In spite of the geographic limits suggested by its title, Genocide in the Middle East: The Ottoman Empire, Iraq, and Sudan by Hannibal Travis comprehensively surveys mass killings around the world, with particular emphasis on the 20th century. Travis defines genocide broadly: it is “the crime of destroying, or attempting or conspiring to destroy, a national, ethnic, or religious group, whether in whole or in part” (p. xxiii). Referring to the discussions of Raphael Lemkin, a Polish lawyer who invented the term “genocide” in 1943, as well as to the principles of the 1948 Genocide Convention, Travis emphasizes that designating crimes as genocide does not necessarily require an intent to annihilate a group as a whole. Systematic massacres and discriminatory acts may also denote genocidal objectives. Travis also discusses different ways to conceptualize genocide, emphasizing cultural, mental, structural, economic, or biological variants. The result is a highly ambitious historical account of not only mass killings carried out by state and nonstate actors but also acts of economic and cultural discrimination, religious persecution, slavery, colonial expansion, and terrorism.
Travis’ book is unusual in its historical and empirical scope. It begins with a discussion of the evolution of international law in terms of the regulation of armed conflict from ancient times to the present. Travis then gives an overview of the Genocide Convention and other sources of international law that address genocide, such as the United Nations Charter and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The author examines the decisions of the Nuremberg, Yugoslav, and Rwanda tribunals and concludes that death toll is not a necessary criterion in determining genocidal crime. He underlines that various acts from mass killings to rape, deportations, forced impregnations, deprivations of humanitarian aid, and campaigns to destroy cultural characteristics of a group may also indicate genocidal intent. After this general discussion on what genocide is, the book surveys numerous case studies. The list is long. It gives a history of mass killings before monotheism and after the rise of Christianity. A separate chapter covers the genocidal consequences of Islamic conquests, the Crusades, and the Mongol conquests, such as mass killings and attacks on other cultures. Another lengthy chapter surveys “European Colonial Genocides” in the Americas, Africa, Asia, and Oceania. The Holocaust, murders conducted by Stalin's government, massive deaths during the Great Leap Forward, Hindu-Muslim massacres, the Vietnam War, Guatemalan atrocities against indigenous peoples in the 1980s, the Iran–Iraq War, and al-Qaʿida terrorism are among other case studies. Despite the title, only one-third of the book is devoted to a discussion of mass killings in the Ottoman Empire, Iraq, and Sudan.
Travis argues that the comprehensive scope of the book is its major contribution to the literature on genocide. He also stresses that he intended to “draw continuities between, and expand on the findings of, the many studies dealing with cases of genocide from ancient times to the present” (p. 9). While the book is informative and comprehensive, its theoretical contributions are slim. The book's wide scope is also its main weakness. Conceptualizing genocide on such broad terms raises the question of what is not a genocide. Travis places cases that are very different from each other, in both qualitative and quantitative terms, on the same footing. The book adds little to our understanding of the causes behind different types of mass killings. One causal argument that Travis puts forward at the beginning of the book is that economic incentives have been a common motivation behind all genocides (p. 89). Travis cites several examples, such as the killings of Africans during the slave trade, Armenians, Greeks, and Assyrians in the Ottoman Empire, Jews during the Holocaust, Chinese during the Great Leap Forward, and Kurds, Assyrians, and Yezidis in Iraq. This is a provocative argument, but Travis fails to support it with strong empirical evidence in the individual chapters devoted to case studies. He infers causality from consequences, which makes the argument more problematic. The expropriation of non-Muslims’ property in Anatolia by Turks and Kurds during and after World War I does not necessarily mean that economic motivation was the overriding cause of the deportations and killings. Travis’ case studies are quite general and descriptive. They rarely address the overarching argument about economic motivation laid out in the rest of the book.
In the last chapter and the conclusion, Travis discusses possible policy solutions to minimize genocidal acts. He argues that the international community should concentrate on developing mechanisms to force perpetrators to pay monetary compensation to victims as a deterrent. According to Travis, international criminal sanctions, or the trial and sentencing of heads of state and state officials who have committed acts of genocide, have failed as deterrents to genocide (p. 564). It is not clear, however, how mechanisms for compensating the victims could be established, especially given states’ disagreements over what constitutes a genocide, and how international actors would enforce compliance on the perpetrators. Travis discusses various problems of implementation in the prosecutions of the International Criminal Court and the different war crimes tribunals. His policy recommendation remains vague without a discussion of how civil reparations could be more effectively implemented than criminal prosecutions of leaders that have committed genocide have been. In fact, in the conclusion, Travis states that the international community may never eradicate genocide and that international norms will likely continue to be disregarded. Finally, it is difficult to understand his speculations about the future of genocide: “furthermore, the concept of genocide itself may one day be done away with as outmoded and archaic, to be replaced by alternative approaches such as a right to be different, the resurrection of the dead by new technologies, or a mass migration to virtual reality homes” (p. 583).
