In recent years, scholars have focused a great deal of attention on the crucial role that private associations played in the social and economic life of the Greco-Roman world. The past decade alone has witnessed the publication of corpora of documentary evidence (R. Ascough et al., Greco-Roman Associations: Texts, Translations, and Commentary I–III, 2011–2020), a sourcebook of translated documents (R. Ascough et al., Associations in the Greco-Roman World, 2012) and the comprehensive online Inventory of Ancient Associations of the Copenhagen Associations Project, directed by V. Gabrielsen (https://ancientassociations.ku.dk/CAPI/). Alongside this array of scholarly tools, numerous studies have offered new appraisals of the nature, institutions and status of the diverse associations that spanned the Mediterranean world.
A significant set of voices within this renewed research consists of religious studies scholars employing evidence from the broader phenomenon of ‘Greco-Roman associations’ as a comparative heuristic for gaining insight into the models, organisation and context of Jewish and early Christian collectivities. This scholarly subcurrent largely has paralleled the work of ancient historians, with limited interaction between the two groups, but increasingly there have been more systematic efforts to bring these disciplinary approaches into dialogue (e.g. B. Eckhardt (ed.), Private Associations and Jewish Communities in the Hellenistic and Roman Cities, 2019). The authors of the book under review, Richard Last and Philip Harland, are prominent proponents of the comparative ‘Greco-Roman associations’ paradigm and set out to explore not why individuals joined private associations, but rather how they ran and sustained them.
Drawing on evidence spanning the Hellenistic and Roman Mediterranean, L. and H. trace associations’ membership (ch. 1), the evidence for their lifespan and circumstances of their success or failure (ch. 2), their foundation (ch. 3), their fees, costs, property and resources (chs 4–5) and their culture of communal collections and mutual assistance (chs 6–8). Although its subtitle suggests a focus on Jewish and Christian groups, only one chapter is devoted exclusively to them. It rather employs the documentary record of Greco-Roman associations to provide insight into the more limited and largely literary sources pertaining to Christian groups. The result is a wide-ranging and often fascinating tour through the financial underpinnings of these groups. The book exhibits the strengths and limitations of the comparative paradigm. The wide view allows the authors to draw on a large body of evidence to address broad, synchronic questions about the finances and membership of associations. There is little differentiation, however, between types of associations, their local or temporal circumstances or their relation to state institutions or legal frameworks.
Most compelling are L. and H.'s careful reconstructions of the mechanisms for collecting and managing funds, securing meeting places, enforcing regulations and participation, and providing mutual aid. Here a broad view of the evidence is particularly salutary for shedding light on Christian groups and nuancing the rhetoric of the literary sources. The approach helpfully reorients the discussion away from the supposed uniqueness of what some have seen as a particular culture of Christian ‘charity’ to a more widespread ideology of mutual assistance. The practice of providing mutual financial support in turn reveals the sort of social bonds that associations fostered and provides insights into the practices and models upon which early Christian groups could draw.
In other cases, the book's synchronic view is more limiting. For example, L. and H. critique what they describe as a new consensus that most members of associations derived from a ‘middling class’. Drawing on the (debated) model of a highly stratified distribution of wealth in the Roman empire recently proposed by W. Scheidel and S. Friesen (JRS 9 (2009), 61–91), L. and H. argue that estimates of membership in associations (drawn largely from cases like Pompeii) are too high for them to represent mainly the Scheidel–Friesen ‘middling class’, comprising about ten per cent of the population. Associations surely drew on a larger segment of the population, but the Scheidel-Friesen categories are far more precise than those generally employed by ancient historians working on associations. Moreover, it is debatable whether Scheidel and Friesen's model can be applied broadly across the ancient world. Are their categories equally useful for cases like fourth-century b.c.e. Athens, Hellenistic Rhodes and Roman Asia Minor?
The relationship among associations, the state and civic elites provides another case in which a broad model may not be applicable. L. and H. seek to nuance the view that associations were mostly started by a wealthy donor and convincingly argue for more room for collective action in initiating and sustaining associations. But there is also a tendency to apply this broad view to cases where we have much more specific evidence, such as Hellenistic Rhodes. Here the extensive documentation demonstrates that private associations were intimately tied up with public institutions, associations and the competition of office-holding elites for preeminence within the democratic polis (see now C. Thomsen, The Politics of Association in Hellenistic Rhodes, 2020). In other words, this was an associative phenomenon particular to Rhodes and its federal politics, and substantively different from the cases studied by O. van Nijf in Roman Asia Minor (The Civic World of Professional Associations in the Roman East, 1997), and presumably bearing little resemblance to the situation of the Pauline assembly in Roman Corinth.
Despite these reservations, the book is a rich synthesis of the economic life of ancient associations. L. and H. provide a wealth of detail that will be of interest to ancient historians and scholars of religion. The book fills an important lacuna in the burgeoning scholarship on ancient associations and offers a compelling argument for the importance of the financial framework of associations for understanding their social functions and widespread appeal.
