Mary Elaine Hegland is the only American scholar to have conducted fieldwork in Iran during the 1979 Islamic Revolution. In Days of Revolution she shares her ethnographic account about the transformation of quotidian life in ʿAliabad, a village neighboring Shiraz, during and after those critical moments. As such, it is a welcome contribution to the growing body of scholarly literature on the revolution, even if parts of the book have already been published in the collection Women and Revolution: Global Expression (Dordrecht: Kluwer, 1998), edited by M. J. Diamond. The fieldwork was conducted discontinuously over a period of thirty-four years, giving the book a diachronic quality.
Hegland started her fieldwork to study agricultural practices for her PhD dissertation but became sympathetic to the oppression of villagers and a participant in their revolutionary activities. As a result she decided to study the events leading to the revolution in Iran that provides a substantial amount of the data used in this book. As an American she faced suspicions of being a spy, a challenge she partially overcame by obtaining a letter from the religious authorities. Nonetheless, the suspicions lingered on, exacerbated by her visit to the Kurdish area to observe the Sunni attitudes toward the revolution right before the Kurdish Mahābād revolt against the central Shiʿi revolutionary government. (She had spent two years there as a Peace Corps volunteer twelve years earlier.) Hegland left the country following the takeover of the American embassy in Tehran, only to return twenty-four years later. She has not been able to use questionnaires, tape recorders, and access research institutes or government offices. She was left with a limited number of informants (mostly women) and her data are based on informal interviews as well as participant observation.
Hegland challenges one common—albeit discredited—explanation of the Islamic Revolution that suggests it was a revolt against modernizing changes. She argues that it was rather the inequitable modernization by the Pahlavi regime that kindled widespread resentment. For ʿAliabadis, such a realization of inequality was made possible by expanding opportunities to work outside the village. This condition had two impacts on the villagers: it connected them to sources of nationwide political unrest, and exposed them to people living significantly better lives in the city. Furthermore, the lack of political modernization that resulted in the failure to produce a responsive government compounded the inequitable condition.
A major contention of the book is that this context increased the importance of the bilateral and affinal Iranian kin-based political tāyifah (faction) as an unbounded unit of political operation. After a stifled period, tāyifah was fully activated with its particular terminology and narrative during the revolutionary period of weak central government. The author systematically shows that the culture of tāyifah-kishī and its continuous political process of shifting ties and making new alliances, groomed through politics of hospitality and varieties of social interactions (raft-u-āmād), afforded the villagers processual paradigms that superseded the biological kinship categories. Such paradigms divided the villagers into landlords and peasants. It was through the same paradigms that the villagers understood the national revolutionary movement, and even put Hegland in the tāyifah of Americans who wanted to sabotage the revolution. The amorphous process of tāyifah-kishī, that is, mobilization of the kin-based political faction, as discussed by Hegland begs clarification, however. It is not clear what distinguishes this process from basic utilitarianism that animates other forms of political processes.
The main thesis of the book emerges out of the above focus on what Hegland introduces as the secular political culture of tāyifah-kishī as opposed to the usual focus on Shiʿi ideology. Hegland draws on what some scholars have considered as the “‘basic structure of a culture’ that can remain relatively stable over time” (p. 15). However, given the diachronic nature of her work, her concept of a “basic structure of a culture” needs to be reexamined. Upon returning to Iran in 2003 and thereafter, and contrasting her emotional encounter with the reality of the aging and death of many people she had known, Hegland describes in her last chapter the dramatic transformation of ʿAliabad from a village into a suburb of Shiraz. By 2008, due to the booming real estate market, 90 percent of the village land she is told had passed into the hands of outsiders, mostly Shirazis. Considering this invaluable data, the author states that tāyifah-kishī among the remaining villagers is now replaced by city culture, and the land that is now individually owned positions siblings against one another as opposed to uniting them. Accordingly, the author should have reexamined the proclaimed static basic structure of culture.
Furthermore, Hegland uses specific ethnographic examples to argue that Shiʿi ideology was adopted “only after” the villagers had decided to support the revolutionary forces. However, the entwinement of the tāyifah-kishī and Shiʿi ideology is recognizable from several incidents prior to the revolution, for instance, from a religious slogan used against the British (p. 54). It is also distinguishable when during the land reform “Seyyids and mirzais . . . were pitted against non-seyyids” (p. 66). Moreover, revolutionary demonstrators reactualized the Shiʿi-specific ritual of mourning for Imam Hussein. The book also narrates how the villagers became fully involved in the revolutionary rituals and used tāyifah-kishī when brutality spilled over into ʿAliabad on two specific occasions. One of these was the throwing of stones by supporters of the government at a religiously enjoined mourning procession for a local martyr in the revolution. The other was the stabbing of a well-reputed young man who was commemorating the religious occasion of ʿAshuraʾ along with a group of people in the village mosque while shouting “death to the shah.” Both occasions were clearly laden with religious meanings. All of these dialectical interactions between tāyifah-kishī on the one hand, and Shiʿi ideology on the other hand, deserve attention in order to further nuance “the basic structure of culture,” which the author has proclaimed to be unchanging and secular.
Another theme Hegland addresses is the prerevolutionary use of tāyifah. The author outlines three events that have made the villagers realize that the growing control of the central government has made it difficult to mobilize, resulting in the irrelevancy of tāyifah. One was the 1953 Iranian coup d'état that overthrew Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddeq when “[m]any people looked to whichever side appeared to be winning” (p. 58). The second incident was the peasant strike which demanded more shares from the land, but which left many without any land due to the fact that the central government backed the landowners. The third was the land reform of 1962 intending to curtail ownership of the landowners and to distribute lands among the peasants. Coupled with the available alternative economic opportunities to farming, the distribution of lands resulted in a decline of agriculture in ʿAliabad. Hegland argues the restructuring forces of such national changes in the village removed the organizing concerns of the villagers over land distribution and attached those concerns to outside government opportunities. The author however should have used more ethnographic examples to clarify the dynamic of the struggles leading to the realization of tāyifah irrelevancy, particularly in the first two events. That is, how the villagers' attempts to draw on the traditional tāyifah-kishī were stifled? Moreover, it is worth noting that the land reform of 1962 was not marred all over Iran by such corruption due to close ties between the landowners and the central government.
Another strength of the book is the author's attention to women, who played an important role in tāyifah-kishī by engaging in the intensive social obligations within the network of kin. Hegland states that this attention to women has helped her to transcend the male-centered focus of political anthropology. Faithfully, her fifth chapter addresses how women were organizing both in the village and in Shiraz during the revolutionary activities. However, there is a total absence of women in the abovementioned three instances of unrest, as well as during the two incidents of stabbing and throwing stones, with the exception of a brief shouting by a woman. Moreover, in the stabbing case where the perpetrator was married to the sister of the victim, Hegland misses the opportunity to share with the reader the sister's reaction.
Finally, the book contains useful maps of the village, a cast of characters, a comprehensive index, a chronology of significant events, and a glossary. A drawing of major tāyifah and an updated map of the present day town of ʿAliabad could have helped as well. All in all, due to the unique insights into the village life during the revolutionary period, and political and historical information, students of contemporary Iran and cultural anthropology would benefit from reading this rare longitudinal ethnographic study.
