In Main Street Public Library, library historian Wayne A. Wiegand, F. Summers Professor of Library and Information Studies Emeritus in the School of Library and Information Studies at Florida State University, undertakes an analysis of the role of public libraries in small mid-western towns. Wiegand's study spans the years from 1876, when the US government published its first report on public libraries, to 1956, the date of the enactment of the federal Library Service Act which provided federal funds for public library services through state library agencies. Wiegand opens his book with the provocative and, for many, surprising statistic that the United States has more public libraries than McDonald's restaurants and also notes that in the first decade of the twenty-first century, two-thirds of Americans made at least one annual visit to the public library. He provides ample proof that the American public library continues to be a well-used and pervasive public institution, particularly in small towns, since eighty percent of public library systems in the United States serve towns with populations of less than 25,000. However, surprisingly little research has been done on the history of the small-town public library, a gap this book is intended to redress.
The first four chapters of the book are devoted to meticulous case studies of the formation and growth of four public libraries: the Bryant Library of Sauk Centre, Minnesota; the Sage Public Library of Osage, Iowa; the Charles H. Moore Library of Lexington, Michigan; and the Rhinelander Public Library of Rhinelander, Wisconsin. Wiegand traces the establishment of these libraries, the formation and membership of their library boards, and the personalities, qualifications and performance of their librarians. The result is a rich and detailed portrait of small-town public libraries in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, a portrait which challenges the traditional assumption that the public library's primary role during this time was to function as an educational institution, providing information essential to an informed democratic society. Rather, Wiegand maintains that the education was an important but ultimately secondary goal; he argues that these four small-town public libraries functioned primarily as agents of social harmony through two key strategies. First, these libraries provided safe public spaces to assimilate newcomers into the community and to reinforce appropriate social behaviours, to manifest civic participation and to celebrate citizenship. As such, the libraries functioned as positive agents of socialization, habituating citizens into the local culture while, at the same time, celebrating reading and literacy. This gave rise to the second primary function of the small-town public library: the promotion of social harmony through shared reading.
In the fifth chapter of his book, Wiegand provides a compelling analysis of the crucial debate in professional public librarianship over the imperative to provide readers either with edifying, high-quality literature or with popular books, including a quote from the 1921 Bulletin of the Iowa Library Commission which castigated some libraries for the egregious mistake of advertising their new fiction in the local newspaper. The author of the Bulletin argued,
The desire to attract people to the library is legitimate, but to attempt to do so with new fiction as bait is like tempting a sick person to eat food which will make him sicker and also increase the percentage of sickness in the town. (150)
Clearly library professionals of the time felt that reading popular fiction was dangerous and would lead to a proliferation of negative social consequences; hence the appeal to librarians to promote “good reading” rather than popular reading. Wiegand, however, provides clear evidence that, although the broad library profession attempted to exert its power to recommend certain titles through an increasing number of collection guides and review periodicals, the librarians in these four communities provided collections which reflected their local community's particular reading interests rather than prescribed reading lists. Librarians in these four small towns stocked their shelves with recommended titles, but they also responded to local demand for the popular fiction titles which accounted for seventy-five percent of each library's circulation. Wiegand maintains that it was popular fiction which helped immigrants assimilate into the local culture through shared reading, which offered accessible models for successful living and problem solving.
This is a well-researched and very readable book which will attract anyone with an interest in the history of reading for pleasure, libraries, print culture or censorship. It successfully fills a gap in the library-history literature in its detailed and carefully documented portraits of small-town public libraries during decades of tremendous social change.
