Anyone who either worked in a research laboratory during the 1970s, 1980s or 1990s, or followed the vicissitudes of biology during that time, can look forward to a trip down memory lane when they read this book. Make that four lanes, if you were involved with DNA sequencing in any way. Do you remember pouring polyacrylamide gels between those tall sheets of glass held together with clamps? (Mine, I have to admit sheepishly, leaked and wound up as often in the sink as between those sheets). How about melting agarose in order to pour those smaller gels (much easier) for RFLP analyses? Or wicking solutions through sheets of filter paper to produce chromatograms with different-coloured spots? The furore over PCR and its eccentric inventor, Kary Mullis? Miguel García-Sancho brings all these memories – which were in turns exciting, exhilarating, embarrassing or often just downright exhausting – vividly back to life in his new book recounting the history of molecular sequencing in the second half of the twentieth century.
Sequencing today is inextricably linked with, indeed entirely subsumed within, molecular biology, a fact that, the author laments, has also caused its history to be conflated with that of DNA and genomics. In the process, he says, the history of research into protein sequencing which did not merely precede DNA research, but also continued to develop alongside it, has been marginalized, if not completely ignored. Furthermore, the understanding and portrayal of sequencing itself, he argues, has been reduced to that of a ‘technique devised to solve a particular experimental problem’ within the ‘pathway of a particular scientific discipline, molecular biology’ (p. 11). Among his explicit aims in this book, therefore, are to provide a bigger, more complete history of sequencing, encompassing its many genealogies in different disciplines, and to treat sequencing as a ‘particular form of work’, a result of the confluence of multiple scientific practices ‘unrestricted by disciplinary frameworks’ (p. 12).
García-Sancho's goal in producing such a history is laudable and the meat of his book provides a thorough survey of the various practices that played their part in both the invention of molecular sequencing techniques and their applications. I am a little sceptical, however, about the framing device for his account of this history. For one, I am not sure that his charge of a narrowness of vision, especially on the part of of various historians of science, is entirely accurate. His own account is, in fact, rich in references to eminent historians – Soraya de Chadarevian, John Pickstone, Bruno Strasser and Edna Suárez-Díaz, to name but a few of the most prominent – whose work has pushed and expanded boundaries of the type that he criticizes. While the book has done well to draw attention to this scholarship, the references to the approaches and methods these authors have described are entirely appropriate as they stand and do not need the additional justification. García-Sancho is slightly more persuasive in his criticisms of the understanding of the scientists who participated in the molecular revolution in biology. It may well be true that the perceived success of the Human Genome Project and its promise for the future of biomedicine instigated scientists to recollect their research experiences in a way that implies a conflation of the history of sequencing with DNA. But it seems to me that he is overlooking the possibility that such narratives were constructed more in keeping with the specific rhetorical aims of these researchers and less because they did not understand importance of proteins in sequencing or, more broadly, in biology.
So intent seems García-Sancho on freeing the history of sequencing from its confines within molecular biology that he overlooks his own insights about academic disciplines being ‘strategic constructions of researchers’ (p. 62), instead of strict areas of study with sharply delineated boundaries. This fuzziness in disciplinary boundaries is especially true of molecular biology, which can be considered more appropriately as a discipline born of techniques and approaches than as one stemming from a particular subject of inquiry, and which is utilized by many of the older subdisciplines of biology, including biochemistry and genetics. García-Sancho might have done better to treat molecular biology also as yet another ‘form of work’ in biology, whose practices were among those whose confluence influenced the development of sequencing, and whose own progress was significantly influenced by advances in protein research in addition to nucleic acid studies.
None of the criticisms above, however, detract from the wealth of information that García-Sancho has to impart in the body of his narrative, and these facts and stories give this book its greatest value. Biology and chemistry form only part of the story, as he makes clear here in devoting nearly two-thirds of the book to the other major player in this history, the computer in its multiple roles. In today's world of high-speed Internet, hand-held devices and terabyte memory chips, most of us take our computers and their capabilities for granted. While we would certainly acknowledge their vital role in the development of the biological sciences, I would venture to say that few, if any, of the historians of science who use them have anything more than a superficial understanding of how these technologies have shaped scientific practices and understanding. The author has done a masterful job of integrating information about the way in which different aspects of computer science – from something as mundane as word processing to the processing of millions, if not billions, of base-pairs’ worth of DNA sequence data – have contributed to the development of sequencing as it is practised today. And for that reason alone Biology, Computing, and the History of Molecular Sequencing is an invaluable, possibly even essential, addition to the bookshelf of anyone wishing to understand modern biology in all its facets.
