Kingdoms and Chiefdoms is a serious but flawed work of scholarship, undertaken by an experienced specialist historian. Elizabeth Eldredge has divided up the early political history of southeastern Africa into a generous 13 chapters on chiefly (or tribal) history, the history that led up to the big states of the nineteenth century (she stops at 1830). Her terrain is mostly southern Africa, east of the Kalahari Desert.
Eldredge makes use of spoken traditions, missionaries’ accounts, and, especially, originally orally-transmitted genealogies that have come down to her in textual form. Archaeology has proven more difficult for historians to use as a confirmatory source (242–3). Zulu military expansion, about which Eldredge has written before, features in the book, but so do other amalgamative processes. In her introduction, Eldredge delightfully reads S. E. K. Mqhayi's novel, Ityala Lamawele, ‘The Court Case of the Twins’, as reinforcing the notion that merit and the people's will more determined who ruled them than orderly inheritance. She suggests this was always the case, that there was no major break in the later eighteenth century that produced more complex states.
Natal and southern Mozambique are considered side by side, beginning with a close look at Portuguese shipwreck accounts before the eighteenth century. We learn that chiefs around Maputo (Delagoa) Bay picked up some English from whalers and referred to themselves as ‘King George's men’ (147). Trade is a part of the story – Dingiswayo had a hundred men making karosses for the Portuguese market (170) – but politics were mostly driven by opportunistic leaders, not competition for manufactures. The coastal (written) sources, however, appear scarcely to touch the scene inland. For that we rely on oral history.
As the book moves through dozens of defunct ‘chiefdoms’, past and present, one by one, Kingdoms and Chiefdoms starkly highlights the limits of what such an approach can accomplish. A great many patriarchal stories, related at various times, about politics, are deposited in exclusively Ba- and Ama- (‘those of’) framings: AmaCele; AmaZondi; and, BaPulane, etc., etc. (369, n122). This risks buttressing the ‘citizen–subject’ distinction we must move beyond in order to understand everyone's politics in a single historical framework. The narratives do not intersect in a comprehensible way, and at times, the book simply recapitulates available published (collected) accounts, from G. M. Theal, Ellenberger, and the James Stuart papers.
Eldredge's task is made more difficult by her insistence that southern African oral traditions were accurate records of long-past centuries. Because there were often competing genealogies in circulation, however, she has to privilege one. What was the correct inheritance sequence, the actual movement of groups of people, the true size of the herd stolen, the genuine rank of major houses? She weeds out redundant praise names and finds other ‘errors’. Inevitably she is unable to share her reasoning fully in the space provided. But the project is flawed in conception as well as execution.
How can there be such accuracy and yet variation? ‘Maziyana, Mbovu, and Mcotoyi all provided genealogies of Mcotoyi's ancestral line of amaThuli chiefs, with disagreement only for the earliest names from seven generations earlier’ (113, emphasis added). In accounting for the ‘AmaZondi’, the author finds two genealogies, a father's and a son's, which trace their heritage to their founder (Lusibalukulu) differently. This discovery is revealing in itself, yet the discussion terminates (115). On page 123 appear the two main extant genealogies for the ‘AmaTembe chiefs’, one from Mahungane and Nkomuza, and one garnered by Junod. The schemes are entirely different from one generation before ‘Mayete’, identified as ‘Mayett King Kapell’ by Captain William Owen. In a recent MA thesis, there is a third version. There were at least two accepted genealogies for ‘Zulu’ (100 and 367, ns87–8). Eldredge assembles or finds the true list (368, n103); she does not ask how this coexistence of difference was in fact tolerated as a societal reality.
Eldredge explicitly criticizes Carolyn Hamilton's Zulu reconstructions (and those of this reviewer). Hamilton and John Wright have argued that politics in the Zulu kingdom transformed regional or lineage identities into statuses of various kinds. Students of their work take ‘amaNtungwa’ and ‘amaLala’, and even ‘Zulu’, as complex and changeful categories. Eldredge, in contrast, wishes to restore them as lineage names. She asserts (as she has in her work before) that the location of the ancient Zulu house's grave sites speak against the plausibility of later tinkering with oral tradition. While Hamilton doubts whether Qwabe and Zulu were historical sons of the same father, for instance, Eldredge restores them to a single ‘AmaChunu’ (of MChunu) household in a corrected genealogy (100). She claims to hold that ‘[k]nowledge’ was ‘retained’ through the ‘repetition’ on ‘ceremonial occasions’ of names (9) and that the ‘deliberate’ alteration of chiefly lore was impossible as this would require ‘subterfuge’ and/or a general ‘acceptance of the act of altering or inventing genealogies’ (50). Of course, she herself finds evidence of interested alterations in genealogies she rejects.
One notices some undeniable errors. Queen Mohurutshe is a female chief (245, 249). It is anachronistic to identify ‘Sotho’ as an invented identity and as an underlying ethnicity extending into (for example) Mozambique (96, 109, 120). At times, it seems Eldredge conflates polities with eponymous chiefs; who really was ‘Mchunu’? (Chief Manhiça? Inyaka? ‘Kapell’?). Eldredge does not factor in likely distortions of memory, such as hourglass configurations of lore, or the telescoping of genealogies, even though (again) she finds them in practice (296 and 372, n31). How do we know that the debated, middle parts of the royal genealogies do not sometimes name junior household-heads of the past, elevated later by the enthronement of a descendant? And if ancestors were forgotten before a hero-founder, could not more recent hero-chiefs also have (unknown) ancestors who were forgotten or replaced by descendants? Scholars agree that there is a constant, legitimating function for chiefly oral recitations. Don't they do this job by changing?
The AmaPhongose origin tale, the first AmaTlokwa emergence, the trials of the MaPulane, and AmaZondi lines – contested political stories – cannot convincingly be tied to material remains. Nonetheless for Eldredge, the reciters of oral traditions were bound to speak correct history, vouchsafing the ancient (even 1,000 years ago!) existence of their groups. In contrast, this reviewer suggests that rejected stories are marks of past factions and shifts, in which wider, general patterns might be discerned. Without them, we behold a tableau of great breadth and detail, but uncertain historicity.
