Following the military interventions in Kosovo and East Timor in 1999, there has been a growth in support for the idea that military force may constitute a legitimate response to genocide, ethnic cleansing, and systematic human rights abuses. This doctrinal shift towards ‘new interventionism’ has been partly attributed to the end of the cold war, during which the Security Council (‘the Council’ or SC) had been unable to exercise its powers under Chapter VII of the UN Charter because of the threat or use of the veto by the five permanent members.Footnote 1 Scholars have also highlighted that, since the Gulf War in 1990, the Council has adopted a broad interpretation of ‘threats to the peace’, which fall under the Council's jurisdiction by virtue of Article 39, Chapter VII of the Charter.Footnote 2 The numerous Council resolutions passed with regard to Yugoslavia, Somalia, Rwanda, Haiti, and East Timor have been interpreted as demonstrating the Council's increasing willingness to treat humanitarian crises as a threat to international peace and security.Footnote 3
Amid the surge of support for humanitarian intervention, this article attempts to diverge from mainstream debate and analyse the impact of this doctrine upon women in the recipient states from a feminist perspective. Some feminists have embraced the new doctrine of humanitarian intervention as lex ferenda Footnote 4 (contributing in part to its rising acceptance), and have argued for military interventions in response to systematic sexual violence. Such arguments have been made with regard to the situations in Bosnia (1993), Afghanistan (2001), and Iraq (2003), as well as more recently in Sudan and Somalia.Footnote 5 In contrast to these feminist ‘calls for troops’,Footnote 6 this article asserts that such a response would be counterproductive for women's rights, and disproportionate in terms of the international law governing the use of force.
Following the approach of feminist scholarship, which looks for silences in dominant discourse and seeks to interject alternative voices, this article departs from the mainstream legal and normative discourse surrounding humanitarian intervention to ask some marginalized questions: first, how does military humanitarian intervention directly and indirectly impact upon women's rights? Furthermore, is military humanitarian intervention a proportionate response to humanitarian crises, including situations of systematic sexual violence? In seeking to answer these questions, this article will consider the recent convergence between (some) feminists and interventionists, and offer a critique of the appropriation of women's rights to justify military action. It will then offer a contextual basis for its critique by analysing the direct and indirect impacts of military intervention in relation to sex trafficking and forced prostitution in Kosovo. It is the author's contention that the dangers of military interventionism may be demonstrated by adopting a feminist perspective. The article will conclude by evaluating responses to sexual violence at the international level, reflecting upon the wider implications both for the laws on the use of force and for women's rights.
The author is mindful of the potential criticism that it is pessimistic to focus on the ‘dark sides’Footnote 7 of one of the few humanitarian practices that exist within international relations, and, furthermore, that it is regressive to criticize feminist calls for humanitarian intervention, which has been hailed by many as a success for women's rights. However, Kennedy encourages us, as scholars of international law, to evaluate that which is seen as virtuous, and to search for the dark sides, blind-spots, and biases of humanitarian practice.Footnote 8 Such an approach also lies at the core of feminist theory, the purpose of which is to look to the margins of mainstream discourse and to expose the blind-spots and biases within dominant narratives.
By analysing the converging relationship between feminists and interventionists, it is evident that the relationship between the two schools has been counterproductive. In exposing the disjuncture between rhetoric and reality in intervention narratives, this article illustrates that the political potency of women's rights is vulnerable to appropriation by ‘heroic’ governments seeking to liberate female ‘victims’. In reality, women's experiences of military intervention have been far from liberating. By simply shifting the focus of the lens, important alternative narratives are revealed. It is imperative that these narratives be included and understood within future debates surrounding intervention.
The emergence of feminist hawks
There are numerous developments within state practice and opinio juris to indicate an emerging norm of humanitarian intervention within customary international law. Evidence can be found in the statements issued by the UN Secretary-General in relation to Rwanda and Kosovo, General Assembly resolutions regarding interventions throughout the 1990s, and the general support of the international community with regard to the interventions in Kosovo and East Timor. In the context of Kosovo, for example, widespread consensus asserts that, although NATO's action was illegal under positive law owing to the lack of Security Council authorization,Footnote 9 it could nevertheless be exceptionally condoned on the grounds of humanitarian principles.Footnote 10 In response to criticism by legal scholars regarding the dubious legal justifications for NATO's intervention, Secretary-General Kofi Annan stated:
‘[T]he genocide in Rwanda will define for our generation the consequences of inaction in the face of mass murder … If … a coalition of States had been prepared to act in defence of the Tutsi population, but did not receive prompt Council authorization, should such a coalition have stood aside and allowed the horror to unfold?’Footnote 11
More recently, the World Summit Outcome Document, 2005, demonstrated a strong commitment from the General Assembly to the ‘Responsibility to Protect’ (R2P) doctrine, stating that ‘we are prepared to take collective action … through the Security Council … should peaceful means be inadequate and national authorities manifestly fail to protect their populations from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity’.Footnote 12
Feminist scholars have also seized on the R2P doctrine as an opportunity to draw attention to the systematic abuses of women and to demand a military response. The convergence of feminism with interventionism was notably demonstrated in the case of Bosnia. Engle explains that feminist ‘success’ in equating Serbian rape policy with acts of genocide provided a huge moral imperative to the international community.Footnote 13 Nesiah describes the partnership between certain feminists and ‘military hawks’ as forming a ‘marriage’ of convenience between the two entities that has, since Bosnia, been further demonstrated in justifications for interventions in Afghanistan and Iraq.Footnote 14 Drawing on the work of Engle and Nesiah, this article therefore uses the term ‘feminist hawks’ to refer to this convergence between the two constituents.Footnote 15
‘Saving women’ narratives
‘Will the Marines never land for [women]?’Footnote 16
The rhetoric employed by advocates of intervention in Bosnia-Herzegovina (1995), and more recently in Afghanistan (2001) and Iraq (2003), demonstrates the increasing incorporation of women's rights as a justification for military intervention. In Afghanistan, perhaps more prominently than elsewhere, Afghan women, supported by numerous feminists, lent their rhetorical potency to the US Department of State and became the symbolic face of Operation Enduring Freedom: ‘as we drive out the Taleban and the terrorists, we are determined to lift up … the women and children of Afghanistan, [they] have suffered enough’.Footnote 17 The US First Lady, Laura Bush, delivered radio broadcasts drawing attention to the plight of women in Afghanistan: ‘I'm delivering this week's radio address to kick off a world-wide effort to focus on the brutality against women and children by the al-Qaida terrorist network and the regime it supports in Afghanistan, the Taleban’.Footnote 18 At present, support for military intervention in Darfur and the Democratic Republic of Congo continues to increase as media attention focuses on the documentation of systematic rape within these conflicts.Footnote 19 From the perspective of radical feminism, this represents a significant victory for women's rights campaigns that posit women's sexual vulnerability as the factor to be addressed by feminist politics.
Furthermore, in June 2008, the UN Security Council Resolution (SC Res) 1820, which supplements the Council's earlier resolution SC Res 1325 on women, peace, and security,Footnote 20 established a new binding instrument specifically focused on sexual violence in conflict and post-conflict situations.Footnote 21 The passing of this significant resolution indicates that the ‘marriage of convenience’ between women's rights and military interventionists is now influencing international law.Footnote 22 Most notably for the present discussion, operative paragraph 1 (OP 1) of SC Res 1820, states that the Council ‘expresses its readiness, when considering situations on the agenda of the Council, to, where necessary, adopt appropriate steps to address widespread or systematic sexual violence’.Footnote 23
What exactly such ‘appropriate steps’ may entail is not elaborated on in this resolution, but it is certainly inferred by the text of OP 1 that widespread or systematic sexual violence may incite the authorization of force under Article 42. Heathcote points out that most of SC Res 1820 deals with sexual violence as a violation of international humanitarian law (jus in bello), whereas OP 1 implies that sexual violence may also fall within the definition of a ‘threat to international peace and security’, placing sexual violence within the framework of the laws on the use of force (jus ad bellum).Footnote 24 While the political will to invoke such an authorization is substantially lacking, the language of OP 1 indicates that sexual violence may have made its way onto the agenda of the Council as a threat to international peace and security, further broadening the potential scope of Chapter VII authorization for humanitarian intervention.
In addition to the resolution itself, public statements reflect the growing consensus that the R2P doctrine may extend to the realm of women's rights. Condoleezza Rice, in the Council's Debate on Women, Peace and Security that preceded the drafting of SC Res 1820, stated that ‘When women and girls are preyed upon, and raped, the international community cannot be silent or inactive. It is our responsibility to be their advocates and their defenders’.Footnote 25 Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon in his opening remarks at the debate, urged the Council to adopt resolutions with stronger language on sexual violence, in order that ‘the UN can respond more forcefully’, which may implicitly denote endorsement of the use of force.Footnote 26
At a discursive level, key feminist scholars have contributed to fostering a recognition of sexual violence as a security threat worthy of military response. For example, MacKinnon, in her analysis of the paradigmatic shift in approaches to security following the 11 September 2001 terrorist attack on the United States, embraces the emerging R2P doctrine, yet questions why it is not applicable to violence against women, or the ‘war on women’.Footnote 27 MacKinnon recognizes that violence against women does not constitute a conventional ‘armed attack’Footnote 28 and has therefore not been relevant to jus ad bellum.Footnote 29 However, since 9/11 there has, she argues, been a radical re-conceptualization of the nature of ‘armed attacks’ within international law, which must now be extended beyond terrorism to systematic acts of violence against women; both, she claims, constitute crimes against humanity.Footnote 30 Feminist hawks such as MacKinnon demand to know why the severe abuses of Afghan women under the Taliban regime were not, in themselves, valid justifications for military intervention: ‘Why … was their treatment alone, not an act of war or a reason to intervene (including militarily) on any day up to September 10, 2001?’Footnote 31
While MacKinnon is justified in questioning the prioritization of terrorism as a greater security threat, her recommendations that force must be deployed in response to violence against women fail to recognize the impacts of intervention and post-conflict militarization of society upon women. The fundamental assumption underlying her question is that military intervention will ‘save’ these women.Footnote 32 The following section offers a critique of ‘saving women’ narratives, which presuppose that military intervention will lead to liberation.
Deconstructing ‘saving women’ narratives
It is the author's contention that ‘saving women’ narratives, as discussed above, are regressive for women's rights. First, they are based upon the articulation of women as ‘victims’ and dispossess women of their self-determination. This can be seen in the transition from the first Security Council resolution adopted on women, peace, and security, SC Res 1325 of 2000, which focused predominantly on women's participation, to SC Res 1820 with its narrow focus on women's sexual vulnerability.Footnote 33 Kapur argues that the reliance upon the status of victimhood in an effort to claim rights for women is based upon gender essentialism.Footnote 34 In this sense, the oversimplified perspective of SC Res 1820 ignores the intersectionality that bears upon women's experiences, where not only gender but also race, class, ethnicity, and nationality all contribute to experiences of oppression.Footnote 35 To narrow the focus of women's experiences down to their shared commonality as women is to ignore the complexity of the wider context and falsely reduce women's experiences.
The victim/agency dichotomy creates an inaccurate lens through which to understand women's experiences and provokes an endless debate. Women are not simply one or the other. Agents, whether of change or of warfare, may also be victims of sexual violence or affected by it in some way. In fact, experiences of victimization may invoke agency. Victimhood and agency, violence and participation, are inextricably linked. SC Res 1325 and 1820 therefore need to be applied holistically, not dealt with as two distinct resolutions.
Secondly, ‘saving women’ narratives are premised upon a notion of cultural essentialism, portraying non-Western women as victims of their culture. As interventionists observe the victimized ‘Other’ through the neo-colonial lens, they adopt the stance of an ‘arrogant perceiver’.Footnote 36 This ‘arrogant perception’ ‘reinforces stereotypes and racist representations of that culture and privileges the culture of the West’, while wholly ignoring the influence of colonialism, dominant racial regimes or religions, and cultural hegemonies.Footnote 37 Kapur warns scholars to show caution with regard to narratives reminiscent of imperialist intervention that incite protectionist responses from states. Furthermore, these protectionist responses, invoked by the violence against women discourse, are counterproductive to the promotion of women's rights.Footnote 38 This will be demonstrated below in the analysis of the case of Kosovo.
It is the popular acceptance of ‘saving women’ narratives that forms the preface of the ‘heroic’ intervention story. Drawing upon feminist and post-colonial theories, Orford suggests that interventionist narratives ‘create a powerful sense of self for those who identify with the hero of the story’.Footnote 39 Orford argues that these interventionist narratives produce subjects that are dependent upon sexual and racial differentiation, depicting the Western white male as the hero and defender of the non-Western, non-white female.Footnote 40 The ‘heroic’ narrative is therefore wholly reliant upon the construction of female victimhood and the illusion that women need ‘saving’. Fanon's theory of racial differentiation can be transcribed onto sexual differentiation in the sense that ‘not only must the [hero] be a [hero]; he must be a [hero] in relation to the [female victim]’; the ‘hero’ must also be positioned in the narrative as the antithesis of the ‘rogue’ state or oppressor.Footnote 41 The interdependency of these narratives serves to reinforce racist and sexist perceptions of the subjects, simultaneously denying women's agency and promoting the ‘heroes’ of the story as the agents of change.
Finally, ‘saving women’ narratives remain unsubstantiated beyond the rhetoric. When one considers how intervention has impacted on women in recipient states, it is beyond dispute that such a strategy is counterproductive. By shifting the focus away from ‘heroic’ rhetoric, and by focusing instead upon the effects of military intervention upon women in Kosovo, the following analysis presents a significant challenge to the interventionist standpoint.Footnote 42
The NATO intervention in Kosovo
Background
The conflict in Kosovo dates back centuries, mainly to the Battles of Kosovo in the fourteenth century, which continue, to this day, to arouse nationalist tensions between the Serbian and Albanian populations. In 1946, Kosovo was absorbed into Serbia, although it was given autonomous status as a concession to the demands of the Albanian majority. In 1963, Kosovo became an autonomous province and, the following year, under Tito's constitution, was granted virtual self-government.Footnote 43 However, after Tito's death the 1980s were characterized by a climate of fear and systematic discrimination as violence between the two ethnic groups escalated.Footnote 44 In 1989, Slobodan Milosevic, President of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, asserted that the Serb minority in Kosovo was at significant risk and revoked Kosovo's autonomy. This enabled the government of Serbia to exert direct control over the previously self-governed areas and to impose ethnically based, centralized rule. In response, a resistance movement, the Kosovo Liberation Army, was formed and engaged in hit-and-run attacks on Serb forces. In turn, the Serbian army carried out large-scale frequent military attacks, and by 1998 some 200,000 Kosovar Albanians had been displaced.Footnote 45
The treatment of the Kosovar Albanians was denounced by the international community as ethnic cleansing. The Council passed Resolution 1199 (1998) requiring Belgrade to allow international monitors to observe the situation in Kosovo, and to withdraw security forces used for civilian repression.Footnote 46 In January 1999, negotiations between the Kosovar Albanians and Serbs were held by the ‘Contact Group’Footnote 47 in Rambouillet, France. The purpose of these negotiations was to establish a political framework for Kosovo's autonomy, following a three-year interim period.Footnote 48 In order to guarantee compliance, the Contact Group demanded that NATO be allowed to operate in the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (FRY). The Kosovar Albanians consented to the conditions set out by the Contact Group; the FRY remained intransigent.
The NATO intervention in Kosovo
On 24 March 1999, after diplomatic efforts failed to halt the ethnic cleansing of Kosovar Albanians by Serbian forces, NATO began a seventy-eight-day bombing campaign against Serbia. NATO did not receive the authorization required from the Council under Chapter VII of the UN Charter,Footnote 49 nor did its actions constitute self-defence as provided for under Article 51 thereof, which refers explicitly to the occurrence of an ‘armed attack’ against a sovereign entity.Footnote 50 Despite this, NATO Secretary General Solana declared ‘that NATO saw sufficient factual and legal grounds to threaten the use of force, and if necessary, to use force’.Footnote 51
While the majority of international lawyers and scholars concede that the intervention was illegal,Footnote 52 there are a number of liberal scholars who argue that on the contrary it was legal,Footnote 53 as well as others who hold that it could at least be condoned on humanitarian grounds.Footnote 54 Those who provide a critique of the intervention do so either on positivist legal grounds or by setting out the underlying non-humanitarian motivations.Footnote 55 Proportionality considerations are generally sidelined, except by Chinkin, who contends that the intervention was disproportionate (in terms of jus ad bellum) because it ultimately failed to end the human rights abuses.Footnote 56 However, not one of these mainstream critiques considers the impact on women. Drawing upon evidence collated by non-governmental organizations (NGOs), UN agencies, and journalists, the following section considers the effects of the intervention upon women, in particular the increase in sex trafficking and forced prostitution, before discussing the legal implications for international law on the use of force.
Sex trafficking and prostitution in KosovoFootnote 57
Since the deployment of the UN Kosovo Force (KFOR), in July 1999, alongside the establishment of the UN Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK), Kosovo has become a major destination country for the trafficking of women and girls into the sex industry.Footnote 58 The majority of women are trafficked from the neighbouring countries of Moldova, Bulgaria, and Ukraine, mainly via routes through Serbia. More recently, however, there has been a surge in internal trafficking of local women and girls and trafficking both into and out of Kosovo, facilitated by porous borders and weak visa regimes.Footnote 59 While Kosovo appears to have had a non-existent sex industry prior to 1999, reports show that, by July 2003, over 200 locations exploiting trafficked women were identified by UNMIK and the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe.Footnote 60
This phenomenon is a result of a number of interrelated consequences of intervention that will be analysed below. First, the sudden presence of military personnel created an immediate increase in demand for sexual services in a region with previously negligible demands. Secondly, the post-intervention militarization of Kosovo sustained this demand and fostered an environment where organized criminal networks could reap substantial profits. Thirdly, the disruption of society and the economy resulted in increased numbers of vulnerable women and girls in need of remuneration, thereby creating the supply for a burgeoning sex industry. Finally, the failure of UNMIK to adequately address the problem of trafficking allowed for a culture of impunity to prevail.
Enter the heroes
During the latter half of 1999, around 40,000 KFOR troops were deployed to Kosovo, along with hundreds of UNMIK personnel and more than 250 international non-governmental organizations.Footnote 61 Within months of their arrival, brothels had been established around the military bases and Kosovo had become a major destination country for trafficked women; a small local trade in prostitution became a flourishing industry based on trafficking by organized criminal networks.
A study conducted by the UN Development Fund For Women (UNIFEM) in 1999 identified eighteen main locations for prostitution. These included brothels in the Gnjilane area, predominantly servicing US military personnel; Prizren, where clients were mainly German KFOR soldiers; Pejë, servicing Italian KFOR soldiers; and Mitrovicë, where clients were largely French KFOR soldiers.Footnote 62 By January 2001, the number of brothels had grown to approximately 75, and by January 2004 over 200 locations harbouring trafficked victims had been identified.Footnote 63
In February 2000, the International Organization for Migration (IOM) publicly recognized KFOR and UNMIK staff as a significant factor in the increase of trafficking and prostitution.Footnote 64 The IOM also acknowledged that the trafficking industry was fuelled by Kosovo's proximity to source countries with established routes to European Union countries via Albania, as well as by co-operation among Serbian, Albanian, and Macedonian criminal networks.Footnote 65 Furthermore, the sudden international presence stimulated economic growth through the resultant increase of foreign money in the region. This meant that certain sections of the Kosovar population experienced a rise in prosperity and hence that the local population was given the possibility, which they may not have had before the intervention, of purchasing sexual services.
A hero's welcome
‘The problem is that nobody considers the need for brothels in the German contingent. The Americans and the French … have their army brothels. I'm not trying to say that the prostitutes have to come over from America or France, but …’Footnote 66
While the traffickers proved more prescient than the international community in anticipating the market for trafficked women and girls, they also recognized that years of conflict, displacement, and trauma had left many women across the Balkans particularly vulnerable, such as those living in refugee camps in Macedonia and Albania.Footnote 67 The disruptions in the economy caused by the NATO intervention also led to greater numbers of unemployed women in need of some form of remuneration; these women and girls were to become the supply for the new market opportunities.Footnote 68
According to the UNMIK Trafficking and Prostitution Investigation Unit (TPIU) set up to combat trafficking in Kosovo, around 90% of women working in prostitution there have been trafficked.Footnote 69 While women trafficked from abroad are often led to believe that they are migrating for legitimate employment, NGOs report that increasing numbers of Kosovar women are being abducted by force and trafficked internally – the majority of them are girls from families displaced by conflict.Footnote 70 Kosovar women and girls also face increased risk of being trafficked out of Kosovo, most commonly to Italy or to ethnic Albanian areas of Macedonia.Footnote 71
Trafficked women and girls interviewed by NGOs and journalists in Kosovo have provided firsthand evidence that the demand is predominantly fuelled by international peacekeepers. In an interview with the BBC, ‘Monica’Footnote 72 discusses her client profiles: ‘most of them were Americans and Germans …. Of course, I appealed to them for help … but all of them said that they would get into trouble if they helped’.Footnote 73 A Bulgarian woman interviewed by Amnesty explains that ‘Germans came … even after their commander did forbid that. They said they would get in a lot of trouble. They told the pimp that if someone would be coming he should alarm them … the pimp employed a guardian’.Footnote 74
The armour of impunity
‘It is absolutely essential that all U.N. forces are held to the same standards of international human rights law as nation states … to do otherwise, creates a climate of impunity in which offences proliferate.’Footnote 75
The militarization of a society has been linked to increased impunity for gender-based violence – the greater the military presence, the greater the possibility that men may violate women without consequences.Footnote 76 This theory is substantiated by evidence found in Kosovo. Despite the eventual recognition by UN agencies that peacekeeping personnel were both complicit in facilitating trafficking and in using the services of trafficked victims, little action has been taken to address these crimes.
As the interim administration in Kosovo, UNMIK was legally responsible for taking effective action against those suspected of involvement in trafficking. Under Article 6 of the Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW), as well as General Recommendation 19 on violence against women by the Committee for the Elimination of Discrimination against Women,Footnote 77 UNMIK is required to exercise ‘due diligence to prevent, investigate and … punish acts of violence against women, whether those acts are perpetrated by the state or by private persons’.Footnote 78
To date, however, UNMIK's record of dealing with trafficking cases has been far from diligent. It did not take any decisive action on trafficking until November 2000, when it established the TPIU as a division of UNMIK police.Footnote 79 Until January 2001, trafficking was subsumed under the FRY and Serbian Criminal Codes, particularly Article 251 – dealing with ‘intermediation in the exercise of prostitution’ – and Article 18(8) of Kosovar law, which established the minor offence of intermediating in prostitution or forcing another into prostitution.Footnote 80 The absence of a codified law on trafficking meant that trafficked women involved in prostitution were being dealt with as criminals, whereas trafficking crimes were not being punished. By February 2001, only four persons had been convicted under Article 251 for ‘intermediation into prostitution’.Footnote 81
In January 2001, the Special Representative of the UN Secretary-General introduced UNMIK Regulation 2001/4,Footnote 82 which criminalizes the acts of engaging in trafficking,Footnote 83 organizing and facilitating trafficking,Footnote 84 and withholding identity documents of trafficked women.Footnote 85 Significantly for the purpose of this analysis, Regulation 2001/4 also addresses the demand side by making it a crime to knowingly use the services of a trafficked person.Footnote 86 A further vital development incorporated in it is the recognition that trafficked persons must not be treated as criminals for their involvement in prostitution or other illegal activities.Footnote 87
Although the promulgation of this regulation marked a positive development in addressing impunity of the domestic population, it did not address impunity among the international personnel. UNMIK and KFOR personnelFootnote 88 are protected from prosecution in Kosovo by immunity granted under UNMIK Regulation 2000/47.Footnote 89 UNMIK personnel may only be prosecuted if a waiver is granted by the UN Secretary-General, while KFOR personnel's immunity may only be waived by the head of the national regiment.Footnote 90 The Ombudsperson Institution in Kosovo has criticized the regulation as being ‘not in accordance with the law’, particularly with regard to its failure to protect individuals in Kosovo against arbitrary conduct by KFOR or UNMIK personnel.Footnote 91
Despite the establishment of the TPIU and the promulgation of Regulation 2000/47, law enforcement has been weak and criminal justice proceedings scarce. Amnesty International suggests that lack of training and consultation with local judiciary has led to problems with interpretation and implementation of this law, including the failure to correctly identify trafficked women and to provide adequate support, and the continuation of arrests, prosecutions, and deportations of trafficked women for border violations or on prostitution charges.Footnote 92 While scores of women have continued to face charges of prostitution and related offences, there have been very few charges laid against men who knowingly used the services of trafficked women.Footnote 93 Despite the growing demand for trafficked women, demonstrated by the staggering increase in illicit premises from 1999 to 2003, alongside the TPIU finding that 90% of sex workers in Kosovo have been trafficked, not a single prosecution has been brought under Section 4 of the Trafficking Regulation.
Weak law enforcement and lack of political will are further consolidated by some affected women's acceptance of the ‘heroic’ narrative. This has resulted in trafficked women and girls being reluctant to give evidence against the peacekeepers. When the Rural Women's Network approached women's organizations to hold a round table on prostitution and sexual harassment, many were reticent, stating that they ‘do not agree to discuss topics which will offend the internationals’.Footnote 94
Responses at the international level
‘… if the rule of law means anything at all, it means that no one, including peacekeepers, is above the law’Footnote 95
Response at the international level has been just as weak as activity on the ground. In 2002, the UN Secretary-General submitted a report to the Council pursuant to SC Res 1325, in which he tentatively acknowledged that ‘there is some evidence that prostitution increases with international intervention. In some instances, peacekeeping personnel may have condoned the establishment of brothels and been complicit in the trafficking in women and girls’.Footnote 96 The Secretary-General emphasized the responsibility of member states to prosecute their nationals, as status-of-forces agreementsFootnote 97 accord exclusive jurisdiction to the contributing member state in the event that one of its nationals commits a crime during a peacekeeping operation.Footnote 98 The report also reaffirms Article 101(3) of the Charter, which requires all UN staff to uphold the highest standards of integrity, and the UN peacekeepers' Code of Conduct, which states that peacekeepers must not ‘indulge in immoral acts of sexual, physical or psychological abuse or exploitation of the local population or United Nations staff, especially women and children’.Footnote 99 The Code of Conduct has, however, been criticized by many experts as largely ineffective,Footnote 100 and the Assistant Secretary-General for Peacebuilding Support, Jane Holl Lute, has acknowledged the difficulties in unifying 103 troop-contributing countries under one code.Footnote 101
Some small progress has been made in dealing with impunity relating to sexual exploitation. In March 2002, the UN established the IASC Task Force,Footnote 102 whose mandate was to develop definitions of sexual exploitation and abuse and produce codes of conduct.Footnote 103 In October 2003, the Secretary-General issued a bulletin that emphasized that misconduct in the form of sexual exploitation would be subject to disciplinary measures and dismissal.Footnote 104 In 2004, he appointed an Adviser on Sexual Exploitation and Abuse by UN Peacekeeping Personnel, who subsequently issued a report detailing strategies for eliminating sexual exploitation within UN peacekeeping missions.Footnote 105 In response to large-scale exploitation in the Democratic Republic of Congo in 2004, the Secretary-General reinforced a zero-tolerance policy: ‘We cannot tolerate even one instance of a United Nations peacekeeper victimizing the most vulnerable among us. … The basic policy is clear: zero tolerance of sexual exploitation and abuse of any kind’.Footnote 106 This has been supplemented by a strong discouragement of all forms of sexual behaviour, including consensual relations,Footnote 107 and a more recent focus on victim protection.Footnote 108
Despite this progress, allegations of sexual exploitation and abuse continue to be brought against international peacekeepers.Footnote 109 The prevailing problem is the lack of accountability of military personnel. In the 2007 Secretariat Report, which addresses criminal accountability of UN officials and experts on mission, the Secretariat expressed concern that if contributing states ‘have not extended the operation of their criminal laws to apply to crimes committed in the host State – then there is a jurisdictional gap and the alleged offender is likely to escape prosecution’.Footnote 110 The report therefore recommends the promulgation of a convention that would extend the jurisdiction of member states to cover crimes committed by all UN personnel. However, the Secretariat upholds the exclusion of military personnel, reaffirming the exclusive jurisdiction of the contributing state with regard to its military and thus preserving the jurisdictional gap and perpetuating impunity.Footnote 111
Undermining the heroic narrative
Such a phenomenon cannot be dismissed from assessments regarding the proportionality of military intervention; the scale of trafficking in women and girls constitutes one of the most severe forms of human rights violations, defined by some as a crime against humanity, and included in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) as one of the most serious crimes.Footnote 112 It has also been argued, based on the jurisprudence of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia and the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, that sexual violence constitutes a violation of jus cogens.Footnote 113 Moreover, states are under an obligation to suppress trafficking and exploitation of prostitution.Footnote 114 Trafficking also violates the right to liberty and security of the person (International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), Article 9; European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), Article 5); rights to freedom of movement (ICCPR, Article 12), rights to privacy and family life (ECHR, Article 8; ICCPR, Article 17); and the right to be free from inhuman or degrading treatment (ICCPR, Article 7; ECHR, Article 3; Un Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 37).Footnote 115 In addition, trafficking violates the right to freedom from slavery, enshrined in the Trafficking Protocol;Footnote 116 ICCPR, Article 8(1); ECHR, Article 4; the African [Banjiul] Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights (ACHPR), Article 5; the American Convention on Human Rights (ACHR), Article 6; the International Labour Organization Convention (105) on the Abolition of Forced Labour; and Article 1(a) of the Convention supplementary to the Slavery Convention.Footnote 117 Furthermore, the authorities' failure to identify victims of trafficking and subsequent repatriation of them to their country of origin, where they are vulnerable to re-trafficking, may violate the principle of non-refoulement Footnote 118 and by extension make that state responsible for a violation of the right to be free from torture.Footnote 119 By creating and sustaining demand for an industry that violates the prolific number of rights listed above, and on some occasions by directly facilitating trafficking, international peacekeepers have dispelled one system of abuse under Milo
ević only to replace it with another system of abuse under their own ‘protection’. The ‘heroes’ of the story have failed to fulfil the rhetorical promises to ‘save women’ and have instead undermined the very purpose for which military action was taken.
By creating and sustaining a market for sex trafficking, military intervention justified in the guise of humanitarian action thus subverts the ‘heroic’ narratives asserted by feminist hawks and interventionists. In the case of Kosovo, intervention merely replaced a system of ethnic cleansing with an environment where trafficking and forced prostitution are rife. Traffickers simply adopted the tactics used in the rape camps and deployed them in the post-conflict situation for the trafficking of women:
‘Methods used to confine women in the Kosovo brothels do not differ much from those used in the camps in the Bosnian war … the criminal organisations behind the ‘business’ made use of the experience gained during the IFOR and SFOR missions in Bosnia-Herzegovina.’Footnote 120
Implications for the laws on the use of force
Any legal consideration of the right to use force, in accordance with jus ad bellum, must determine whether the proposed use of force is proportionate to the initial breach or grievance. The key criterion is whether the benefits of the use of force will outweigh the costs.Footnote 121 The resort to force is limited by this principle of customary law, the classic formulation of which can be found in the case of the Caroline Incident of 1838, which establishes that the use of force must be proved to be necessary (that is, ‘instant, overwhelming, leaving no choice of means and no moment of deliberation’) and proportionate (that is, ‘nothing unreasonable or excessive’).Footnote 122 The proportionality requirement has since been confirmed, in relation to self-defence, by the International Court of Justice in the Nicaragua caseFootnote 123 and more recently in the Nuclear Weapons case.Footnote 124
In the case of humanitarian intervention, the application of this principle becomes uncertain, as it is not based on the conventional Charter rights to use force but on a lex ferenda. However, Gardam points out that the proportionality principle is also relevant to any action taken under Chapter VII. This is confirmed by a statement of the former UN Secretary-General Perez de Cuellar, who declared that the Council must ‘satisfy itself that the rule of proportionality in the employment of armed force is observed’, extending the principle to cover situations envisaged by Article 42 (i.e. the authorized use of force).Footnote 125 It may therefore be inferred that an emerging norm must also be subject to the same customary principles.
In light of the proportionality requirement, the following question arises: to what extent can military intervention achieve its aim of protecting persons from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes against humanity, while ensuring that the intervention itself respects human rights and prevents further violations? If the Security Council or NATO cannot satisfy this legal requirement, which they failed to do in Kosovo, military intervention can be deemed disproportionate and counterproductive. Considering once again SC Res 1820's operative paragraph 1, which ambiguously infers that the Council may exercise its Chapter VII powers to counter systematic sexual violence, how can the Council ensure that the use of force will not merely be a catalyst for new forms of sexual violence as seen in Kosovo?
Proportionality assessments of intervention currently do not incorporate any understanding of the impact upon women. Conventional measurements look at the degree of aggression employed by the hostile states, and even the impact upon cultural property and the environment,Footnote 126 yet fail to take into account the extent of sexual violence that women suffer as a direct and indirect result of military intervention. The above analysis of post-intervention trafficking in Kosovo indicates a need for the international community to incorporate an understanding of women's experiences into their legal assessments. This would require an awareness at the international level of the impact of the use of force on women's lives and women's rights, such as their right to be free from sexual exploitation and abuse, and their right to be free from inhuman and degrading treatment and slavery and slave-like practices. Proportionality assessments must not only consider the immediate effects of intervention but must also take into account the long-term impact of military presence on women's experiences: the disruption in socio-economic stability leading to high numbers of unemployed women, the creation and sustenance of illicit markets, the consolidation of power of male-dominated organized criminal networks, the trafficking of women and girls for forced prostitution, the sexual health of women and the wider community,Footnote 127 and the attitudinal and behavioural transformation of the domestic male population in relation to women and women's bodies in society.
Kosovo does not stand alone with regard to women's devastating experiences of intervention. One can see a pattern emerging in the cases of Kuwait,Footnote 128 AfghanistanFootnote 129 and Iraq,Footnote 130 where ‘saving women’ rhetoric is disjunctive from the reality of women's lives. Terms such as ‘empowerment’ and ‘liberation’ for women have been declared from the platform of the Bush administration and from some sectors of the feminist movement. On pausing to evaluate the reality of women's post-intervention experiences, very few would agree that women have been ‘saved’. Some may hold that intervention is the lesser of two evils for women, echoing the thoughts of NATO's Secretary General: ‘We know the risks of action but we have all agreed that inaction brings even greater dangers’.Footnote 131 Others may argue that the process of liberation is gradual. Nevertheless, the current situation is dire. Women should not be forced to choose between ‘two evils’, nor must they endure years of military presence before a ‘free’ society can emerge.
Conclusion
The outcome of the present analysis puts us in an uncomfortable position. Does exposing the ‘dark side’ of ‘saving women’ and ‘heroic’ narratives mean we must remain inactive in the face of systematic sexual violence? Should we adopt the stance of John Stuart Mill, and recognize that intervention is not the best method of ensuring freedom and liberty; rather, ‘it is during an arduous struggle to become free by their own efforts that these virtues have the best chance of springing up’?Footnote 132 Should women, in contexts of systematic sexual violence, therefore be left to struggle for their own self-determination? The question of whether to intervene or not to intervene in response to sexual violence seems to leave us in a dilemma. But this is not the only way to frame it, between these two alternatives. Orford points out that one must step back from the question of whether to intervene or not and consider instead how international law might be best employed, not at the moment of crisis but as a preventative or deterrent mechanism so that such a crisis point may be avoided.Footnote 133
Some feminists have argued that the answer lies in reform of military culture itself. Connell argues that the military is composed of a diversity of masculinities that are socially constructed, not biologically fixed, and therefore capable of transformation.Footnote 134 Taking a similar viewpoint, Spurling argues that the ‘warrior ethic’, or the hegemonic masculinity within the military, must change before SC Res 1325 and 1880 can take any effect. She argues that militaries are trained to use brute force, and not to keep peace among peoples; any change in the violent culture of the military would be seen as a weakening and emasculation of the army.Footnote 135 Similarly, Featherston points out, ‘if we only train people for war it is far more likely that that is what we will get’.Footnote 136 Adopting this standpoint, one answer may be to improve educational programmes for militaries and peacekeepers, incorporating gender awareness within training strategies. A report produced by the Transnational Crime and Corruption Center and the United Nations Interregional Crime and Justice Research Institute has supported this notion, and suggests the need for a comprehensive training programme for both peacekeepers and local institutionsFootnote 137 that would both raise awareness of the issues of sexual exploitation within peacekeeping regions and improve anti-trafficking capacities.Footnote 138 Mazurana argues that training must include human rights law, especially women's rights.Footnote 139
Another solution may be to refocus attention on SC Res 1325 concerning the advancement of women's participation in decision-making processes and senior-level positions within peacekeeping and military institutions. Mazurana points out that the most successful peacekeeping operations are those that have had more women personnel, strong human rights monitoring mandates, and more civilian and fewer military personnel.Footnote 140 ‘Success’ has been measured, inter alia, on the basis of reports of the local population providing positive interactions with peacekeepers.Footnote 141 Charlesworth and Chinkin, however, have reservations about increasing women's participation in the military, as it implies that the ability to use force is an important part of society and a necessary element of citizenship, which deflects attention away from exploring methods for reducing the use of force, and instead transforms the gender balance of the actors using force.Footnote 142 In the light of interviews with women's organizations across Bosnia-Herzegovina regarding male dominance in the military, Cockburn and Hubic concluded that the women were implicitly asking for a re-gendering of the notion of the soldier and of the military culture, in which the strength of military force in dealing with war criminals and providing security could be accompanied by sensitivity and responsiveness to women's needs and their humanity.Footnote 143
What is required now is a divorce of women's rights from interventionist agendas, so that women's rights are not subsumed into counterproductive narratives and appropriated for their political potency. A genuine understanding of women's experiences would see beyond the crisis point which ‘calls for troops’, and instead would look to the aftermath of their arrival. The convergence of interventionist doctrine with the feminist concern about systematic sexual violence, underscored by ‘saving women’ and ‘heroic’ narratives, has proved to be a relationship of inequality. While women's rights have been conveniently apropriated by governments, the military, and the media to serve their own interests, women's experiences demonstrate that the ‘marriage’ has not turned out to be quite so convenient after all.
Many scholars have pointed to the ‘dark sides’ of humanitarian intervention: state self-interest, neo-imperialism, collateral damage. What the above analysis shows is that there is another ‘dark side’ to this doctrine that often goes unnoticed, that manifests itself in the illicit world of trafficking and forced prostitution; and that, perhaps, the darkest shadow of all is cast upon women.
