My relationship to the performing arts began as a dancer at the age of four, an actor at nine, and was combined with my love of martial arts when I was thirteen. Although the only one of these disciplines I continue to practice is martial arts, I have spent the past thirty-odd years as a professional dramaturg whose primary interest is how meaning is generated in performance. For all these reasons I was excited to read Stanton B. Garner Jr.'s book Kinesthetic Spectatorship in the Theatre: Phenomenology, Cognition, Movement. It does not disappoint.
This closely argued book is about “movement and movement perception: about the centrality of movement to human life and the embeddedness of theatre in this sensorimotor reality” (1). Garner's reach is broad, drawing upon “phenomenology, cognitive science, neuroscience, acting theory, dance theory, philosophy of mind, and linguistics” as he develops the insight that “one of the ways we apprehend the movements of others is by vicariously enacting these movements at pre-conscious and conscious levels” (1). For Garner this process is a function of kinesthetic empathy. Here he makes a clear distinction between kinesthesia—our personal experience of our movements and the sensations they generate—and kinetics—movement and/or motion as an objectively observed phenomenon. In the theatre, language is a kinesthetic phenomenon. As Garner puts it, “embodied utterance is gestural . . . theatrical speech foregrounds its corporeal delivery in ways that underscore its kinetic and kinesthetic foundations” (7). As he points out, the kinetic and kinesthetic qualities of theatre have been less often studied because the predominance of realism in Western theatre has made them more difficult to see than in highly physicalized theatre forms.
This book joins a dialogue between phenomenology and cognitive sciences in which each has traditionally seen the other as naive or empirically unsound. In contrast, Garner sees cognitive sciences and phenomenology as “natural collaborators in the investigation of experience” (17). Proceeding accumulatively through an introduction and six unnumbered chapters, he seeks to “situate empirical models of sensorimotor cognition within the phenomenological dynamics of movement and movement perception” (24). The first chapter, “Movement and Animation,” establishes the fundamentals of self-movement and external movement perception; the next, “Movement, Difference, and Ability,” treats theoretical and methodological aspects of the phenomenological study of movement while positing different ways to approach categories such as normality and difference. The third chapter, “Movement, Attention, and Intentionality,” explores the dynamics of attention and intentionality with regard to kinesthetic spectatorship, whereas the chapter on “Kinesthetic Resonance” looks at how we engage vicariously with others’ movements. The last two chapters, “Language, Speech, and Movement” and “Empathy and Otherness,” respectively explore how the kinesthetic exchange between spectators and actors is shaped by language and its verbal performance, and examine how empathy is produced from a sensorimotor and kinesthetic point of view.
Throughout the book Garner largely eschews both academic and scientific jargon as he deftly moves among disciplines, drawing upon theatre practitioners such as Jean-Louis Barrault and Jacques Lecoq, as well as a wide variety of phenomenologists, scientists, and artists such as Edmund Husserl, Carrie Noland, Hans-Thies Lehmann, Wanda Strukus, Wordsworth, Tillie Olsen, Shakespeare, Beckett, and Pinter to establish his points.
Although the book is grounded in Garner's comprehension of theory and science, his clarity as he applies that knowledge to performer–spectator interchanges in an expansive array of performances and performative events is the volume's true contribution to the field. These include Sandglass Theater's 2017 production of D-Generation, which explores dementia using both puppets and human performers; the texts of Shakespeare's The Winter's Tale and King Lear; Beckett's own production of Footfalls with Billie Whitelaw; AXIS Dance Company's choreography, which showcases a mixture of differently abled bodies; Ivo van Hove's production of A View from the Bridge on Broadway; the performance art of Stelarc, Robert Wilson, and Cathy Weis; Deaf West's production of Spring Awakening; Simon McBurney's The Encounter; and Sam Gold's controversial Broadway production of The Glass Menagerie, among others. Perhaps the most effective applications of theory to practice are Garner's discussions of Anna Deavere Smith's work and her contention that her performance practice is one of “reaching for the other” rather than “becoming the other” in a Stanislavskian manner (247), and Proteus Theatre Company's Merrick, The Elephant Man, a production that sought on many levels, through a multiplicity of movement strategies, to embody the figure of Merrick rather than exploit it, as the well-known Broadway play does.
Throughout Kinesthetic Spectatorship in the Theatre Garner develops two seemingly incompatible ideas: that our spectatorial experiences of movement in the theatre share commonalities of structure and point us to shared futures, and that those experiences are simultaneously highly individual and never identical. For Garner phenomenology is the means by which to resolve this conundrum, as it allows us “to identify the shared variables that render difference and individuality conceivable” (27). His deft descriptions of how this operates in a series of experiences of kinesthetic spectatorship in the theatre give us valuable insight into how meaning is created in each instance. My one quibble with the book is its rather abrupt ending, which leaves the reader with a lack of closure. But perhaps Jacques Lecoq's contention that “everything moves” (36) comes into play here, as the preconscious and conscious kinesthetic experience of reading Garner's book leads us to get up and move.
