The defeat of Reconstruction, although certainly a setback for African Americans, did not mark the destruction of African-American resistance to social and economic exploitation. In the last two decades of the nineteenth century, blacks in the South waged an increasingly puissant class struggle on several fronts: local, state, and national. From Texas to the Carolinas, African American farmers, sharecroppers, and workers united. As part of the populist movement, they challenged the economic, social, and political power of the landed and industrial elite. The conceit of author Omar H. Ali is that the history of black populism has not been given due attention and has been either ignored or treated as a creature of the white populists.
Black populism developed in the mid-1880s from a brew of local organizations dedicated to improving the conditions and standing of African American farmers. The southern branch of the Knights of Labor (which upheld a commitment to interracial organizing), the Colored Agricultural Wheel, the Cooperative Workers of America, and other organizations were built largely on local and statewide lines and were concerned primarily with economic and labor issues. In December 1886 local organizing took a qualitative leap with the formation in east Texas of the Colored Farmers Alliance (CFA). By 1890 its adherents numbered in the hundreds of thousands. African American farmers and agrarian laborers shared an overlapping, but not identical, set of problems with their white counterparts. At times blacks sought to cooperate with whites—indeed, one of the CFA's founders and first spokesman was Richard Humphrey, a white man whose work earned him distinction as a “friend of the race.” However, such close cooperation was exceptional, and black populism charted a path independent of the white Southern Farmers Alliance.
Rather, black and white Farmers Alliances worked together on specific actions, such as a campaign to abolish the Louisiana lottery and a boycott of the “Jute Trust,” which had raised prices on the fabric used to wrap cotton bales; the black alliance also endorsed the white alliance's “subtreasury” loan plan. Not surprisingly, areas of friction abounded. For example, the CFA endorsed a raft of civil rights measures like the Lodge Bill of 1890, which protected black men's franchise, whereas the Southern Farmers Alliance held fast to “states' rights,” code words for white supremacy. The CFA included in its ranks sharecroppers and laborers as well as landowners, but white planters exercised disproportionate influence within the Southern Alliance. The conflict between the alliances reached a head during the 1891 cotton-pickers' strike. With cotton prices falling precipitously, farmers demanded a fair price for their crop, while workers, who were predominantly black, demanded fair wages. The Southern Alliance, dominated by large landowners, adamantly objected when the CFA called for the strike to enforce a minimum wage of fifty cents per 100 pounds of picked cotton. The Southern Alliance's solid opposition, combined with armed force and severe intimidation of the largely black cotton pickers, crushed the strike.
In Ali's fine rendering, the CFA drew an important lesson from the strike. Economic weapons, like strikes and boycotts, were insufficient to advance the cause of black farmers and laborers. In order to confront the power of the large landowners the CFA would have to engage in independent political action to directly challenge the Democratic Party, the party of the large landowners. CFA leaders were among the first to call for the formation of a third party when white alliancemen still cast their lot with the Democrats.
The People's Party debuted nationally in 1892 and drew significant strength from African Americans in states where the CFA and its predecessors had been active. Black populists' platforms varied by state, but North Carolina's appeared to be typical, with its emphasis on a fair, free, and secret ballot, support for the Lodge bill, federal appropriations for education, local electoral reform, and opening up jury service to African Americans. According to Ali, however, the sine qua non of black populists was defeating or splitting the Democratic Party; this often meant making compromises, such as not running black candidates on the Populist ticket (but capturing leadership positions within the party) or supporting disaffected Republican and even Democratic office seekers rather than Populists. Tactical flexibility paid off in the 1892 elections with Populist victories in Kansas, Texas, Louisiana, and Arkansas. African-American office holding increased in elections between 1890 and 1895, as well, although a preponderance of the winners ran as Republicans, not Populists. Fusion campaigns were highly successful, especially in North Carolina. Electoral gains brought out all manner of resistance from the Democrats: violence, changes in election laws, and ballot-box stuffing were three significant ways the party of white supremacy fought black populism and brought its insurgency to an end by 1900.
In the Lion's Mouth is well written, but it suffers from analytical weaknesses. Three are worth noting. First is an overly expansive definition of black populism. In Ali's view, black populists include not only African-American members of the People's Party but disaffected Republicans and others who challenged Democratic Party rule but, due to political considerations, did not identify as Populist. Much of the book privileges a discussion of the savvy nature of African American politicking, which is an important corrective for those who believe that populism was an exclusively white affair. However, the black populist program for a restructured economy and polity and how it differed from other parties' and organizations' platforms is given too little attention. Second, Ali claims at the outset that black populists had a nationalist sensibility—that is, they placed a value on separate organization. Maybe, but the assertion deserves fuller exploration, for at other times the evidence strongly indicates that separate organizing was primarily a function of the white Farmers Alliance's practice of racial exclusion. For Ali, however, the mere fact of separate black political organizing supersedes even the importance of the black populists' political program. Third, Ali prefaces his study with the provocative observation that black populism shared much in common with independent black political action in the Caribbean and South America but never mentions it again. In the Lion's Mouth is an important survey of black political activism in the 1880s and 1890s but does not surpass—either in narrative or analysis—Gerald Gaither's pioneering Blacks and the Populist Revolt (1977).
