In the twenty-two years since Thomas Postlewait and Bruce McConachie published their edited volume Interpreting the Theatrical Past: Essays in the Historiography of Performance (Iowa City: Iowa University Press, 1989), the field of theatre historiography has become increasingly complex, as feminist and gender studies, performance studies, and other fields of critical theory have exerted more and more influence across the humanities. In his new text, Postlewait acknowledges this broadening of perspectives; however, rather than parsing these developing areas, the author focuses his energy on laying out the basic elements of historical inquiry that apply to both theatre and performance studies.
Postlewait begins his study with two stated purposes: first, to lay out the fundamental skills and techniques necessary to write theatre history; and second, to instill in the reader the proper mind-set for historical writing, particularly regarding the questions historians pursue through their work. In fulfilling these goals, the author has produced a readable synthesis that explores the issues central to the researching and writing of history. He brings together scholars from within and from outside the theatrical field, a choice that emphasizes the necessity of connecting performance to historical work beyond the theatre. In doing so, Postlewait notes both the successes and failures of previous historians, including his own missteps—a refreshing admission that points to the difficulties attendant on the relatively unfixed nature of historical evidence.
The author employs a number of case studies as the primary means of illustrating particular issues. Take, for instance, his refutation of the scandal accompanying the premiere performance(s) of Jarry's Ubu Roi, which serves as an example of how narrative tropes can overcome historical evidence. In addition to these case studies, Postlewait also makes extensive use of lists, further focusing his efforts to hone in on the nuts and bolts of writing history. Perhaps most prevalent is his extensive use of questions, which can at times feel overwhelming; it can become quite easy to get lost in some of the longer strings of questions. And yet even this choice seems apt, as it reflects the inquisitiveness—and sometimes the inundation—of the historian.
The text is divided into four parts. Part I seeks to diminish the supposed differences between documentary and cultural historical approaches. Instead, Postlewait argues that historical inquiry into any performance event requires attention to both the documentary evidence and the cultural context, and that neither should be prized above the other. Part II examines the differences between the aesthetic and historical significance of theatrical events, at the heart of which lies the layering of historical contexts of the performers, the audiences, the cultural milieu, and even the playscript itself. In Part III, the author focuses on the ways in which external organizational tools, such as periodization and political contextualization, can affect the interpretation and representation of history. Postlewait emphasizes that, while we cannot be entirely free from the layers of distance (linguistic, temporal, locational) between the historian and the event, the recognition of this distance allows for the issue to be acknowledged and minimized.
The fourth and final part in the text presents an extensive primer on the twelve “cruxes” surrounding theatrical events. Each crux emphasizes a particular area of examination, ranging from the self-contained event to the tropes historians use to present their ideas to a contemporary audience. Throughout Part IV, Postlewait supplements his points with a detailed case study on the 1889 London production of A Doll's House, which he earlier describes in Chapter 4. The effect is to reinforce the necessity of at least addressing each crux, without suggesting a rigid structural pattern for historical inquiry.
This book should prove to be an invaluable resource to a number of people. For graduate students, it represents an entertaining and accessible entryway into the field of theatre historiography, which also makes it an ideal text for instructors of courses in research methods. Theatre history teachers should also find this book to be a useful model for communicating to students not only what we know but also how we know it—or in some cases, why some historians get it wrong. Finally, seasoned theatre historians should find time to read this text; much as veteran actors remind themselves of the basic principles of their craft, scholars certainly benefit from an occasional reminder of the schemata that underlie the writing of history.
