This collection of essays by Willem Assies, compiled by his partner and a group of friends and collaborators, is a tribute to a remarkable colleague who died in 2010 at the tragically early age of 55. It is divided into five parts. Each contains two essays on themes to which Assies made important contributions: urban social movements, agrarian issues, indigenous rights, ethnicity and citizenship, and political developments in Bolivia. The parts have short introductions by colleagues with whom Willem, who always enjoyed working with others, collaborated on that theme, all authoritative experts. The book has a foreword by his PhD supervisor, Geert Banck, and a general introduction by the editors. Those who never had the privilege of meeting Willem will learn something about the man as well as his work by reading these introductions, but their main purpose is to highlight why his original and influential contributions constitute an enduring legacy. The book is a tribute to a dead colleague but his deeply perceptive analyses remain very much alive and relevant, regardless of the date of their original authorship.
This is in part because Assies was a brilliant essayist. The collection demonstrates his extraordinary ability to synthesise key academic debates, putting them in their historical context, and always recognising residual strong points that might be overlooked in paradigms that had clearly been overtaken by developments in the world. Never dogmatic and strongly resistant to the ideologisation of any issue, Willem did more than take the ‘best bits’ from existing schools of thought and disciplinary perspectives, such as identity-focused approaches to social movements and political opportunity models. As all the essays show, he consistently added new ideas to the mix through a combination of analytical astuteness and logical rigour with a deep respect for the available evidence. Willem's forte was incisively critical but carefully grounded argument, as illustrated by his rejection of the arguments of Alain de Janvry about the implications of military land reform in Peru and ground-breaking essay on the northern Bolivian Amazon ‘From Rubber Estate to Simple Commodity Production’, two contributions to the Journal of Peasant Studies in the second part. Both derive theoretical inspiration from Marxist accounts of simple commodity production within capitalist formations (by Rosa Luxemburg and Marx himself). Yet this is not a formalistic Marxism of labelling things, but one built on deep analysis of lived social and economic contradictions.
As the title of the book suggests, all Willem's work was inspired by his profound sympathy with the struggles for social dignity of the actors at the bottom of the chain of capitalist exploitation, which was what led him to pay particular attention first to the urban poor and then to the new indigenous movements of Latin America. Yet his contributions were distinguished by the equilibrated absence of any illusions about what actors within socially differentiated and often internally politically conflictive poor and indigenous groups might think or do in practice, on the one hand, and a focus on power relations that avoided the trap of ‘blaming the victim’, on the other. Assies was spectacularly good at analysing complex political processes and the social and economic forces underlying them with the historical depth necessary to understand structural shifts. This is particularly well illustrated in the book's final essay, on Bolivia. Prescient in its analysis of the processes that were impelling Evo Morales and the Movimiento al Socialismo towards national power, this not only offers an analysis without illusions but also recognises that a social scientist who attempts to predict the future is likely to be confounded by events. Both chapters in the final part offer profound insights into the complex political consequences of neoliberalism in Latin America. The first offers a pioneering exploration of the lessons of the Cochabamba ‘Water War’ for understanding the reconfiguration of social protest at the turn of the millennium.
The book begins with essays on the evolution of urban social movements that draw on Willem's research in Brazil. Always critical of the euphoric stance of many protagonists of the new social movements literature, he not only encouraged anthropologists and political scientists to talk to each other through his theoretical interventions, but also produced illuminating empirical analyses of the shifting role of ‘external actors’, especially the Catholic Church, ‘engaged’ professionals and NGOs, in social movement dynamics before and after the return of democracy. The selected essays are ideal for introducing students to both these forms of insight.
So are the other two sections, devoted to the politics of indigeneity, indigenous-state relations and critical analyses of neoliberal ‘state reform’ and multiculturalism. All four essays are just as relevant today as when they were originally written, since they deal with dilemmas and contradictions that have proved intractable, such as the meaning of ‘autonomy’ in relation to the administration of justice, the distinction between ‘land’ and ‘territory’, the relationships between ‘recognition’ and ‘redistribution’ (not exclusive in Willem's view), and issues of resource sovereignty. Assies was one of the first to recognise that ‘neo-extractivism’ posed challenges for the indigenous policies of ‘pink tide’ governments. His qualitative but systematic comparisons of how indigenous policies have been implemented in different countries are well represented in the book, and his carefully documented analyses of the practical implications of different institutional arrangements and notions of ‘ethnic citizenship’ should continue to provide food for thought for both academics and activists for some time to come.
Assies was a complete ‘Latin Americanist’. His research covered Brazil, Mexico, where he worked for a number of years at the Colegio de Michoacán, and the Andes and lowland South America. His intellectual legacy as an anthropologist is all the stronger for its transcendence of disciplinary and national boundaries, and the rich diversity of themes that his concern for the voiceless led him to explore and analyse in an outstandingly perceptive way.
