“No volcano in the world blazes as much as she does,” Benjamin Constant once said about his friend Germaine de Staël (1766–1817). “If she knew how to govern herself, she would have ruled over the entire world.” He could hardly have been more on the mark. Staël was a larger-than-life character who had strong admirers, critics, and enemies. A Protestant in a Catholic country, born into a distinguished Genevan bourgeois family, she had major literary and political ambitions. She witnessed the early phases of the French Revolution before leaving France in early 1793, thus avoiding the Terror. The postrevolutionary republican regime viewed her with skepticism and she fought hard to have her French citizenship recognized in 1796. She was denounced by some as a shrewd political operator attempting to bring to power her own friends; others saw her as a disguised friend of the aristocrats conspiring against the legacy of the revolution. After 1799, Staël became a staunch critic of Napoleon and her salon at Coppet in Switzerland turned into a major center of opposition to the First Consult and, later, Emperor.
Any reader of Staël's political works will find in her writings a strong commitment to a few key principles and values which define her vision, at the heart of which lie the concepts of political moderation and the liberty of the moderns. She fully deserves her place in the pantheon of liberal thought for her original contributions to our understanding of representative government. And yet, for all the remarkable renaissance of interest in French liberalism (Montesquieu, Constant, Guizot, and Tocqueville) in the last three decades in the English-speaking world, Staël's political writings have been overlooked or underestimated, even if her prodigious personal life and literary contributions have not gone unnoticed, especially in feminist circles. When I began editing a new edition of her masterpiece, Considerations on the Principal Events of the French Revolution (published by Liberty Fund in 2008), none of her political works was available in English at that moment. This explains in part why she has remained an exotic figure among political theorists, better known for her tempestuous relationship with Constant than for her own theoretical contributions to the development of political liberalism.
Biancamaria Fontana, a historian of modern political thought at the University of Lausanne, who has previously worked on Constant, Montaigne, and the Edinburgh Review and has translated into English Constant's political writings, has now written a learned and timely book that attempts to redress this regrettable oversight. Her interpretation of Staël takes a close look at most (though not all) of her political writings and makes a persuasive case for why students of modern political thought should read these works. Even if some of the writings analyzed here are circumstantial or unfinished, they help us understand Staël's complex personality as well as the challenges she faced in trying to form a political center in dark times.
Organized around Staël's most important political texts from her early essays on the opinion of the nation and the reflections on peace to Of Present Circumstances and Considerations on the Principal Events of the French Revolution, Fontana's book sheds light on the relevant theses of these writings, which are placed in their historical context. She invites the reader to follow Staël's intellectual and political trajectory, which intersected with that of her father, Jacques Necker, and many brilliant friends. Thus we get to follow her from the early stages of the Revolution through her experience of the Terror and her tribulations during the Directory, to her exile during the First Empire, her return to Paris in 1814, and her last days. Fontana does a particularly good job at analyzing Staël's early views on interpreting the opinion of the majority of the nation, her reflections on the cruel fate of Marie Antoinette (in her thirty-page text entitled Reflections on the Trial of the Queen, which came out anonymously in September 1793), and her dialogue with William Pitt in Reflections on Peace Addressed to Mr. Pitt and to the French. In this latter text, she rejected political fanaticism and denounced the “chimerical system of equality” which had previously become a dangerous form of political religion in France. Staël's Reflections also called for the formation of a moderate party that, she hoped, would be able to build upon the principles of 1789, reject the Terror of 1793, and pave the way for peace at home and abroad.
This theme reappeared in an important subsequent essay, Reflections on the Internal Peace, written in the summer of 1795, but withdrawn from the press for prudential considerations. Fontana is right to devote an entire chapter (chap. 5) to this seminal text conceived as an attempt to influence the deliberations of the constitutional committee entrusted with the drafting of the constitution of 1795. She rightly insists that this was much more than a merely circumstantial work; it brilliantly displays Staël's skill at combining “a theoretical perspective with pressing practical considerations.” Along with Of Present Circumstances, a major unpublished manuscript (analyzed in chapter 7), described by some as “one of the most representative texts of republican constitutionalism,” it offers a lucid account of Staël's moderate and centrist political agenda articulated around such concepts as bicameralism, a strong executive power, and respect for private property. Fontana deftly comments on Staël's elevation of civil equality over political equality and her skepticism toward democracy, as evinced by her conservative form of republicanism. To these texts one could add a shorter one (not analyzed here), “Ideas on a Declaration of Rights,” that contains Staël's recommendations for a new declaration of the rights of man supposed to end the revolution.
Fontana also pays close attention to On the Influence of Passions on the Happiness of Individuals and Nations, a terrific book which Staël viewed as the true “testament” of her thought (unfortunately, the promised political part of the book was never written). A philosophical account of the causes of the most violent episodes of the French Revolution, the book emphasized the importance of political passions; it distinguished between destructive passions (which she wanted to combat) and moderate passions (which she wanted to promote). The last two chapters of Fontana's volume examine Staël's On Literature (1800), regarded here as a “belated anti-Burkean pamphlet,” and Considerations, interpreted as “the confident celebration of a hard-won future victory.” Staël's complex attitude to Napoleon is discussed along with what Fontana sees as the surprising affinities between Staël's vision of republican government and the Consular regime.
Stimulating and clearly written, Fontana's book invites the reader to dialogue and, like all good volumes, raises a few interesting questions which the author could consider for a future edition. It might have been useful to start with a brief discussion of Staël's first major book, Letters on the Works and Character of J.-J. Rousseau (1788). While she admired his literary works, especially Émile, Staël expressed reservation toward some of Rousseau's political ideas, which she briefly analyzed in the fourth chapter (she would engage again with Rousseau's ideas a decade later, in Of the Present Circumstances). Two other books, On Germany and Ten Years of Exile, might have also been addressed here since both carried an important political message and shed light on Staël's political and philosophical views (see, for example, her praise of enthusiasm at the end of On Germany). The reader might wonder about Staël's views on religion and the impact of Protestantism on her political views, under the influence of Necker's works. Staël's complex attitude toward the events of 18th Fructidor (1797) would also deserve some attention because it shows how difficult it was for postrevolutionary liberals to carve out a middle ground between revolution and reaction. Consider for example, an incomplete text, “Fragment on the Right of Initiative,” in which she defended granting the right to initiate laws to both the legislative and the executive power. Furthermore, Staël's selective reading of the past in Considerations would also be worth examining in further detail, both for her liberal ideas and subjective interpretation of key issues, characters, and episodes. Finally, Fontana's book might benefit from a stronger conclusion, which would be a good place to provide a final assessment of Staël's ideas today, compared, for example, to those of Constant (in Fragments abandonnés and the first edition of Principes de politique) and Sismondi (in Recherches sur les constitutions des peuples libres). They all belonged to the Coppet group, the “crucible” of French (and Swiss) liberalism, for which political moderation was a key concept.
To conclude, Fontana's book convincingly demonstrates why Staël deserves a prominent place in the history of modern political thought. One might even go further to claim that whoever neglects her political writings risks getting only a distorted and truncated view of the development of European liberalism, the prerequisites of liberty, and the institutional foundations of a free regime. Let's hope that this thoughtful book will be followed by other interpretations that will consolidate Staël's reputation as a first-rate political thinker.
