This deeply researched study elegantly explores prostitution, an important yet little studied topic in nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Cuban history, and specifically its relationship to the state and to nation-building processes. The book charts an admirable course between depth and breadth. Its rigour and detail will make it very useful to those with a more specialist interest in the topic, while for students or general readers, the book provides original and fresh perspectives on much broader themes across nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Cuban history more generally.
Lacking a single or obvious source base to which to turn, Sippial has been creative and original in her research strategy, and the book draws on an impressively diverse range of materials. The earlier parts of the work, in particular, draw closely on archival sources, mainly located across the collections of Havana's rich National Archive, pertaining to judicial, policing, legal or administrative matters regarding prostitution. Throughout, the book also draws on a diverse array of published primary materials, particularly Cuban newspapers and contemporary medical treatises on prostitution.
The book is ambitious in its chronological scope, charting the changing and complex relationship between prostitution and the state from the mid-nineteenth century, when Cuba remained the ‘ever faithful’ Spanish colony, through the abolition of slavery and the independence wars that marked the late nineteenth century, and into the early twentieth-century period of US occupation and frustrated nationalism. Along the way the author charts how the story of prostitution in Cuba both intersected with, and significantly departed from, international trends. From about the mid-nineteenth century, colonial officials gradually embraced the official regulation of prostitution, following ‘hygienic’ approaches adopted in, for example, Paris and Madrid. The regulatory mechanism that receives the most attention here is the establishment of a ‘tolerance zone’ in the city of Havana by 1873. In studying the shifting parameters and political significance of this zone, the author sheds new light on Havana's socio-spatial history, charting the city's rapid nineteenth-century expansion and the demolition of the city walls that transformed the city's geography. Like so many other works on ‘Cuba’, this is principally an urban, Havana story, although it certainly opens the way for historians of other Cuban regions to tell their own stories about prostitution and particular regional responses to it.
The author then explores how, between the late 1860s and the 1890s, diverse voices within Cuban society began to raise objections about colonial regulation policy. These voices ranged from medical doctors, influenced by ‘scientific’ approaches toward race and progress, to a raucous, short-lived Havana publication, La Cebolla, which purported to contain the writings of Havana prostitutes themselves. Concerns about ‘progress’ became closely entwined with nationalist demands: taking advantage of national ferment and a moment of decreased censorship after the end of the Ten Years’ War against Spain (1868–78), regulated prostitution became a metaphor for everything that was wrong with colonial government itself.
Following the US occupation after 1898, the new administration sought a thorough overhaul of diverse aspects of Cuban life, including significant public health initiatives, most notably the campaigns to eradicate yellow fever. However, Sippial points out that the North Americans left the regulated prostitution system largely intact. Even Havana's Spanish-instituted tolerance zone itself, which was increasingly controversial in a fast-changing city landscape, remained mainly unchanged. This came at a time when ‘modern’ (European) societies were turning away from regulated prostitution, when prostitution was not regulated on the US mainland itself, and when prostitution was promptly deregulated for Puerto Rico after 1917, when Puerto Ricans became US citizens. By contrast with such developments, the maintenance of regulated prostitution in Cuba was interpreted by critics on the island as a symbol of coloniality, whether a hangover from Spanish policies or the embodiment of a neocolonial approach by the US administration. For Sippial, ‘Cubans … constructed a uniquely nationalistic case for reform as a means of advancing their own decolonisation process’ (p. 181). Interestingly, the familiar images that immediately spring to mind of Cuba as a US ‘playground’, for gambling but also prostitution, are absent from this analysis, which focuses more on prostitution as a local and national phenomenon, albeit influenced by US-driven policies during the occupation period.
The final chapter reveals how, following mounting criticism, prostitution was finally deregulated under President García Menocal in 1913. Prostitution and venereal disease began to be treated separately, the latter being reconceptualised as a broader public health problem. Meanwhile, a complex web of new voices added their views on the prostitution issue. By the 1920s, international organisations were lobbying against the alleged ‘white slave trade’ in trafficked European women. They, as well as new burgeoning Cuban feminist organisations, joined the other voices on the island that, by this point, were pushing for greater controls on immigration. Thus the book shows fascinatingly how concerns about prostitution and ‘trafficking’ specifically helped bolster the broader xenophobic turn in Cuba during these years.
One area in which perhaps more questions are raised than answered is that of the links between prostitution, race and immigration in the twentieth century. In earlier chapters Sippial explores the image, common in anxious post-emancipation Cuba, of the ‘vicious’ Afro-Cuban prostitute. By the final chapter, on 1902–25, these images jostle with other depictions of prostitutes as trafficked white women who have become victims and are to be protected. Yet at the same time the chapter also explores a wave of suspicion against the physical and moral threat posed by a supposed influx of Caribbean (especially Haitian and Jamaican) prostitutes, as part of the wave of early twentieth-century immigration. Where did these women fit into the ‘victim’ narrative? Might they also appeal to be protected, or did they simply need to be excluded wherever possible? Where did Cuban-born women of colour who became prostitutes – or popular images of such women – fit in? A related point is that there is no mention in this final chapter of the massacres of thousands of Afro-Cubans in 1912, just one year before prostitution was deregulated. This is striking given the book's publication just after the centenary commemorations of 1912, which have prompted renewed scholarly and popular interest in those events both on and off the island. These complex, intertwined issues of race, immigration and prostitution perhaps merited a little more space for exploration. Meanwhile, the actions and agency of individual prostitutes, always difficult to get at, also become less visible as the book moves toward its concluding years.
Criticisms of this kind are surely inevitable in a book with such an impressive breadth of chronological scope, and whose ambitious focus is on those ‘hidden from history’. Regardless, the book admirably traces a longue durée, comprehensive history of prostitution in Cuba while simultaneously shedding new light on broader histories of colonialism, nationalism and modernity.
