How do bodies move through, beyond, and in relation to extrajudicial violence and tightly choreographed state terror? How are these moves methods for thinking, feeling, and existing in an alternate world of possibility, “otherwise” to dominant social orders? Victoria Fortuna's Moving Otherwise: Dance, Violence, and Memory in Buenos Aires takes up these questions and offers a deep and illuminating engagement with movement—that which is danced and that which frames and extends from dance—and its oft under-the-radar relationship to politics in Buenos Aires–based contemporary dance. Tracing a period that spans the eve of military dictatorships in the 1960s to the free-market economic collapse in the early 2000s, Fortuna attends to both the expressly “political” and the “politics of” dance on and off the concert stage (8). She beautifully renders a story that features dozens of dancers who “mov[ed] otherwise” to “represent, resist, and remember violence,” by creating space, relation, survival, and healing in the face of political and economic turmoil (4). The book argues that Argentine contemporary dance offers a unique site for understanding the role of corporeality in state politics, carefully mapping how concert dance echoes and cites the local activist praxis of poner el cuerpo (putting the body on the line). As such, Moving Otherwise takes its place in a diverse body of English-language hemispheric performance studies scholarship, extending Diana Taylor's powerful articulation of “percepticide”—the use of violent spectacle in Argentina to induce self-blinding and consolidate state power— and effectively applying a dance studies lens to illustrate how the corporeal and kinetic function alongside, and often in place of, the spectacular. Fortuna helps us understand “the corporeal machinations of state power” while also making a case for how movement practices served for many people as a kind of corporeal safe harbor and site of embodied connection and care (8).
Moving Otherwise draws on an extensive archive of dance materials (many performances can be accessed through captivating videos on a companion website) that Fortuna engages through lucid movement analysis and places in conversation with insights gleaned from fifty-three personal interviews with interlocutors whose words she cites as “method as well as an object of analysis” (24). Along with her own dance experiences in Buenos Aires, Fortuna weaves these archival materials and interviews into a fluid prose that tracks how the bodily indexes a history of disappearance, confinement, and social mobilization. The choice to focus the book on concert dance (in both its on- and offstage life) and the constellation referred to as contemporary dance is articulated with a great deal of nuance. She destabilizes the center–periphery relationship produced through dance studies’ privileging of US and European experimentalism by citing Buenos Aires as “a key nexus in the circulation of global modernisms” while also challenging universalizing formulations of contemporary dance that render it not only unmarked racially and culturally, but politically neutral (14). Furthermore, in following the many moves otherwise performed throughout the transnational careers of her interlocutors—Ana Kamien, Susana Zimmermann, Estela Maris, Alejandro Cervera, Renate Schottelius, Susana Tambutti, Silvia Hodgers, Silvia Vladimivsky, and others— she tracks strategic refusals of, and engagements with, what critical dance studies scholar Marta Savigliano calls the “political economy of passion” that circulates around tango and other popular dance practices associated with nation-building projects in the Global South (112).
The book's five chapters, chronologically organized, center around the axes of mobility, militancy, survival, trauma, and cooperation. Focusing on the 1960s, Chapter 1 follows choreographers whose careers were rooted in an artistic experimentation that circumvented normative gender and class expectations and was ultimately the foundation of a movement practice that critiqued and challenged the emergent political climate by sounding a “‘state of alert’” for the violence that would follow (34). Chapter 2 discusses how embodied dance knowledges infused leftist militant tactics while also attending to dance works that directly engaged militant ideologies during the military rule of the late 1960s and early 1970s. In a dramatic account, Fortuna shares her discovery of how imprisoned revolutionaries used dance as cover and distraction to create embodied connection and community and to rehearse literally the famed Rawson prison revolt through danced physical exercises, such as Silvia Hodgers's “crouched-down march” (64). Examples of both “militants dancing and dances about militancy” powerfully illustrate how the assumed apolitical nature of dance—as daily practice and artistic product—served as protection from censorship (57). Examining the period 1976–83 known as the “Dirty War,” Chapter 3 continues to engage with what Francine Masiello identifies as dance's unique “‘advantage of marginal space’” (81). Fortuna demonstrates how this marginality ultimately facilitated the creation of spaces (studios, schools, and companies) and physical practices such as expresión corporal that nurtured the body in the context of extreme corporeal control, censure, and in many cases disappearance. She traces how the experiences provided by these dance spaces and practices eventually led to the creation of works directly and indirectly critiquing disciplinary corporeal strictures, such as the 1981 Danza Abierta festival, where hundreds of spectators defied government policy by publicly gathering outdoors to experience dance works by seventy choreographers and more than five hundred dancers. Chapter 4 examines how dance was used in the postdictatorship period starting in 1983 to process, physically and psychically, the collective and individual (often sexual) trauma Argentines had experienced. Fortuna here analyzes three works that mobilized tango as both a citation of the genre's own history of moving otherwise in the context of immigration, marginalization, and racialized poverty and as an invocation of tango's danced power dynamic between follower and leader. Chapter 5 turns to the period following the economic collapse of 2001, when communities across the country contended with the “economic disappeared” (140) in the wake of neoliberal imperatives to sacrifice communal survival for individual benefit. This chapter explores initiatives that linked dance to the politics of the laboring body by examining grassroots projects and cooperative practices that challenged hierarchical power relationships modeled by the globalized governing structures causing the crisis.
Moving Otherwise should be celebrated for how it covers vast terrain in a meticulously complex yet still broadly accessible manner that promises the book's success across a variety of classrooms. The admittedly less prominent, though still present, engagement with sexual, gender, and especially racial politics is notable given the centrality of these dynamics in Latin American performance and in dance and performance studies more generally. We get a glimpse of Argentina's complicated racial dynamics in the protest march fascinatingly described in the book's Epilogue, where we encounter a reference to Afro-Argentine history—itself a national trauma of expulsion and disappearance—through the Afro-diasporic orisha dances of Argentine company Oduduwá Danza Afroamericana. Signaling pathways to future research that are beyond the scope of this book's project, it also sets into relief Argentina's unique relationship to whiteness, a whiteness that ultimately conditions the possibilities for resisting embodied containments and imagining embodied freedoms. The poetics of “moving otherwise” so beautifully detailed throughout this book call to mind Black performance theorist Ashon Crawley's formulation of the “otherwise worlds of possibility” manifested in the sociality of Black performance. Considered together, Fortuna and Crawley powerfully frame the corporeality at the genesis of the “otherwise” futures we so desperately need.
