The fin-de-siècle elite has never quite managed to outrun the cloud of moral opprobrium that first began looming overhead in its Gilded Age heyday, when the founding editor of the Nation, E. L. Godkin, was among those who branded the nation's wealthiest “the robber barons.” The disparaging phrase stuck, thanks in no small part to historians such as Matthew Josephson, whose eponymous1934 book popularized it for the New Deal generation.Footnote 1 In recent decades, scholars have opted for more measured descriptors, and yet their narratives have often continued to cast the Industrial Age's upper class in the role of villain. Thomas F. Rzeznik complicates such caricatures in Church and Estate, a richly documented study of religion and wealth in which Philadelphia's leading citizens appear not as “robber barons,” but rather as complex moral actors—indeed, fully orbed human beings.
At the center of Rzeznik's intervention is an argument that, while historians have frequently treated elite religion as so much window dressing, countless upper-class Philadelphians were people of sincere faith. Their religious lives were often entangled with their class politics, but for Rzeznik this fact is not so much extraordinary as it is axiomatic. Indeed, he persuasively contends throughout the book that “religion” and “class” are not distinct realms of activity but rather interlocking, even mutually constitutive, dimensions of everyday life.
Industrializing Philadelphia provides Rzeznik with ample evidence of such entanglement. He describes, for example, the vast and varied influence the wealthy wielded over the life of both individual congregations and entire denominations. As the city's richest citizens assumed the mantle of a ruling class, they gave extravagantly to a variety of charitable and religious organizations. But their generous contributions came more and more often with strings attached. Rzeznik cites leading merchant John Wanamaker's philanthropic relationship with his home church, Bethany Presbyterian, as one example of “the increasingly legalistic and contractual nature of giving” (35). In his will, Wanamaker specified exactly how the monies and lands he left Bethany could be used, joining a generation of benefactors who sought “to control church affairs from beyond the grave” (33). Many did not wait that long. The Philadelphia elite served in large numbers on church boards and vestries, taking on lay leadership roles that assured them a dominant voice in ecclesial governance. Meanwhile, across the metropolitan area, well-heeled believers collaborated with accomplished architects, contractors, and religious leaders to design and construct church buildings that reflected a decidedly patrician “aesthetic vision” (77). In the process, they did far more than beautify the urban landscape. As Rzeznik writes, “The ability to shape the physical form of their churches endowed the elite with ‘ecclesiological’ influence, through which they were able to physically define the proper relationship between faith, practice, and aesthetics” (77).
But if wealthy Philadelphians exercised disproportionate influence over church affairs, their commitments reflected more than just a crass attempt to advance class interests. In the first place, Rzeznik reminds, church leadership was rarely as glamorous as the title of trustee or vestryman might lead one to believe. The work smacked as often of facilities management as of executive board; indeed, he writes, “Those who served in these capacities spent their nights fretting over leaky roofs, heating bills, mortgage payments, and other matters” (67). While Rzeznik acknowledges that Philadelphia's elite-financed church building spree reflected in part sociopolitical ambitions, he is sensitive also to its spiritual underpinnings. He wants to recover, for example, the “theological impulse” animating the Gothic revival (89). In his discussion of one particularly grand project—the Church of the New Jerusalem's Bryn Athyn Cathedral—he admits that the donors “cherished the high esteem” their largesse won them and yet goes on to insist that “their devotion to the project came from their personal faith, commitment to the New Church and its teachings, and their belief in the spiritually transformative power of ecclesiastical design” (87).
Of course, religious initiatives did advance the elite's class interests. Rzeznik acknowledges that, from the very beginning, the system of private financing made Protestant churches, in particular, unduly responsive to their leading members. By the early twentieth century the Philadelphia upper crust was flocking to the Episcopal Church; in so doing it participated in a national trend, namely, “the religious consolidation of the social and financial elite” (110). Rzeznik discusses at some length how, in positioning itself as the church of the nation's ruling class, the denomination secured a wealth of “spiritual capital” for its members (8). Religious belonging could and did strengthen class authority. But here again Rzeznik resists a reductionist reading, asserting, “upper-class Episcopalians successfully blended religious and class imperatives.” He elaborates, “They believed that they had a moral obligation to exercise public leadership and serve as models for emulation. The Church likewise affirmed upper-class identity as the ‘best sort’ in society and commissioned them to go and make disciples of the same” (140).
Toward the end of the book, Rzeznik turns to the matter of contestation, discussing how some Progressive Era Philadelphians—including, notably, a number situated within elite-run institutions—came to challenge the authority of the religious establishment. This illuminating section leaves one wishing only that Rzeznik attended more fully to earlier and wider threats to upper-class rule. Indeed, the growth and consolidation of the establishment, which he describes in such splendid detail, must itself be understood, at least in part, as a response to the class upheavals of the Gilded Age, which riveted elite persons across the ever more connected industrializing world.
Church and Estate is essential reading for anyone interested in the vital intersection of religion and capitalism in modern American history. Rzeznik's nuanced discussion of elite piety will not convince everyone, but it should at the very least provoke fruitful conversation about the interplay of spiritual and material motivations in the Industrial Age. His book leaves no doubt, meanwhile, that those searching for the origins of latter-day partnerships between Christian and corporate Americas would do well to look earlier than we have perhaps thought—in the late nineteenth century, when the so-called robber barons roamed the land.
