Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:13:07.397Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Dynamics of a trefoil knotted vortex

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 July 2021

Jie Yao
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX 79409, USA
Yue Yang
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory for Turbulence and Complex Systems, College of Engineering, Peking University, Beijing 100871, PR China
Fazle Hussain*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX 79409, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: fazle.hussain@ttu.edu

Abstract

A slender trefoil knotted vortex is studied using direct numerical simulation of the Navier–Stokes equations for vortex Reynolds numbers ($Re \equiv \varGamma /\nu$, circulation/viscosity) up to 12 000. For initially zero twist ($T_{w,0}=0$), neither the writhe $W_r$ nor the global helicity $H$ is conserved. Initially $W_r$ slowly decreases, then suddenly drops during reconnection and becomes almost constant thence; its evolution is almost $Re$ independent. Before reconnection, $H$ also gradually decreases but sharply increases during reconnection. The evolution of $H$ after reconnection strongly depends on $Re$. While steadily decreasing at low $Re$, $H$ significantly increases before eventually decaying at high $Re$. Flow visualization, helicity decomposition and helical wave decomposition reveal that significant amounts of positive and negative twist helicities are simultaneously generated before and during reconnection. Also, the small leading and large trailing rings resulting from asymmetric reconnection have respectively negative and positive twists, which then decay differently due to different initial values, geometries and mutual induction. In particular, at high $Re$, the twist in the small ring, under stretching by the large trailing ring, decays much faster and even switches sign to become positive by the writhe-to-twist conversion – the main reason for the ‘transient growth’ of $H$. Simulations with non-zero initial twists ($T_{w,0}=7.48$ and $22.48$) reveal that the overall dynamics is similar to the $T_{w,0}=0$ case. Hence, the evolution of the trefoil knotted vortex is mainly governed by $W_r$, not $T_w$, although the latter is found to play an essential role in enstrophy growth as well as energy cascade.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematics of (a) writhe, (b) torsion twist and (c) intrinsic twist. Adapted from Moffatt & Ricca (1992) with permission.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Top, (b) front and (c) side views of the initial configuration of the trefoil knotted vortex (represented by vorticity isosurface at 4 % of maximum initial vorticity colour coded by the helicity density $h$). Note that $R_t-r_t$ and $R_t+r_t$ are the minimum and maximum knot radii, and the blue lines inside the vortex tube denote the vortex centreline.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Time evolution of (a) enstrophy $\varOmega$ and (b) global helicity $H$ for $Re=2000$ (red), $6000$ (blue) and $12\,000$ (black). The dashed lines in (a) denote $\varOmega (t)=\varOmega _0 \exp [-\int ^t_0(2\nu /\sigma ^2)]\,\mathrm {d}t$ with $\sigma =\sqrt {\sigma ^2_0+2\nu t}$, and the inset in (b) shows the long time evolution of $H(t)$ for $Re=6000$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Evolution of flow structures represented by vorticity isosurface at 4 % of maximum initial vorticity ($|\boldsymbol {\omega }|=0.04\omega _0$) shaded with helicity density $h=\boldsymbol {u}\boldsymbol {\cdot }\boldsymbol {\omega }$ for (a) $Re=2000$, (b) $6000$ and (c) $12\,000$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Evolution of extracted vortex centreline (shaded with centreline helicity density $h_c=\boldsymbol {u}\boldsymbol {\cdot }\boldsymbol {T}$) for structures shown in figure 4: (a) $Re=2000$, (b) $6000$ and (c) $12\,000$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Time evolution of the normalized total length $l_c/L_c$ for the vortex knot before reconnection (circle), and for SLR ($\triangle$), LTR ($\triangledown$) and their sum ($\square$): (a) $Re=2000$, (b) $6000$ and (c) $12\,000$. Note that the total length for the $Re=2000$ case (solid lines) is shown in (b,c) as a reference.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Time evolution of the third components of the directed area enclosed by the vortex centrelines $S_3$ for the vortex knot before reconnection (circle), and for SLR ($\triangle$), LTR ($\triangledown$) and their sum ($\square$): (a) $Re=2000$, (b) $6000$ and (c) $12\,000$. Note that the dashed lines represent the theoretical value $4.5{\rm \pi}$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(a) Mean radius $\bar {R}$ and (b) mean $z$-location $\bar {z}$ for the vortex knot before reconnection, and for SLR and LTR for $Re=2000$ (red), $Re=6000$ (blue) and $Re=12\,000\ \textrm {K}$ (black). The bars denote the range between minima and maxima.

Figure 8

Table 1.Fitted values of the propagation velocity for the vortex knot before reconnection ($v_t$) and SLR ($v_s$) and LTR ($v_b$) after reconnection.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Time evolutions of (a) separation distance $\delta (t)$ and (b) $\delta ^2(t)$ for $12\,000$. In panel (b) the dashed lines indicate linear scaling for pre- and post-reconnection, and the inset is $\delta$ as a function of $|t -t_0|$ for pre-reconnection.

Figure 10

Table 2.Fitted values of the prefactors $a^{\pm }$ and $t^{\pm }_0$ for the minimum distance scaling $\delta (t)\sim a^{\pm }|t-t^\pm _0|^{1/2}$. The superscript $\pm$ stands for before ($-$) and after ($+$) the reconnection, respectively.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Time evolutions of (a,c,e) the centreline helicity $H_c$ and (b,d,f) the writhe $W_r$ for the vortex knot before reconnection (circle), and for SLR ($\triangle$), LTR ($\triangledown$) and their sum ($\square$): (a,b) $Re=2000$, (c,d) $6000$ and (e,f) $12\,000$. Note that the black solid lines represent the global helicity $H$, and the black dashed and dash–dotted lines in (a,c,e) represent the total helicity for LTR and SLR, respectively, and the red dashed lines in (d,f) denote $W_r$ for $Re=2000$.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Time evolution of (a) the torsion $T_t$ and (b) the self-link number $L_s$ for the vortex knot before reconnection (circle), and for SLR ($\triangle$), LTR ($\triangledown$) and their sum ($\square$) at $Re=12\,000$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Time evolution of (a) helicity dissipation $H_d$ and (b) $H^{\pm }$ for $Re=2000$ (red), $6000$ (blue) and $12\,000$ (black). Note that the circles in (b) denote $-H^-(t)+H(0)$, with $H(0)=3.52$ the initial global helicity.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Isosurface of (a–c) helicity density $h=\boldsymbol {u}\boldsymbol {\cdot } \boldsymbol {\omega }$ and (d–f) helicity dissipation $h_d=-2\nu \boldsymbol {\omega } \boldsymbol {\cdot }(\boldsymbol {\nabla } \times \boldsymbol {\omega })$ for $Re=6000$ at: (a,d) $t^*=3.74$, (b,e) $t^*=4.29$ and (c,f) $t^*=6.01$. Note that the red and blue colours denote positive and negative of $5\,\%$ of the maximum value, and the transparent (grey) isosurface represents $|\boldsymbol {\omega }|=0.04\omega _0$. The black arrows indicate the direction of vortex rotation.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Vortex lines shaded with helicity density for structures I–VI marked in figure 13. The black arrow indicates the rotating direction of the vortex.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Isosurface of helicity density $h=\boldsymbol {u}\boldsymbol {\cdot } \boldsymbol {\omega }$ for $Re=12\,000$ at: (a) $t^*=3.63$, (b) $t^*=4.29$ and (c) $t^*=6.01$. Note that the red and blue colours denote positive and negative $5\,\%$ of the maximum value, and the transparent (grey) isosurface represents $|\boldsymbol {\omega }|=0.04\omega _0$.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Time evolution of the generalized twist $\tilde {T}_w$ (calculated as $H/\varGamma ^2-W_r$) for the vortex knot before reconnection (circle), and for SLR ($\triangle$), LTR ($\triangledown$) and their sum ($\square$): (a) $Re=2000$, (b) $6000$ and (c) $12\,000$.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Schematic of (a) asymmetric reconnection of two vortex filaments with opposite sign of helicity density, and (b) mutual induction between two co-axial vortex rings. The black arrows denote the rotating direction of the vortex filaments, and the green arrows represent the induced velocity.

Figure 19

Figure 18.The right-handed (a–c) and left-handed (d–f) polarized components for vortical structures shown in figure 13: (a,d) $t^*=3.74$, (b,e) $t^*=4.29$ and (c,f) $t^*=6.01$. Note that red and blue denotes positive and negative of $20\,\%$ of the maximum value of $h^\pm$; and the transparent (grey) isosurface represents $|\boldsymbol {\omega }|=0.04\omega _0$.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Time evolution of (a) enstrophy, (b) energy, (c) helicity and (d) rate of change of helicity for right-hand (dashed) and left-hand (dotted) polarized structures at $Re=2000$ (red), $6000$ (blue) and $12\,000$ (black). The global enstrophy, energy and helicity, which are the sum of right- and left-hand components, are shown in (a–c). Note that the circles in (c) denote $-H^L(t)+H(0)$, with $H(0)=3.52$ the initial global helicity.

Figure 21

Figure 20.(a,c,e) Kinetic energy spectrum $E(k)$ of the total structures and (b,d,f) helicity spectrum for the right- and left-handed components at several instants for: (a,b) $Re=2000$, (c,d) $6000$ and (e,f) $12\,000$.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Evolution of flow structures represented by vorticity isosurface at 4 % of maximum initial vorticity (shaded in colour with helicity density) for (a) $Re=2000$ and (b) $Re=6000$ with $T_{w,0}=22.48$.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Time evolution of (a) the length $l_c$, (b) the writhe $W_r$ and (c) the centreline helicity $H_c$ of the vortex knot before reconnection (circle), and for SLR ($\triangle$), LTR ($\triangledown$) and their sum ($\square$) for $Re=6000$ with initial twist $T_{w,0}=22.48$. Note that the solid lines in (a,b) are the total length and the helicity $W_r$ for $Re=6000$ with $T_{w,0}=0$ cases, and in (c) are the global helicity $H$ for $Re=6000$ with $T_{w,0}=22.48$.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Time evolution of (a) the enstrophy $\varOmega$ and (b) global helicity $H$ for different initial twist and Reynolds numbers. The dashed lines in (a,b) denote $\varOmega (t)=\varOmega _0 \exp [-\int ^t_0(2\nu /\sigma ^2)]\,\textrm {d}t$ and $H(t)=\varGamma ^2W_r(0)+\varGamma ^2T_w(0) \exp [-\int ^t_0(2\nu /\sigma ^2)\,\textrm {d}t]$ with $\sigma =\sqrt {\sigma ^2_0+2\nu t}$, respectively.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Time evolution of (a) $H^{\pm }$, (b) enstrophy, (c) energy and (d) helicity for $Re=6000$ with $T_{w,0}=0$ (black) and $T_{w,0}=22.48$ (blue). The solid, dashed and dotted lines in (a) denote $H$, $H^+$ and $H^-$, respectively, and in (b–d) represent quantities for global, right-handed and left-handed components.

Figure 26

Figure 25.(a) Kinetic energy spectrum $E(k)$ of the total structures and (b) helicity spectrum for the right- and left-handed components at several instants for $Re=6000$ and $T_{w,0}=22.48$ case. The insets in (a,b) show the comparison of $E(k)$ and $H^R(k)$ at $t^*=4.45$ between $T_{w,0}=0$ (solid) and $T_{w,0}=22.48$ (dashed) cases, respectively.

Figure 27

Figure 26.Time evolution of (a) enstrophy $\varOmega$ and (b) global helicity $H$ for $Re=2000$ (red), $6000$ (blue) with different grid resolutions.

Figure 28

Figure 27.Schematic illustration of the Batchelor vortex. Note that the red arrow represents the rotation direction of the vortex, and the purple line denotes the vortex lines.

Figure 29

Figure 28.Time evolution of the global helicity $H$ for the co-axial oppositely twisted vortex rings. Flow structures are represented by vorticity isosurface at 4 % of maximum initial vorticity shaded with positive (red) and negative (blue) helicity densities.