Chicago Made is a fascinating, detailed study of factory districts in Chicago at the beginning of the twentieth century. Robert Lewis, a University of Toronto geographer, immersed himself deeply in both the business history and Chicago history literatures, but neither the economic nor economic history literatures. How much the book suffers from the absence of the latter two is a matter of perspective. Given the level of detail at which Lewis presents most of his findings, he is on firm footing. Given the level of generality on which the context for his case studies rest, he could have benefited from both literatures.
The book is divided into two sections. The first discusses the building of industrial Chicago around factory districts; the second, how the city's industrial districts were networked. A relatively short introduction sets the stage. The year is 1911, and a group of Chicago executives are about to embark on an inspection tour of industrial districts on the city's periphery. The purpose is to convince those leaders—and Lewis' readers —that “rational metropolitan growth was a necessity” (p. 2), that “factory districts could only be achieved through the building of industrial linkages across the wider metropolis” (p. 3).
Geographers consider central factory districts to be the primary locus of manufacturing employment until the 1940s. However, through annexation and consolidation, what was a suburban factory district when initially constructed ultimately became part of the city. Lewis comments that such districts have been little studied, especially those from the 1800s because nonresidential suburbanization is not thought to be important until the 1920s. Chicago's stockyards are one of four case studies in chapter 3. The first yards, usually adjacent to inns, were sprinkled throughout the city. Many animals were allowed to roam free to forage in the gutters. As more and more animals arrived via railroads, this practice proved a nuisance, and stockyards were banned from Chicago. The solution, engineered by the railroads, was the Union Stock Yards that opened in 1865 in the adjoining suburb of Lake. As the industry evolved, the major packers sold meat at a slim margin above cost and made their profits on by-product utilization. The industrial district formed by these firms, and the firms they supplied, returned to the city in 1889 when Lake annexed itself to Chicago.
As Lewis notes, manufacturers “made the place”; they created the necessary infrastructure. Suburban firms were firmly tied to the central city through their demand for the accountants, lawyers, and wholesalers who located there. Interfirm relationships within the metropolis proved an important determinant of how Chicago was built. Interfirm relationships across metropolitan areas helped to determine the city's growth relative to other central cities.
The first section begins with a statistical snapshot of Chicago's industrial structure circa 1880 and 1924. Lewis then turns to a discussion of suburbanization. While he describes the resistance of some to a suburban location, that firms would move to the periphery was inevitable. First, Chicago's location, where the Chicago River empties into Lake Michigan over 20 miles due north of the bottom of the lake, made increasingly less economic sense as water transportation gave way to rail. His discussion of the growth of the Calumet district in chapter 6 is among the places where the narrative would have benefited from the economics of location. Second, as Lewis mentions, factory technology changed over the period. Simply put, factories were built out instead of up. Four four-story factories on one city block had to move before the land could be used for one one-story factory. When the city had few vacant blocks, a firm building a modern factory had little choice other than a suburban location.
The second section focuses on the geography of firm linkages. Lewis' primary source for this is a set of bankruptcy records that he has mined to great effect. What he finds is illuminating, but he does not inquire into its representativeness. Many of the statistics he reports could have been compared to census data, but this was not done. Nonetheless, the middling firms that make up his sample enable him to establish the ties between firms at a very detailed level. He notes that manufacturers were “underrepresented” in the Loop, but given the need to move materials in and out of factories, given the Loop's elevated land rents, it cannot be surprising that factories largely had left the city center. Lewis follows the networks across the city—and across the United States—for such industries as automobile, furniture, metalworking, and steel, to name but a few.
The book concludes with a summary of the major points. In particular, “The decentralization of industry out of the city core was a major force driving the development of a multinucleated metropolis. Metropolitan Chicago's manufacturing geography, with its incremental decentralization and continued specialization of factory districts, was based on a cyclical process of economic change involving an assortment of industries that can be traced back to the mid-nineteenth century. The formation of factory districts on the urban fringe has always been part of Chicago's growth” (p. 270). He then presses further to present a sympathetic discussion of labor's plight, a discussion that is signaled throughout the book, especially when the word “profit” is employed in a pejorative context.
Chicago Made presents a remarkable depiction of Chicago's industrial development. It explains the linkages between the individual industries (and personalities) that have been widely studied by others. Chicago Made is essential reading for anyone with an interest in Chicago and its industries, but economists and economic historians will leave with a sense that it could have been just that much more.
