More than 40 years ago, Polly Hill called rural Hausaland ‘the unexplored territory’ of sub-Saharan Africa. Since then, anthropologists, geographers, sociologists, economists and others have studied rural Hausa society in detail, but aside from Hill's own distinguished corpus relatively few monographs have systematically surveyed rural society as such. Paul Clough's Morality and Economic Growth in Rural West Africa is therefore particularly welcome. The book is an empirically dense portrait of farmers living in a roadside hamlet called Marmara in the south of Nigeria's Katsina state. Clough's focus is on non-capitalist patterns of economic accumulation and growth; his book portrays the strategies of Marmara's farmers as they attempt to make better lives for themselves and their families. Like many others working on west African agrarian issues, Clough finds relatively little evidence of a widespread transition to agrarian capitalism.
In Marmara, land distribution is becoming more equal as land transfers tend to go from large holders to small holders rather than the reverse. Accordingly, there was no emergent landlord class or rural proletariat. Immigrants and especially young men were often landless, and many worked at least part time in agriculture as wage labourers. However, landlessness and wage work were not the harbingers of the formation of a discrete class of workers alienated from the means of production. Labour conditions were negotiated within well-established norms of moral obligation and reciprocity, which provide even the least powerful with socially recognised claims on their superiors. Arguing explicitly against Robert Shenton and more generally against the Marxist school of history based at Ahmadu Bello University, Clough suggests that villagers in Marmara are managing to maintain a genuine aloofness from spreading capitalist relations and their attendant disenfranchisement.
These findings are interesting, and they complement those of many other scholars, some Clough cites (such as Hill and Paul Ross) and some he ignores (like Christian Lund's account of the effects of institutional change on land disputes in Nigerien Hausaland). The book is, however, more than a useful addition to a gradually accumulating picture of land tenure and labour organisation among Hausa farmers across the past century. The richest and subtlest part of the book is Clough's account of credit, social consumption, trading and strategies for personal accumulation. Here too he demonstrates that the people he discusses are fully rational economic actors but that they are not solely focused on accumulating capital narrowly defined and putting it to economic use. The inhabitants of Marmara are most concerned with cultivating and maintaining friendships, kinship networks and marriages – a classic case of wealth figured in people rather than in things. People's credit-worthiness and ability to invoke broadly recognised moral norms depend on precisely these relationships. Three interlocking chapters describe credit institutions and how these intersect with households as units of social consumption and obligation, on Marmara's place in broader patterns of trade between regions, and on the careers of three exemplary figures. The result is a subtle and nuanced portrait of the ways in which Marmara's farmers organise their work lives and interact economically with the world.
Clough's ethnography is embedded in an awareness of broader patterns of historical change. His intensive fieldwork was in the late 1970s, and it was updated by further trips in 1985 and 1997–8. Much changed across those two decades – in the earlier period many in Marmara practiced indigenous forms of religion, but by the 1990s everyone had converted to Islam, and the reformist Izala organisation had become influential. But while this did change sociality (e.g. beer drinking declined while religious study increased), villagers continued to understand local moral norms in ways that greatly resembled the past. The strictures of structural adjustment had not hurt villagers too terribly. While several landholders acquired land on an unprecedented scale, this mostly represented a consolidation of the upper end of the wealth scale rather than a broader disenfranchisement. Thus despite a tumultuous two decades for Nigeria as a whole, Marmara suggests continuity more than change.
Clough's is an admirable book. Where it falls short is in its engagement with scholarship produced since the mid-1980s. Clough's arguments would have benefited from a greater engagement, for example, with Sara Berry's famous account of accumulation in south-western Nigeria, cited in passing with her name misspelled, or Christopher Udry's work on credit in northern Nigeria. While the very large recent historiography on rural Hausaland may be a bit far from Clough's time period, his account of Islamicisation would have been made more substantive by a less superficial engagement with the work of anthropologists like Adeline Masquelier and Roman Loimeier. This lack of attention to 25 years of scholarship underlines one of the most glaring issues with the book, which is its overwhelming and unacknowledged bias toward men. This is doubtless the product of the extreme gender segregation of Hausa society (as Clough acknowledges in an interesting article on Africa), but it could have been addressed in part through some engagement with the huge literature on Hausa women and gender relations that has developed in recent decades. Nonetheless, the book is a real achievement and a most useful addition to the literature. It will be of great interest to every Hausa specialist.
