The history of Latin popular music and its role in the formulation of the notion of latinidad in the United States is complex in its geographical and historical scope. Scholars have tackled this topic from varying disciplinary perspectives to include ethnomusicology, anthropology and history. To be sure, these studies have mostly focused on histories of Mexican American music and music of the Spanish-speaking Caribbean. Christina D. Abreu's book, Rhythms of Race: Cuban Musicians and the Making of Latino New York City and Miami, 1940–1960, studies Cuban music's contributions to this process of Latinisation in the mid-twentieth century. This was a key historical moment given the extent to which black and white Cuban musicians and migrants participated in its formulation across the spectrum of US popular media and in their own communities. With Rhythms of Race Abreu attempts to understand this history of Latinisation by asking what it meant for these musicians and their fellow migrants to be ‘“Cuban”, “Afro-Cuban”, “Latin”, “Negro/Black”, “Hispano/a”, and “Latino/a” on the stages, dance floors, television and movie screens, and crowded streets of New York City and Miami in the 1940s and 1950s’ (p. 15). The author addresses this question by engaging with the complexities of these national and ethnoracial categories as these materialised in the lived experiences of musicians out of which developed, Abreu argues, a collective cultural consciousness of latinidad in all its contradictions (p. 19).
Abreu takes her understanding of Latinisation or latinidad from the work of sociologist Agustín Laó-Montes, who considers discourses of Latinisation as materialising across cultural, social, and political arenas and from the actions of migrants as well as of corporate and governmental bodies. With this analytical framework in place, the author focuses her examination on three themes. The first involves the differences in experiences among Cuban musicians as they operated within US and Cuban systems of race relations and in response to US popular culture's demands of embodying racial difference. Abreu's analysis of Mario Bauzá’s musical career in Havana and Harlem brings to the fore the ambiguity, if not contradictions, between and within US and Cuban systems of race relations. Moreover, in tracing Bauzá’s work in New York within the colonia hispana, the author addresses the strategies that black Cubans forged to contest the racism they encountered from other Latinos/as and in Spanish-language newspapers. For Bauzá, his strategy was to reject the category ‘Latin music’ and to reinforce his sense of blackness by emphasising the centrality of Afro-Cuban music. While his blackness – along with that of his peers Francisco ‘Machito’ Grillo and Miguelito Valdés – authenticated their music as Afro-Cuban from the perspectives of their audiences in New York and Miami, it often limited the extent to which they could expand and sustain their careers beyond the local.
The book's second theme intersects with the first in that it considers how Cuban musicians negotiated the difference in consumption habits of Cuban and other Latino/a audiences in relation to Anglo-American audiences. It is in this discursive space that other Cuban musicians contested the category ‘Latin’ music in favour of the national categories ‘Cuban’ and ‘Afro-Cuban’ music. Abreu shows, for instance, how Xavier Cugat (who was born in Spain but raised in Cuba) negotiated his racialisation as non-white and non-black by the conflicting perspectives of his Anglo-American audiences in order to enable his music to be read as authentically Afro-Cuban and Latin. The author studies the reception of the similarly raced musicians Marco Rizo, José Curbelo, Arturo ‘Chico’ O'Farrill and Desi Arnaz. The collapsing of Afro-Cuban music into a homogenised conception of Latinness was especially potent as a result of Desi Arnaz's professional output from the early 1940s through to I Love Lucy, in which he was leading man and producer.
For those interested in tracing the history of the notions Latino/a and Hispano/a in the United States, the book's third theme is particularly insightful. Abreu provides rich documentation from newspaper editorials, oral histories of musicians and local Cuban social club records to show just how these notions were, on the one hand, fraught with ambiguity for Cubans and, on the other, integral to their experiences as immigrants. With El Club Cubano Inter-Americano as one of her main case studies, Abreu shows how black Cuban musicians Generoso Montesino, Alberto Socarrás, Marcelino Guerra and Arsenio Rodríguez, along with the club members for whom they performed, contributed to not only the formation of but also the need for a more racially and ethnically inclusive Hispano/a and Latino/a identity while at the same time foregrounding their identities as black Cubans. What is more, Abreu is careful to also analyse these histories of Cuban social clubs in New York and Miami within the contexts of World War II, its aftermath and Jim Crowism, in which their expressions of pan-Americanism was yet another form of materialising a collective sense of latinidad, albeit racialised as white.
Abreu rightly claims that this book helps bridge the gap between studies of Cuban migrants at the turn of the twentieth century and those of the Cuban Revolution that claim 1959 as ‘the moment of origin for Cuban migration to the United States’ (p. 6). The author accomplishes this by researching oral histories and an impressive breadth of newspapers (Spanish-language included) published in New York City and Miami. Her analysis of New York's La Prensa and Miami's Diario las Américas is particularly productive in tracing the circulation of latinidad and hispanidad among Cuban migrants. It is curious, however, that Down Beat was not one of the author's sources given the extent to which this major jazz trade magazine often represented Afro-Cuban music as synonymous with Latin music. Still, Abreu productively analyses her sources for insight into the imagined and lived realities of race and class, doing so through the lenses of thick description, discourse analysis and identity formations. Her chapter on Cubans in Miami pre-1959 makes an especially unique and needed contribution to scholarship on Latin music. Indeed, Rhythms of Race joins the growing scholarship on Afro-Latina/o cultures and histories to bring to critical light the long presence of Latinos/as, in all their diversity, in the United States.
