Maurits H. van den Boogert's Aleppo Observed, the sixth instalment in Oxford University Press's Arcadian Library series, provides a thorough account of the lives and work of two Scottish doctors, Alexander Russell (1715–1768) and Patrick Russell (1727–1805), who served overlapping terms as physician to the English merchants at the Levant Company's factory at Aleppo in northern Syria between 1740 and 1772. At the centre of the study is one book, The Natural History of Aleppo, written by Alexander, published in 1756, and expanded into a two-volume edition by Patrick in 1794. As Boogert points out in his introduction, the ‘natural history’ of the title is a broad term effectively referring to all living things: the work embraced zoology, botany, meteorology, medicine and (what we might now call) anthropology – the study of human culture in its widest sense. However, Boogert also brings to light several of the Russell brothers’ other publications – many of them printed in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society – and assesses their activities in a diverse array of scientific disciplines, which went well beyond the city with which their name remains linked.
The picture which emerges is of a significant, if sporadic, contribution to eighteenth-century science. Patrick Russell's work on Indian snakes (pursued during a stint as surgeon and naturalist to the East India Company at Madras), for example, Boogert signals as ‘groundbreaking’ (p. 64). His research on fish collected at Visakhapatnam on the Coromandel Coast was, says Boogert, ‘an important contribution to ichthyology’ (p. 65). Alexander Russell's reputation as a botanist rests largely on his detailed description of the ‘true scammony’ (Convolvulus scammonia), the dried juice extracted from the root of which was used as a hydragogue, and on his introduction of the Arbutus andrachne into English gardens. His most important contribution to medicine was his description of the so-called ‘Aleppo mal’ (cutaneous leishmaniasis), a skin disease transmitted by the bite of the phlebotomine sandfly. However, in both botany and medicine, it is again the younger brother who is depicted as the real innovator: Patrick added a catalogue of over seven hundred Syrian plants to the 1794 edition and adapted his brother's previous identifications to the Linnaean system. Patrick Russell's Treatise of the Plague (1791) extended the research previously undertaken by Alexander to produce what Boogert describes as ‘the most methodical, comprehensive and critical analysis of the literature on the plague available in the West until the end of the eighteenth century’ (p. 178).
However, it is the two brothers' observations on the social life of Ottoman Syria which has proved their most lasting contribution to scholarship. The thirty-plus years they collectively resided in Aleppo, and their privileged status as physicians (in which capacity they treated both European and Ottoman patients) provided them with insights unavailable to previous Western visitors. Through his analysis of Alexander's and Patrick's writings on topics such as marriage and childbirth, Aleppo's religious communities, and the oft-discussed Ottoman harem, Boogert highlights the ways in which the Natural History attempted to provide a more objective account of Syrian society than was available in the frequently prejudiced and inaccurate reports of travellers. The account of Patrick Russell's translations of Islamic marriage contracts (the first, Boogert says, to be printed in the West) and his activities as a collector of Arabic medical, historical and literary manuscripts bring to light some hitherto unexplored aspects of the brothers' careers.
Two preliminary biographical chapters set this work in its social and intellectual contexts. Drawing on archival sources (including a handwritten set of Charles Alston's lectures by Alexander himself), Boogert reconstructs the formative influence of Edinburgh University's medical school. Again, these sections expand the scope of the study beyond Ottoman Syria and bring to light the Russell brothers' significant roles in the scientific circles of eighteenth-century London. Alexander emerges as an important figure behind the London-based ‘Society of Physicians’, an informal group established in the early 1750s which discussed and published medical case studies, and as a reforming influence on the fringes of the Royal College of Physicians. Both Alexander and Patrick were active members of the Royal Society, and both were called upon to advise the Privy Council as experts on the plague.
Ultimately, however, Boogert's assessment of Alexander and Patrick Russell's achievement is somewhat muted. In a sense, the Natural History appeared at a juncture between two distinct genres: whereas it clearly surpassed older travellers' accounts in its descriptive precision, the fact that it was necessarily limited to the data collected by two busy professionals meant that it fell short of the kind of systematic treatises which, through the endeavours of the likes of Carsten Niebuhr (an associate of Patrick Russell's), were beginning to be produced towards the end of the eighteenth century. What emerges frequently from Boogert's account – in the brothers' decision not to add previously identified plants to their catalogue, for example, or in Patrick's neglect of the available secondary literature on smallpox inoculation – is a portrait of two practitioners working in isolation from an accumulated body of scientific knowledge. For this reason, Boogert concludes that credit for genuine discoveries is often shared with more distinguished scientists, and that the scientific value of the Natural History declined after the end of the eighteenth century. On the plague, the interest at the very centre of the first edition, both Alexander and Patrick were mistaken regarding its cause, inevitably decreasing the reputation of their works on the topic. The Natural History's ethnographical observations continue to be cited by Ottoman historians today. Ultimately, however, Boogert concludes that we should remain aware of their limitations. Most significantly, the brothers' primary occupation as physicians often meant that their interests in other fields were refracted through the prism of their professional concerns.
Despite these limitations, the work of the Russell brothers will no doubt remain of interest to historians both of eighteenth-century scientific culture and of Ottoman Syria. Although aspects of their work have been explored before – most recently by Barbara Hawgood and Janet Starkey – a full-length biography has been notably missing for some time. Boogert's elegantly written and informative book admirably fills this gap. Like previous Arcadian Library publications, the study is richly complemented by numerous illustrations from the work of the Russells and their contemporaries.
