Edinburgh in 1828 was a leading center for the study of anatomy. Accordingly, anatomists needed bodies and, until the Anatomy Act of 1832, there were few legal sources. Given the high level of demand, a good body could fetch between £8 and £20. The major sources of supply were shipments from Ireland and the digging up of the recently buried. Dr. Robert Knox was the major buyer. One night a pensioner died in a lodging house, and after supplying a coffin, the four permanent occupants of the house decided to remove his body and replace it with tanner's bark. They then sold his body to Dr. Knox for seven pounds and ten shillings. Realizing the financial benefits to be gained by such transactions, the four members of the household established a body-supply business. During the course of a year, 13 people were murdered solely for the purpose of selling their bodies to Dr. Knox. This was the infamous case of Burke and Hare, who were assisted by their wives, M'Dougal and Log. Only Burke and M'Dougal were tried; Hare and Log were given immunity by supplying evidence. Burke was hung. M'Dougal was found not guilty of murder; her lawyer argued that as a wife she was only obeying the demands of her husband and that she had not been directly involved. It seems that the chief reason for the verdict was that people at the time did not believe women were capable of such horrendous crimes. M'Dougal, Hare, and Log left Edinburgh and disappeared.
Most of the book details the various aspects of this case, such as who, where, and how each person was murdered. Ironically, however, this is not the main purpose of the book. Dr. Deborah Symonds's main hypothesis is that crime was a business organized on a household basis, and that it shifted and followed the nature and course of the larger legitimate economy. In this environment criminals not only preyed upon visitors to the neighborhood, but also upon their neighbors. Their actions were tolerated, and indeed, considered as an acceptable means of surviving. Hence, Dr. Knox and his assistants must have been aware that the bodies supplied to them by Burke and Hare had been murdered; yet it was to their advantage to overlook this possibility. Similarly, neighbors must have been suspicious of the containers leaving the lodging house and the sudden displays of wealth by the household. They ignored these facts as long as they could, but became enraged when they discovered the full extent of the murders and the real possibility that they could be next. The case is an example of the economics of crime; the high prices for the bodies were a function of supply and demand. To further support her arguments, Dr. Symonds briefly relates a number of other crimes, all theft; however, the connections are weak, unconvincing, and somewhat annoying (as is the frequent repetition).
Dr. Symonds places great weight on the location of the various crimes mentioned. A small map is provided (p. xii), but it does not cover the whole of the area described by her. A more complete, larger map would be useful for those unfamiliar with Edinburgh. In a similar vein, because of the stress placed upon the prices paid for bodies, the graph presented (p. 134) is inadequate and incomprehensible without detailed study. Furthermore, insufficient mention of the graph is made in the text.
The book is well researched. It contains 32 pages of endnotes. Some of the most interesting material is contained in the notes. This material should have been included in the main text.
The main hypothesis of this book is that criminals are entrepreneurs looking for economic opportunities and they base their operations within a household. Accordingly, the nature of crimes changes as the economy changes. The objects stolen fluctuate in value according to the laws of supply and demand. Dr. Symonds uses the watch as one example; prior to reliable mass production, watches were a valuable, necessary aspect of industrialization, fetching high prices on the black market. Similarly, the human life became, because of the development of scientific anatomy, a valuable object of crime. Burke and Hare were entrepreneurs who saw opportunities and tapped into this market area, even planning to expand their business operations by establishing branches in Glasgow and Ireland (p. 135). The fact that human life became a saleable object of crime represented a new element of the shadow economy.
I am not convinced that the book successfully demonstrates a transformation of the underworld in Edinburgh; indeed, the exact nature of this transformation is not clearly stated. The view that criminals are entrepreneurs is not new. The Burke and Hare case may have eventually led to a reform of the Anatomy Act, but Burke and Hare did not bring about a transformation of the shadow economy, unless it is argued that other entrepreneurs took their place. This did not happen; even the shadow economy had its acceptable standards, and the public outrage impacted on the level of demand, insuring that murderers could not benefit financially from their actions. The Burke and Hare episode was unique. Edinburgh's underworld continued to operate as before. In other words, the economics of crime did not change.
In spite of these reservations, I found this book an interesting read. It does provide a clear and concise account of Burke and Hare, giving a new perspective to the case.
