This symposium discusses whether political science conferences need reform. Although complaining about the American Political Science Association (APSA) and the Midwest Political Science Association (MPSA) annual meetings is not rare, I will argue that they work well for the profession in general and for most of us as individuals. Over the years, I have heard many ideas for reform, and this symposium suggests additional possibilities. While some are useful, I find many alternatives to be largely impractical, too-clever-for-their-own-good, or containing flaws that seem predictable to this scholar of human behavior. I also find that the stakes are high in this debate. Conferences are the primary way we personally interact with the profession in all of its diversity, and how they are organized provides many benefits to you and me throughout our careers. If our annual meetings drastically change, we all may be the losers.
If this is the first essay you are reading in this symposium, I suggest you pause and read Mark Rom’s introduction, as well as his original and more detailed article in the Journal of Political Science Education titled “The Scholarly Conference: Do We Want Democracy and Markets or Authority and Tradition?” (Rom Reference Rom2012). When I read his provocative essay, my first (uncharitable) thought was that a tenured professor at a prominent research university was proposing a series of reforms that would benefit mostly tenured professors at prominent research universities. My second thought was to worry about the consequences of large-scale changes to such a central part of our discipline. Institutions and ecosystems are fragile, and we should not make changes lightly. For those who study public policy, the problems associated with sweeping reform plans are clear. I need only mention “campaign finance reform” to remind us how the best of intentions can lead to problematic outcomes and unintended consequences.
Defending the status quo is rarely the popular position to take. Higher education is filled with breathless essays about the need for change, and many commentators are eager to jump on various pedagogical, organizational, and IT bandwagons. Given all of the ink spilled about the alleged problems of higher education, we might be surprised that academia still exists—and in a form largely recognizable to previous generations. Of course, it is more fun to write boldly about transformation, change, reengineering, and so forth than to suggest that “Criticisms of peer review are greatly exaggerated” or “Academic libraries are adapting well to the digital age” or “Online education fills a niche but does not challenge traditional education.”
As I write in defense of the conferences we know, I feel like Baby Stewie, a character in the animated cartoon “The Family Guy.” In one episode, he imagines himself at Woodstock, being booed as he sings the lyrics “Establishment, establishment, you always know what’s best.” After all, Rom (Reference Rom2012) titled his original paper to suggest that we must choose between the cool future of the invisible hand (democracy and markets) or the dead hand of the past (authority and tradition). My essay is not meant to reflexively defend current conference formats; rather than thinking of their features as flowing from “authority” or an “establishment,” I see them as reflecting the collective wisdom and experience of thousands of faculty and graduate students across a century of political science. We may not be experiencing the Platonic ideal conferences (as if this were possible), but I think our conference world is healthy and thriving.
I have been presenting papers at political science and other social science conferences since 1994 (thank you, Northeastern Political Science Association, for that first opportunity). I have attended conferences as a graduate student, assistant professor, associate professor, and now full professor. At all career stages, I have found conferences to be invaluable, but—and this is a key point—in different ways. With this experience in mind, as well as countless conversations about conferences while attending conferences, I will reply to the bold ideas generated by Rom.
Rom begins his essay with the claim that “The conventional political science conference is a dinosaur, large, lumbering, and increasingly ill-suited for its environment, although extinction does not appear imminent” (2012, 333). Is the dinosaur metaphor accurate? I have not seriously studied dinosaurs since the fourth grade, but I remember that they flourished for more than 150 million years and were well adapted to the environments of their time. They became extinct because an asteroid hit the earth, the original case of “punctuated equilibrium”—too bad dinosaurs could not have read Baumgartner and Jones (Reference Baumgartner and Jones1993). I do not see an equivalent shock that has hit academia today, notwithstanding the many op-eds by higher education’s strident critics and self-declared reformers. And are political science conferences too large? They may appear so in comparison to the annual meeting of a group such as the Latin Punctuation Association or Academic Conservatives of America, but not when compared to medical, computer science, and business conferences. Dinosaurs certainly did not appear to be “lumbering” to the characters in the movie Jurassic Park, who were chased down and eaten.
Although Rom similarly refers to the APSA Annual Meeting as “hidebound” (2012, 333), he notes that the current format is different than the original practice. He reports that the first meetings were more like roundtables and that the current panel structure began in 1946 and became standard by 1974. This suggests that, far from lumbering dinosaurs that do not evolve, conferences experienced change about halfway through the development of the discipline. Nevertheless, Rom then suggests that conferences have not subsequently changed because we are largely bound by “authority and tradition” (2012, 334). I hypothesize that they changed to better meet the needs of the membership, and that they have not subsequently changed because the current format works as well as possible for everyone involved.
Rom finds numerous problems with today’s conferences—problems that require radical restructuring. A key question is the quality of conference papers, in terms of both content and presentation. Rom’s essay presents data on contemporaneous paper presentations. He hired eight PhD students to assess the quality of papers presented at whichever panels they chose to attend at the 2008 APSA Annual Meeting. The results indicated that 51% “were judged to be essentially finished papers”; 35% “were fairly well-developed works in progress”; and only 6% were “unclear in questions, themes, and methods” (2012, 338). This is quite encouraging; 86% of the papers were in the top two categories, which confirms my impression that most presenters are serious about their papers. I can think of very few times in the past 20 years when I either heard or was a discussant for a truly bad paper.
Rom also reports that the presentation quality varied widely, although no specific data were presented. He claims that few incentives exist for high-quality presentations, but I see the best incentive at work—our reputations. We may not be the most dynamic and entertaining presenters, but no structural reform will make us more like Sammy Hagar (Reference Hagar1984). My experience is that people do their best. Nobody wants to give a poor presentation, but we may be rushed, jet-lagged, or nervous. The only surprise is that presentations are as good as they are. I also find that the newest generation of scholars is giving great presentations—so much better than I likely did as a graduate student or assistant professor.
Rom’s PhD students also reported that few questions were asked in panels, with almost 40% of presenters receiving no questions. His summary of panels is that “The presenters walk in, present, and walk out; the audience sits down, listens, and leaves” (2012, 339). My experience is that some presenters may receive no questions and the quality of discussant comments varies, but most receive at least some feedback. I also see a fair amount of post-panel discussion between presenters and audience members, which provides additional feedback as well as builds relationships.
Rom raises the point of connectivity—your paper must be presented alongside two to four other papers, which may or may not be related to your topic. He suggests that this is a problem for both audience members and panel participants, but I have always seen it as a bonus. There is a serendipitous element to conferences, which helps us to grow as scholars. It is easy to read only those articles in your field and to talk to people you know, but conferences can introduce you to new topics, new methodologies, and new people. If I could tailor my conferences exactly to my interests, I would miss out on much.
There is a serendipitous element to conferences, which helps us to grow as scholars.… conferences can introduce you to new topics, new methodologies, and new people.
Rom’s paper “proposes the customized conferences as a way to use democratic and market mechanisms to replace authority and tradition in conference design and operation” (2012, 334). This statement is based on his conclusion that attending conferences, as they currently are configured, is not the optimal way to learn and build community. My caution is that we should not compare conferences as they are—that is, large and complex events that must accommodate thousands of people, dozens of sections and groups, and considerable diversity in terms of topics and methodologies—to the ideal conference. The real always fails to measure up to the ideal.
To improve conferences, Rom turns to democracies and markets, which “are typically better equipped to meet individual’s preferences and needs and, at the same time, to build communities of common interests” (339–40). This may be generally true, but policy scholars may question whether market logic can be applied easily to every policy domain. For instance, there are vigorous debates about whether and how choice can be applied to educational policy making. Furthermore, political scientists may doubt whether democracy should be maximized in all organizations. Like the US Army, the APSA might be better served to defend democracy than to practice it.
The Rom plan is to abolish traditional panels and substitute “Teaching” and “Learning” presentations. The former is for polished papers, which would be presented individually. The latter would feature not formal presentations but rather discussions of works in progress that would benefit from extended feedback. In addition, the membership would vote on which Teaching papers it wants to hear. Rom anticipates some of the criticisms of these ideas, but he is unpersuaded.
My first thought about teaching presentations is that if we want to read polished papers, we can pick up a journal. By their nature, conferences are locations for interaction and feedback. For those who seek to teach our colleagues, we have many outlets available.
Second, who would take the time to vote on these Teaching presentations, which would number in the hundreds or even the thousands? Political science knows one or two things about who participates in activities that are time consuming but provide few tangible benefits. Rom is not concerned, writing that “In democracies, it is a given that those with more votes win elections, and those with fewer votes lose them; if the rules are clear and fair, these unequal outcomes are perfectly acceptable” (2012, 345). Many scholars who study civil rights and human rights movements may take issue with this view, as a democracy is more than a series of winner-take-all elections. The idea that academic minorities just need to accept defeat is odd. Rom states that people will have incentives to read the proposals and participate because “their votes will matter” (2012, 348). However, turnout is very low in many elections in which our votes matter—consider city council elections and other local contests.
We also might ponder these implications for the study of minority groups within political science. Not long ago, for example, relatively few panels could be organized on Race, Ethnicity, and Politics and Latino Politics topics. This was the case because section allocations were based on panel attendance, which was based on who attended the conference, which was based on panel-allocation decisions from the distant past. This circular and path-dependent model allowed few options for increasing the scholarly diversity of the conferences. However, although allegedly based on “tradition” and “authority,” my understanding is that the APSA Annual Meeting responded to pressure and revised its panel allocations. If this had been left to a vote of the membership, conference diversity might have changed little in the past two decades. The large majority of scholars claim to support diversity, but if asked to choose between diversity and their traditional interests, I wonder how most would vote.
Rom also suggests a variety of ways to restrict the vote, which would likely introduce a number of biases. Perhaps only members of the association should be allowed to vote, he suggests, or those willing to pay a $10 fee. He might give more votes to those who regularly attend conferences. If you think a small group of insiders dominates conferences today, I can only imagine how this reform plan would privilege those with the cash to join the associations, regularly travel to conferences, and pay to vote.
In my view, the result of this Rom-ulan plan would be low-turnout voting that predominantly selects well-known people from well-known universities. Full professors would provide the vast majority of the “Teaching” presentations, while the emerging, the underplaced, and the untenured would move to the margins. This would certainly change the conference experience, but in a “rich-get-richer” way that needlessly enhances professional inequality.
In addition, such voting would simultaneously ignore emerging subjects as well as accentuate the topical and methodological “flavors of the month.” Imagine Rom-ulan conferences in the midst of various trends: game theory in the 1990s, social capital in the 2000s, and experiments today. And how can innovative methods and emerging topics find a place at such conferences when, by definition, the electorate is less familiar with them? Moreover, attendees would experience lower levels of serendipity, the “inadvertent audience” learning that takes place at traditional panels. Maybe you attended a panel because three of the four papers looked interesting, but it is the fourth that you remember.
I also worry that the Teaching presentations would begin to resemble TED-style talks, as benefits (specifically, future votes) would accrue to those who can impress a crowd. Are those the type of talks that we want to dominate our conference experience?
I like democracy, but I do not want 2,000 candidates on the ballot.
What about the Learning presentations? Who would want to attend a presentation that is not a talk but rather a discussion of a work very much in progress, where you may not learn anything new but instead help someone else write or revise a paper? My guess is nobody. And if nobody wants to attend, then who will want to present? Rom also predicts that the Learning format “might be similar to the poster sessions of the conventional conferences, but without the stigma” (2012, 341). I suspect the stigma would be even greater because posters do manage to attract attendees who appreciate the unique opportunity to personally discuss new work with an author.
Rom is aware of other criticisms and responds to them. He essentially agrees with the charge that his plan would lead to “popularity, not merit” (2012, 344), but he does so through a criticism of authority. Why should we give section heads the power to make decisions? Why not empower the political science masses? I might note that authority is not an unknown concept in academia, and it is justified by expertise. We have authority as teachers, as manuscript reviewers, and as members of departmental and associational committees. It therefore seems acceptable to defer to our colleagues who act as authorities in deciding which papers should be presented at the APSA Annual Meeting and similar conferences.
Rom states that it “seems odd, to say the least, that political scientists would abdicate this opportunity for expanded democracy” (2012, 344). I like democracy, but I do not want 2,000 candidates on the ballot. I am happy to subcontract such choices to someone appointed by the program organizer, especially if the alternative is to review and vote on all of the proposals. In addition, as political scientists, we know that one person’s expanded democracy may be another person’s lost influence. Some Progressive Era proposals to expand democracy, including the ballot initiative and nonpartisan elections, were efforts to reduce the power of immigrants and thereby benefit an establishment alarmed at losing power to these new Americans.
Rom recognizes that conferences provide multiple benefits for attendees, many of which do not directly involve the presenting of a paper. However, in order to receive these benefits, scholars must attend the event. This requires financial support from employers, and for most of us, this can only occur when we present a paper. Who knows if Learning presentations will count? Rom says they would not be formal presentations but would “appear on the program to help them qualify for institutional reimbursement” (2012, 343). I am not sure that would be enough; many people could find their conference funding endangered.
We might also ask why conferences are so oversubscribed if they are “lumbering dinosaurs” based on tradition and authority? The main complaint that I hear about conferences is the growing rate of proposal rejection. No one can take for granted that their APSA proposal will be accepted, but that hardly discourages anyone from trying. If conferences are dinosaurs, they are apparently very popular dinosaurs—more Barney than Godzilla.
As I suggest at the beginning of this essay, the popularity of conferences reflects their importance at every stage of our careers. How they are useful to a PhD candidate is different than how they are useful to an endowed chair, but they remain important throughout a person’s career. This may vary according to the workplace, as Research 1 faculty have different career paths than liberal arts college faculty. Nevertheless, to the degree that research and networking matter, conferences matter.
As a graduate student, you need to hear feedback on your dissertation research, become familiar with disciplinary norms, begin developing a professional network, and prepare for the job market. The large conferences provide myriad opportunities for all of the above. It may not be easy or comfortable to hear criticism, ask questions, or introduce yourself to strangers, but the APSA and MPSA conferences provide unique opportunities to do so. The panel structure, in particular, provides opportunities not only to be heard but also to receive feedback, to network, and to learn about new research topics and methods.
Once you receive a tenure-track job, you need to deepen relationships with people in your field, translate good ideas into publications, talk to press editors if you wish to publish a book, increase your familiarity with the ideas of your colleagues and competitors, and perhaps start looking for another job. Once you receive tenure, you may become more involved in the APSA, begin to take on disciplinary service responsibilities, and think about your next projects and career moves. Where else can you accomplish so much, and in only a few days, except at the largest conferences?
The history of political reform indicates that major changes often come with substantial unintended consequences—which are sometimes worse than the problems the reform was intended to solve.
In his classic campus novel Small World, David Lodge (Reference Lodge1984, 313) captures the essence of major academic conferences: “The MLA is the Big Daddy of conferences. A megaconference. A three-ring circus of the literary intelligentsia...Imagine ten thousand highly-educated, articulate, ambitious, competitive men and women converging on mid-Manhattan on the 27th of December, to meet and to lecture and to question and to discuss and to gossip and to plot and to philander and to party and to hire or be hired.”
Why put at risk this unique enterprise that has served us individually and collectively so well and for so long? As political scientists, we should be aware of the dangers of disrupting fragile institutions. We also should automatically question radical reform plans in the name of vague principles such as “markets” and “democracy.” Furthermore, the history of political reform indicates that major changes often come with substantial unintended consequences—which are sometimes worse than the problems the reform was intended to solve. Our conferences ain’t broke, but fixing them could make them so.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Thanks to Gary Freeman and Jan Leighley for their helpful comments on this topic.
