No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
In an Arab country that boasts the highest female literacy rate in the region (79.4% in 1998) and arguably the best educational system, how is it that Jordanian women's participation in the economy falls so terribly short of the hopeful expectations generated by these facts? In her study of women in Jordan, Amira El-Azhary Sonbol provides answers to this question. First, while the Jordanian constitution proclaims equal rights for women, specific legal codes limit these rights. Second, school curricula and classroom practices are gendered, encouraging early marriage for girls, not the pursuit of a career. Third, social attitudes continue to be patriarchal. While all the chapters of the book are written with the aim of addressing Sonbol's central concern, they are also intended to stand individually. The format serves a practical purpose: to facilitate discussion and promote legal change in Jordan and elsewhere.
In an Arab country that boasts the highest female literacy rate in the region (79.4% in 1998) and arguably the best educational system, how is it that Jordanian women's participation in the economy falls so terribly short of the hopeful expectations generated by these facts? In her study of women in Jordan, Amira El-Azhary Sonbol provides answers to this question. First, while the Jordanian constitution proclaims equal rights for women, specific legal codes limit these rights. Second, school curricula and classroom practices are gendered, encouraging early marriage for girls, not the pursuit of a career. Third, social attitudes continue to be patriarchal. While all the chapters of the book are written with the aim of addressing Sonbol's central concern, they are also intended to stand individually. The format serves a practical purpose: to facilitate discussion and promote legal change in Jordan and elsewhere.
The second and third chapters offer historical studies of Jordan's legal system and pre-modern court cases involving women's work. Sonbol explains that it is modern personal-status laws that constitute the greatest hindrance to women's ability to work and own businesses. Specific codes embedded within these laws constrain women's constitutional right to work. Efforts to amend or reform these laws have met with considerable resistance, as the prevailing moral discourse legitimates these laws as having originated in shari

a. Sonbol carefully deconstructs Jordan's legal system, demonstrating that most laws pertaining to women actually consist not of shari

a but of a patchwork of tribal, customary, and Western law, as well as medieval fiqh. Using early Islamic sources and pre-modern shari

a court records, she offers a history of Muslim women's work in the Middle Eastern region. Sonbol shows that along with the stories of the early Muslim community that speak to the involvement of women in politics, business, and community service, Ottoman court records clearly demonstrate women's full participation in local economies. Women owned land, administered awqāf (religious endowments), served as midwives, extended credit, and worked in fields such as weaving, soap making, and agriculture. Sonbol wonders that “today women are fighting an uphill battle to achieve what their sisters already had a hundred years ago” (p. 80). While modern Islamic discourse blames Western influence for Jordanian women's recent demands for equal participation in society, Sonbol argues that it is the modern transformation to the nation-state, with industrialization, capitalism, and Western banking and finance systems, that marginalized Muslim women.
The remaining chapters focus on the situation in Jordan today regarding women's ability to work. They address current laws and court cases, efforts of women's professional associations to encourage women to own businesses, and strategies for legal reform. In Chapter 4, Sonbol argues that, despite the state's efforts to improve women's working conditions, laws regulating taxation, retirement and pension, and social security actually serve as factors that encourage women to retire early. Chapters 5–7 show how laws and court practices involving marriage, divorce, guardianship, and honor crimes discourage women from working. Sonbol demonstrates not only that the law favors husbands and male family relatives but also that, when the law supports women, individual judges often distort it to protect men's interests. Chapter 5 discusses the concept of

urf, or traditional law, and explains how it shapes the construction of gender in Jordan. Through school, television, and other media, women are taught to be obedient and dependent. While the state has in fact worked to grant women more rights, women hesitate to exercise them for fear of social censure. More than that, the specter of the growing rate of honor crimes threatens women to stay well within the bounds of social expectation.
Women of Jordan rests at the intersection of studies of women, law, Islam, and the Middle East. Sonbol's exploration of the origins of Jordan's legal system demonstrates the complexity of the genesis and constitution of personal-status law. She also reveals the striking irony of contemporary Islamic discourses that defend patriarchal laws as deriving from shari

a and accuse reformers of adopting Western attitudes when, in fact, the very same laws they defend often have European origins. Because of the tenacious hold these discourses have on Jordanian society, Sonbol explains that women's associations desiring change have garnered examples of women in Islamic tradition fully participating in the economy to show how Jordan's current laws are neither Islamic nor just. By demonstrating that Jordan's laws have been created by the state rather than by God, Sonbol hopes to show that they can just as easily be changed by the state.
In the Conclusion, Sonbol makes an important theoretical point: that Jordan's political and commercial elites rely on tribal leaders to fill positions in the country's security forces. This point is essential for understanding the state's deference to tribal leaders and, hence, its reluctance to overturn patriarchal laws supported by the tribes. Sonbol argues that the confluence of these interests forms the “hegemony” that prevents the advancement of women. She uses the term “hegemony” liberally throughout the book, assuming the underlying theoretical structure that is explained fully only at the end. Had this been addressed earlier in the text, the overall analysis would have been sharper.