Fintan Walsh's edited collection Theatres of Contagion: Transmitting Early Modern to Contemporary Performance is a valuable addition to scholarship that investigates the interplay among theatre, performance practice, culture, and contagion. The work can be understood in conversation with treatments of the concept of the viral as a means of social, cultural, and theatrical transmission, such as Miriam Felton-Dansky's Viral Performance: Contagious Theaters from Modernism to the Digital Age (2018) [reviewed above—DS]. I first picked up Theatres of Contagion in March 2020, following the theatre closures during the initial COVID-19 lockdown, with questions on the future of touch in immersive theatre and performance works. The word “contagion,” derived from Latin contāgiōn-em, is etymologically related to touch; it “incorporates con (with, together) and tangere (to touch)” (5). In this timely collection, Walsh suggests that “to think about theatre and contagion . . . is always to consider their enmeshment in the realities and fantasies of touch” (6)—an all-too-graspable concept, today, when touch is restricted, feared, and desired.
The collection considers contemporary adaptations of earlier works; development of dramaturgies of contagion with recourse to earlier thinking about, or attitudes toward, contagion; and the idea of hereditary “transmission” of practice between practitioners. In the Introduction, Walsh writes that “part of the challenge in editing this book has been to manage interdisciplinary study across a long historical sweep, but there is no way to neatly contain contagion” (7), and this refusal to be contained characterizes the collection, which enacts and encourages interdisciplinarity and the positive processes of contagion with which it is thematically concerned. Theatres of Contagion is divided into three parts: “Infectious Bodies and Behaviours,” which considers the body as the site of contagion; “Sites of Contamination and Containment,” which investigates the theatre as a site of contagion as well as site-specific notions of contamination and containment; and “Conducting Emotions, Moods and Minds,” which considers the transmission of affect in digital and immersive practices as well as the neurological mechanisms involved in empathy, embodied simulation, and projective identification.
In his own contribution to the volume, in Part 1, Walsh explores the “dramaturgy of contagion,” or the ways in which contagion, ideas about contagion, or the mechanisms of contagion inform performance practice, in his analysis of Dickie Beau's 2017 performance Re-Member Me (13). The performance used audio recordings to conjure the ghosts of Hamlets past, specifically Ian Charleson, who played Hamlet while dying of AIDS-related illnesses. The chapter considers the queer lineage of Hamlet, the AIDS crisis, and the hereditary transmission of kinship among actors playing Hamlet as forms of viral contagion. Walsh also examines the Government Act 1988, Section 28, which compounded homophobia in law as a mode of “inoculating against the (presumed) transmissibility of homosexuality” (32), as well as how performance and queer culture resisted such containment. Shani Bans writes on infectious sights and sites in Shakespeare's work, antitheatricalist rhetoric, and ways of mitigating contaminative risk—notably, the metatheatrical scenes in Twelfth Night, which allow spectators to be safely contaminated. In her contribution, practitioner Rebecca McCutcheon reflects on her own 2014 reimagining of Elizabeth Inchbald's The Massacre (1792) at Dilston Grove. The site-specific work inspired another form of contagion as dramaturgy, McCutcheon's “micro-environment[s]” (82), in which actors devised scenes in relation to parts of the site and their character's narrative, which in turn compelled spectators to empathize and participate. McCutcheon draws on theories of crowd behavior to suggest how cultivating an experience of “in- and out-groups” (77) in performance might lead to understanding violence and, ultimately, affirmative affect.
In Part 2, Kirsten Shepherd-Barr considers the ways in which nineteenth-century theatre borrowed and adapted scientific notions of heredity and, in turn, how this adaptation blurred notions of social and viral contagion. She suggests that such interactions set the stage for Artaud's theories and computer games about pandemics. Shepherd-Barr argues that the game Plague Inc., for example, which encourages users to “stage worldwide pandemics and rack up millions of deaths” (93), enables them to perform a level of control reminiscent of eugenic theories. Exploring the theatre as a site of contagion, Julius Green considers the phenomenon of contagious fainting in response to site-specific psychological and neurological factors. Green considers, for example, the Théâtre du Grand Guignol (1897–1962), a claustrophobic venue in Paris's red-light district. He argues that the site and surrounding environment increase the likelihood of fainting responses by conditioning tension and foreboding. Molly McPhee examines the interplay of law, race, and contagion in her consideration of the Clean Break Theatre Company's productions. McPhee draws attention to necropolitics, or the systems of governance that oppress those who challenge white hegemony in “‘death worlds’” (122), as well as the “tearjerking” practice, which might challenge complacent/complicit/passive spectatorship (127). Lynne McCarthy raises awareness of the environmental racism tacit in the Environmental Protection Agency's use of “bunding” (retaining walls) at the Irish Traveller settlement at Dale Farm, in Essex. Bunding is designed to contain toxic waste, but its usage effectively designates the Travellers as social contaminants (as well as positions them in proximity to literal contaminants).
In Part 3, Ana Pais critiques the neoliberal ideologies as well as processes of othering and exclusion at play in Punchdrunk's Sleep No More. Pais also questions the politics of sonic affect, which thematically resonates with Marcus Cheng Chye Tan's contribution (in Part 1) on auditory and embodied contagion in musical and intercultural theatres. Mark Pizzato reimagines the mechanisms of identification and empathy in the brain as the “inner theatre.” In the consideration of the neuroscientific mechanisms behind emotional contagion, Pizzato designates the neocortex and the left cortex as the “inner scriptwriter/critic” and “mime-improviser/scene designer,” respectively, to explain the performance of self and other (171). Finally, Liam Jarvis's contribution explores how past experiences infect our conscious and unconscious biases, which, in turn, impact our affective reality and behavior. Jarvis then considers the potential (and potential limitations) that virtual reality might have for increasing empathy and, ultimately, altering our experiences of affective realism.
Theatres of Contagion is an exemplary interdisciplinary collection that practitioners and researchers across a wide range of disciplines will find useful, not only as they think through the pandemic and intersections among culture, policy, and wider systems, but more broadly. It will be invaluable in instigating further study as we look toward the future and, in the future, as we start to think through postpandemic performance and culture.
