‘So true is it that an emperor's word will have more force than arms’ (Cassius Dio 69.8–1ª). The study of the administrative structures that made the ‘force’ of the emperor's word possible is the guiding thread of Tiziana Carboni's thesis, presented here in her first book. Governance through the written word is doubtless one of the main objects of study in the history of the Roman Empire.
C. has dedicated this book to the study of the two most important civil offices in the Empire, the ab epistulis and the a libellis. Both arose from the Princeps’ need to maintain communication with peripheral administrators as well as with his subjects, preferably the cities, but also — and this was a peculiarity of the Roman Empire — private citizens. They were, therefore, essential tools of imperial power that, thanks to their endeavours, gradually widened its scope of action, until it was converted into the only source of justice and law. In a nutshell, the path towards the absolutism of the Roman emperors was paved by the work of these two offices.
C.’s book contains four chapters arranged symmetrically. Chs 1 and 4 address the methodological premises and conclusions, while chs 2 and 3 are dedicated respectively to the study of the people who assumed the running of the ab epistulis and the a libellis (ch. 2) and the analysis of the documents that they produced (ch. 3). C. has decided to focus on the second and the beginning of the third century a.d., from the reign of Hadrian to the Severan dynasty. The reason behind this choice is the relative abundance of evidence, including the documents that were issued, of which she provides an extraordinarily useful inventory. This profusion of documentary evidence is not only a matter of chance, but is also the direct result of the evolution of these two imperial offices and the form of government that was being developed at the time.
In ch. 1, C. presents the state of the question and her research methodology. Acknowledging the constraints of prosopography, she has also decided to include an analysis of the documents issued by the ab epistulis and the a libellis. This is a reasonable approach that should be further developed. It is extremely interesting to address the functioning of Roman imperial administration and not only its structures. How existing problems were tackled, what new conundrums arose and how decisions were effectively implemented are all key questions. The actors and the documentary evidence must be analysed together in their evolution over time, and that is precisely what C. does.
The people involved are studied in ch. 2. The narrative is organised by reigns. This sequence is consistent with Eich's thesis on the personal character of the imperial administration (P. Eich, Zur Metamorphose des politischen Systems in der römischen Kaiserzeit (2005)). Far-removed from the complex bureaucratic structures of modern states, it depended on personal, clientelist relationships with the Princeps. In this connection, C. focuses on two issues: clarifying whether the literary careers of some of those in charge of the ab epistulis were determined by their appointments, and analysing to what extent they set the style of imperial correspondence.
As to the first matter, C. believes that this was not the case. Although literary and legal training were essential to the higher education of the aristocracy, proficiency in these two disciplines was not a requirement for occupying these offices. For the emperor, personal trust was more important than literary skill. Furthermore, and with respect to the possible literary influence of the ab epistulis on the emperor, I believe that it should be recalled that one of the purposes of rhetorical training was to be able to assume the ethos of the person on behalf of whom one was speaking. This is an argument that C. has overlooked. Therefore, in line with W. Williams, JRS 66 (1976), 67–83, it is possible to recognise the style of each emperor in some of the correspondence, even though it was in fact written by his secretaries.
Ch. 3 studies the documentary evidence, of which C. offers an inventory by emperor. The documents have been divided into categories (letters and rescripta) and are in turn listed according to whether they derive from direct sources, inscriptions and papyri, or from indirect sources or legal corpora. Their sheer number is truly overwhelming. Crucial issues such as the method of publication of the rescripta and the possible differences between the apokrimata — understood as the emperor's oral replies — and the rescripta are coherently addressed. Nonetheless, it would be useful to have gone a step further to analyse the functioning of Roman imperial administration on the basis of the content of these documents, many of which are replete with references to administrative procedures.
From the conclusions set out in ch. 4 there emerges an idea central to understanding the Roman Empire. Those in charge of the ab epistulis and the a libellis were not bureaucrats tasked with undertaking technical and specialised work, i.e. the drafting, copying, sending, receiving and filing of documents. Those tasks were performed by the freedmen and slaves under their supervision. They were the figureheads of one of the basic power structures of the emperor, with whom they worked closely. They were at the heart of the Empire's government and their study is essential. This book constitutes an important step in this direction.
