In New Babylonians: A History of Jews in Modern Iraq, Orit Bashkin has written a much-needed analysis of a community whose history has too often been distorted, marginalized, or erased in vernacular, official, and scholarly accounts of modern Iraq. The book is neither a story of a “false paradise of Arab–Jewish harmony” (p. 237) nor a melancholic account of a failed attempt at assimilation and coexistence. Instead, it is an empathetic and exhaustively researched study of the experiences of the Jews for whom Iraq was a home, a milieu, an identity, and ultimately a hostile polity.
The book starts with the founding of the Iraqi state in 1921 and concludes with the displacement of most of the Iraqi Jewish community in 1951. As Bashkin explains, it is first and foremost “about intellectual, social, and cultural histories” (p. 14) with a focus on the writings of Iraqi Jews. Drawing on Rogers Brubaker's discussion of processes of ethnicization (p. 2), Bashkin resists portraying Iraqi Jews as a group with a static self-definition. Instead, she demonstrates that in monarchical Iraq, Jews constructed their “Iraqi Jewish” and “Arab Jewish” identities in relation to emerging Iraqi- and Arabic-language discourses; the nascent Iraqi state; and local, regional, and global ideologies, such as Iraqi nationalism, Arab nationalism, anticolonialism, Zionism, and communism. These political and social forces alternately included and excluded Jews; meanwhile, Jews both embraced and rejected them depending on the time period and context. The formation of the State of Israel in 1948 represented a watershed event, leading to an anti-Jewish backlash on the part of the Iraqi government and right-wing nationalists that “silenced” Iraqi Jewish pluralism and increased the influence of Zionism within a community that had hitherto largely opposed it (p. 12).
Bashkin traces these intersecting forces through readings of a variety of sources, including Iraqi periodicals, Iraqi government records, Israeli archival materials, memoirs, and fiction. Her extensive use of both Arabic and Hebrew primary and secondary texts allowed her to develop a broad-based, complex study surpassing any other on this topic in scope and detail, as well as to pick up on nuances of language that are critical to any study of identity formation. In addition, Bashkin puts untapped sources to creative use; for instance, she shows how a preface to an Iraqi Jewish poet's Arabic translation of William Tell constitutes an example of Iraqi Jewish participation in Arab anticolonial discourses (p. 34).
The book's second chapter argues that the pluralism of Iraqi religions, national visions, and ethnicities “created a space” in which Jews could participate fully (p. 16). In this space, Bashkin finds, Iraqi Jews constructed an identity that incorporated Arabness and internalized Islamic vocabulary. The end of the chapter supports these conclusions through an examination of journalist Ezra Haddad's editorial choices in translating a medieval Jewish travel account from Hebrew into Arabic (pp. 47–57). In Chapter 3, Bashkin explores the secularization of Iraqi Jewish culture and identity in the public sphere. Poor Iraqi Jews continued to be highly religious, but the prestige of Jews who assimilated among the effendiyya, formed secular organizations, and took up government positions gradually eclipsed that of the community's religious leaders. Despite differences within the community, however, its sense of being distinct—and distinctly Jewish—remained strong.
The fourth chapter takes up the difficult topic of the June 1941 farhūd, an episode of rioting and violence directed mainly against Iraqi Jews that has been commemorated as a “pogrom” by some of those who experienced it (p. 101). Bashkin constructs a detailed account of how and why the attack occurred. Although Iraqi Jewish intellectuals had expressed primarily anticolonial and pro-Palestinian views, radical Arab nationalists began to conflate them with Zionists. Moreover, pro-German views had become common in Iraq since the British ground invasion of May 1941. The farhūd brought out “both the worst and the noblest aspects of Jewish–Iraqi relations,” as many Muslims risked their safety to shield Jews from the violence (pp. 101–2). Chapter 5 spans the decade between the farhūd and the Jewish community's mass displacement, taking up the subject of Jewish involvement in the Iraqi Communist Party. Bashkin corrects long-held assumptions that the presence of Jews in the party was negligible. She also finds that the popularity of Communism among Iraqi Jews kept them bound to a nonsectarian Iraqi identity even after the farhūd and bolstered the idea of Arab Jewishness by emphasizing the importance of struggling to end colonialism and anti-Semitism from within one's homeland.
Chapter 6 features another significant scholarly innovation: in light of her findings that Iraqi Jews were fully “immersed in Iraqi life and culture,” Bashkin argues that the dislocation of Iraqi Jews beginning in the early 1950s under the pressure of a denationalization law was anomalous rather than inevitable. She offers a detailed analysis of this seemingly “puzzling” event (p. 183). Three factors combined to bring about the tragic collapse of the Iraqi Jewish community: the emergence of a viciously anti-Semitic right-wing press, the Iraqi government's fear of communism, and the temporary popularity of the idea (among both Arab nationalists and Zionists) of a population exchange between Iraqi Jews and Palestinians.
New Babylonians is a significant addition to the literature on the social and political history of modern Iraq. Bashkin's frameworks and sources also make the work relevant beyond this literature. Indeed, her book is essential reading for those interested in nation building and the relationship between identity and politics in the modern Middle East. It will also be of interest to scholars studying Jews in the Arab world, Arab-Israeli relations, and the histories of communist parties in the Middle East. Due to its accessible prose and availability in paperback, New Babylonians would be an appropriate text to assign in graduate and advanced undergraduate seminars addressing any of these topics.
