy fosters pride, pretence, hypocrisy, and similar vices. A few passages from the manuscript are quoted in Ernest Mossner’s Life of David Hume, but apart from that the essay has hitherto never been published, and scholars interested in it have had to make a visit to the Special Collections Department at the Edinburgh University Library. Thanks to Badía Cabrera this has now changed.
In a valuable 40-page introduction to the book, Badía Cabrera gives us both a commentary on Wallace’s main arguments in the essay, and some hard-to-come-by background information about the life and accomplishments of Wallace, who was regarded by his cultured Scottish contemporaries as a “first-magnitude star in the firmament of the Scottish Enlightenment” (1). Among other things, we learn that Wallace helped found the Rankenian Club at Edinburgh in the late 1710s, an early promoter of Enlightenment ideals in Scotland; that he collaborated in founding the Philosophical Society at Edinburgh in the 1730s, which later developed into the Royal Society of Edinburgh; and that in the 1740s he was Chaplain in Ordinary to King George II, Dean of the Royal Chapel, and Moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland.
Wallace is of interest to Hume scholars for several reasons. He was one of the few clergymen who supported Hume’s candidacy for the Chair of Moral Philosophy at Edinburgh University in 1745. He played a major role in blocking the attempts of Scottish clergymen to have Hume excommunicated from the Church of Scotland in the 1750s. He engaged Hume in a highly publicized controversy in the 1750s over the question of whether the ancient world was more populous than the modern one. And, of course, he authored what is perhaps the most elaborate response to Hume’s anti-clerical remarks in “Of National Characters,” which we now have published for the first time.
Wallace’s response to Hume is, in a nutshell, that Hume over-generalizes the vices of the clergy in a way that is not only unsupported by the available evidence, but also runs counter to it. Says Wallace: “Had you confined your satire to certain times & circumstances it had been more excusable /…/ But that they [the clergy] have been thus generally corrupted in all times, or that their Corruption in whatever Degree it has appeared has arisen from the generall [sic] nature of their Profession can by no means be admitted” (57). In his commentary on this passage, Badía Cabrera says that Wallace is here accusing Hume of committing the logical fallacy of inferring “All S is P” from “Some S is P” (25). If this is right, then Wallace seems to have seriously misread Hume, for in the relevant passages in “Of National Characters” (which Badía Cabrera has included in an appendix to the book) Hume is explicit in holding that “tho’ the Character of the Profession will not, in every Instance, prevail /…/ yet it is sure always to predominate with the greater Number” (83; emphasis added). But perhaps Badía Cabrera has read too much into Wallace’s criticism on this point; perhaps Wallace meant no more than that Hume exaggerates the vices of the clergy. Be this as it may, Wallace goes on to mount counter-evidence to Hume’s belief in the moral corruption of the clergy: “Have not we seen a great number of Protestant Clergy take a great deal of trouble to promote knowledge and an impartiall [sic] examination of all Doctrines & opinions, even the most sacred, and to banish implicit faith and pious frauds? ‘Tis [a] pity that we should not be more gratefull [sic]. Who were the Persons who had the chief hand in raising an extraordinary spirit for inquiring into naturall [sic] Philosophy as well as into the foundations of Divinity & Morality, towards the end of Oliver Cromwell’s life & immediately after the Restoration of Charles IId?” (68–69).
In spite of his high regard for Wallace’s essay, which shines through in many passages in his introduction to the book, Badía Cabrera does mount at least one serious objection to Wallace. Wallace, he says, “ignores Hume’s theory of moral causes, which must be addressed for an adequate rebuttal of his explanation about the genesis of eccesiastical evil” (24). This objection takes for granted that Hume’s anti-clericalism is grounded in Hume’s theory of moral causes, a claim Badía Cabrera unfortunately leaves unargued. Even if this assumption is correct, it is of course open to question whether a clergyman engaged in defending his profession against Hume’s adverse criticisms is really under any obligation to first master the underlying theory on which these criticisms rest in order to muster a legitimate defence.
