The articles in this collection, while diverse in content, have a common theme: they explore the place of gender within scientific institutions and organizations in colonial and post-colonial India. The editor provides the raison d'être for the volume in the introduction: lately feminist debate has used gender as an analytical category to query the patriarchy and politics of science in the Western world, but in India this task is as yet largely unfulfilled. The editor argues that this volume fills the gap in understanding the structural as well as everyday practices of science and medicine in India. She therefore questions, among other things, if ‘there was ever any change in the colonial ideology and attitude or even debates over women's access to science and medicine’, and did ‘the patterns of women's … participation in science, medicine, and engineering change in post-colonial India?’ (p. xv). The volume is likewise divided into two sections; the first one focusing on colonial India and the second on contemporary experiences.
It is not surprising that all the chapters on the presence and praxis of women medical personnel refer to the colonial period. The dissemination of Western medicine in colonial India involved the expansion of its remit from the control of epidemics and prevention through vaccines and quarantines to the offer and distribution of Western therapeutics to the general population, and therefore needed to include women in some capacity within civil medical institutions. As Geraldine Forbes argues in her article ‘No science for lady doctors’, although medical professionals of the Indian Medical Service refused to admit women to the important teaching hospitals, the colonial government facilitated the admission and training of women as hospital assistants, a subordinate rank which enabled women to serve as ancillary medical personnel. Meanwhile, science education for women remained limited to ‘non-masculine’ subjects like botany instead of more ‘theoretical’ subjects such as physics. Forbes concludes that the circumscribed inclusion of women in medical and science education ‘essentialized both science and women’ (p. 16).
Antoinette Burton and Maneesha Lal pursue the theme of Victorian Englishwomen's practise of medicine in colonial India. The ‘zenana’, the secluded and the metaphorically dark as well as unhygienic women's quarters, became the site of Victorian medical reform and care; both the London School of Medicine for Women (established in 1876), after battling male privilege in medical education, and the Dufferin Fund (established in 1885 by Lady Dufferin, the vicereine, at Queen Victoria's urging) were the consequence of imperial concern over the plight of the physical and moral health of the segregated women in the ‘zenanas’. Both these institutions, moreover, provided greater opportunities to imperial medical women, both missionaries and ‘professionals’, to practise medicine in the colony.
The presence of Indian women within scientific and science-education institutions in India is examined by Abha Sur, in ‘Dispersed radiance: women scientists in C.V. Raman's laboratory’, where she argues that although a few women scientists such as Anna Mani, Lalita Chandrasekhar and Sunanda Bai, all employed at Raman's famous laboratory in late colonial India, made a place for themselves within the laboratory, this acceptance referred to their professional selves, culturally resonating with the role of ascetic scholars, not as fully fledged emotional and sexual individuals. In ‘How exportable are Western theories of gendered science?’, Carol C. Mukhopadhyay writes of the fallacies in adopting American gendered cultural models to understand the gender gap in women studying science and engineering in post-colonial India. However, her acceptance of the idea of a monolithic, unquestioned ‘Hindu’ cultural and normative paradigm on the part of women in contemporary India is superficial and questionable. Veena Poonacha's chapter, ‘Has feminism passed them by?’, in contrast, examines independent India's science-education policies through four strategic policy papers, and concludes that structural inequities have been inadequately addressed by the state and have sustained the lack of science education among women in post-Independence India; the most important of these have been their access to education at elementary as well as at the more advanced levels.
Overall, this volume has brought together articles on different themes, focusing on institutions that enabled women to practise medicine or science in India, and the structural limitations within them. To the undergraduate student and general reader, they will provide useful pointers towards the organization of medical and scientific institutions in nineteenth- and twentieth-century India. But several of these chapters were published at least a decade ago, and one has clearly retained the unedited version of a conference presentation. If we want to know what new questions this collection of essays initiates in gender studies in India, this volume will not satisfy.
