The Poetry of Statius is a collection of essays on ‘the most brilliant and versatile of the Flavian poets’ (vii). It includes a brief preface describing the volume's contents (vii–x), eleven essays (1–237), a bibliography (239–50), an index of passages discussed (251–9), and a general index (261–9). The essays are arranged alphabetically by author, though, in what follows, I will treat them according to the three general subjects on which they focus: the Silvae, the Thebaid, and the scholarly tradition of Statius.
Three essays explore the Silvae. In ‘Stones in the forest: epigraphic allusion in the Silvae’ (19–43), Kathleen Coleman examines why these poems do not make much use of epigraphic quotation. She compellingly argues that, because Statius strives to create a more exciting reality out of the mundane experiences in the lives of his patrons, he generally avoids incorporating inscriptions, but instead ‘replaces the functions of epigraphy with a far more oblique and sophisticated game of words’ (43). Michael Dewar (‘The equine cuckoo: Statius’ Ecus Maximus Domitiani Imperatoris and the Flavian Forum’, 65–83) employs Silvae 1.1 and archaeological evidence to show persuasively that the famous equestrian statue of Domitian was meant both to overshadow the building propaganda of Caesar and Augustus in the Roman Forum, and to be ‘the unifying element in an elaborate series of architectural mouments laying emphasis on the [Flavian] dynasty's commitment to the maintenance of peace in Rome and her dominions by the just reduction of superbi’ (82). Finally, R. Nauta in ‘Statius in the Silvae’ (143–74) argues that Statius’ mode of self-presentation is ‘mostly that of the praise poet’ but that this persona is integrated with others, such as the ‘representative subject’ (with respect to Domitian) and amicus (173). Statius does not offer much biographical information, but when he does it is usually tied to his persona as poet.
The Thebaid is the focus of five papers. Hans Smolenaars in ‘Statius Thebaid 1.72: is Jocasta dead or alive?’ (215–37) contends that Theb. 1.72 ‘miseraque oculos in matre reliqui’ refers to the Sophoclean variant of the Oedipus myth in which Jocasta kills herself just after learning of Oedipus’ identity, and that these words indicate how Statius ‘has selected and combined elements from every version of his predecessors into an original dramatic setting, to be reconstructed only from this phrase … and the earlier traditions it recalls’ (234). D. E. Hill (‘Jupiter in Thebaid 1 again’, 129–41) offers a close reading of Jupiter's entrance and speech at 1.197–247, arguing persuasively that the passage reveals a ‘blustering Jupiter who seems to understand little and to be doing too little to late’ (141). In ‘Battle narrative in Statius, Thebaid’ (85–109), Bruce Gibson examines narrative features by which Statius characteristically differs particularly from Homer and Virgil: for example, the foreshortening of battle narratives, the de-emphasis on fighting by minor characters, the blurring of the demarcations of night and day, the use of similes that involve counterfactuals, and the employment of anachronistic details. Lorenzo Sanna (‘Dust, water and sweat: the Statian puer between charm and weakness, play and war’, 195–214) reads ephebic warriors such as Crenaeus and Parthenopaeus in the Thebaid, Achilles in the Achilleid (one of the few discussions of this poem in the volume), and Pollux in Valerius Flaccus as figures straddling and confusing the distinctions of male and female, childhood and war. He finds Ovid's Narcissus and Hermaphroditus to be particularly important influences. Peter Heslin (‘Statius and the Greek tragedians on Athens, Thebes and Rome’, 111–28) claims that Statius, through his use of competing Euripidean and Sophoclean versions of the Theban myth at the end of the Thebaid, presents Athens as a ‘cosmopolitan’ model for contemporary Rome (123–4) and the Thebaid ‘as a warning not only against the dangers of civil war, but also of imperial over-stretch’ (128). Gianpiero Rosati's ‘Statius, Domitian and acknowledging paternity: rituals of succession in the Thebaid’ (175–93) examines the idea of political and literary succession at the opening and closing of the epic. Statius’ introduction, through its use of the Phaethon myth, provides legitimacy to Domitian as imperial successor, while the epilogue shows Statius as Vergil's legitimate successor.
Finally, two essays take up the scholarly tradition of Statius. In ‘Wandering woods again: from Poliziano to Grotius’ (45–64), Harm-Jan van Dam first explores how the conception of the genre of the Silvae is voiced by scholars through imitiations from the fifteenth to seventeenth centuries. He then discusses the tremendous surge in the study and importance of the Silvae at Leiden in the seventeenth century, and identifies Hugo Grotius (1583–1645) as the dominant catalyst. Valéry Berlincourt (‘“In pondere non magno satis ponderosae …”: Gronovius and the printed tradition of the Thebaid’, 1–18) explains several reasons why Gronovius’ slim edition of the Thebaid (with just forty-one pages of notes), published in 1653, came to dominate the scholarly and printed traditions of the Thebaid for roughly two centuries, stifling other editions, particularly Barth's monumental work (with over 3,000 pages of notes), which appeared in 1664–65.
As these summaries should indicate, The Poetry of Statius (despite its title) does not present a general or comprehensive examination of Statius’ poetry — the Achilleid, for example, is given little attention, much of the volume (though certainly not all) deals with relatively specialized issues, and the essays are not organized according to themes, individual works, or conceptual categories. Nor does this collection represent the wide range of approaches to Statius that have developed over the past few decades. In part, the somewhat unfocused nature of the collection can be accounted for by its origin: the papers result from a symposium at the University of Amsterdam (marking the retirement of Hans Smolenaars, one of the volume's editors). Readers will therefore have to look elsewhere for a comprehensive treatment of the nature of Statius’ art or of his poetic output. Nevertheless, the individual essays are generally of good quality and will certainly be of interest to students and scholars of Statius and of the literature and culture of the Flavian age.
