Tax theory, as discussed by economists, focuses on positive aspects of a tax system, and takes any value system for evaluating the normative questions as given. Thus, any tax economist picking up Louis Eisenstein's book ventures immediately into uncharted territory. Eisenstein, a tax lawyer, focuses on the beliefs that people hold about how tax burdens ought to be determined. Certainly anybody who has any convictions about the right level of taxation will have them seriously challenged at some point while reading it.
First appearing in 1961 and now back in print, the book outlines the three main ideologies of taxation: ability to pay, barriers and deterrents, and equity. The ideology of ability to pay says that income (or wealth), without any adjustments, directly determines one's proper tax burden. The ideology of barriers and deterrents claims that taxes are perennially too high and threaten to crush economic activity. The ideology of equity states that those who are equally well-off should be equally taxed; this is sometimes called horizontal equity. Eisenstein devotes a chapter to each of these as they operate in theory and an additional one or two chapters to the legislation they produce in practice. Efficiency lovers will be heartbroken to read of some of these laws. Nearly all are still on the books.
There is little chance that your personal belief system escapes criticism. Academics, then, will view this book as invigorating. The author is never content to offer a few good arguments against something; instead, he insists on completely dismantling the rhetoric and results of each ideology. He points out that each ideology is riddled with inconsistencies, but that even complete consistency would lead to some ridiculous outcomes. Believers in each lobby for laws that conflict with their preferred ideology. For ability to pay, it is the differing exemptions given based on age, marital status, and disability, among others. For barriers and deterrents, it is the special treatment of capital gains and the tax break known as percentage depletion. For equity, it is the existence of loopholes, and of course the difference between a loophole and justice is which end of it you find yourself on. As a lawyer, he is able to use the lines drawn in the tax code to great effect. Why does raising and selling poultry result in an ordinary income tax liability, but the same with livestock is treated as a capital gain? Why is there even a preferential rate for capital gains when the ideology of ability to pay does not distinguish between income sources? Eisenstein has quite a deal of fun in the process. He uses religious rhetoric to describe the adherents to each ideology, the homilies that they preach, and the fiscal sins that they commit. When he isn't describing them as blind religious fanatics, he paints them as Orwellian doublespeakers. One of his favorite tactics is to take two adherents of an ideology, who supposedly ought to agree, and pit their rhetoric against each other.
Eisenstein assembles an impressive collection of quotes from politicians, academics, secretaries of the Treasury, lawyers, and citizens dating back as far as Adam Smith. They usually betray the fact that though the tax system may radically change, the language around it never will. Despite the radical changes in marginal tax rates over the life of the federal income tax, there are always many who warn us that we teeter on the brink of economic destruction if rates are not cut. Eisenstein digs up old party platforms and finds that “[i]n 1920 the Republicans announced that 'one of the chief needs of the country is the revision of taxation as one way to lower the cost of living, restore business confidence, and stimulate enterprise.' From this program, the Republicans have never departed” (pp. 54–55). Fifty years on, we should not be surprised to see that they still have not, given the stubbornness of these three ideologies. Democrats are ridiculed as well, but they are mocked for their inconsistency with one another, particularly within the ideology of ability to pay, rather than the Republicans' strict adherence to party doctrine.
The book is not without its drawbacks. The evidence is entirely anecdotal or based off single examples. This is a blessing to tax scholars who may be looking for research inspiration, but it is difficult to get a broad understanding of the tax system. Readers should look elsewhere if that is needed. The author could make great use of a few well-placed graphs and tables. He notes that progressive marginal rates are of limited use when the effective tax rates are often far lower, but offers only a snapshot of effective rates. Some readers will enjoy Eisenstein's mild sarcasm, and others will be bothered. His repetition of arguments causes some chapters to be needlessly lengthened. One must wonder what tax system would please Eisenstein.
The answer seems to be that there is none. Eisenstein warns that political battles over taxation are fundamentally about the desire to pay less. The ideologies can be blindly followed because they are not important; they are merely the means to that desired end.
