The Oslo Accords of 1993 initially appeared to be the first step toward the end of the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip and the creation of two states side by side despite the huge power disparities between them. That hope of a serious transformation is reflected in such studies as Glenn E. Robinson's Building a Palestinian State: The Incomplete Revolution (1997), Amal Jamal's Media Politics and Democracy in Palestine (2005) and his The Palestinian National Movement (2005), as well as the analysis of institution-building efforts by Nathan J. Brown, Palestinian Politics after the Oslo Accords (2003). Jamal and Brown remain cautiously optimistic, even in the wake of the eruption of the second intifada in 2000, the complete breakdown in negotiations, and the reoccupation of virtually all of the territories in 2002.
Others, such as Rex Brynen in A Very Political Economy (2000), sound urgent warnings that Israel's closure of the territories, barriers to movement within the West Bank and Gaza Strip, and accelerated confiscation of land for Jewish settlements contradicted the basic assumptions that underpinned Oslo. Life for Palestinians became harsher, more constricted, and more unbearable than it had been when Israeli control was overt and direct. (Those who have read Sara Roy's profound The Gaza Strip: The Political Economy of De-Development [2001] will recall that it did not seem possible that the situation could become much worse. Yet, today it is far worse than even Brynen expected.)
Although providing important insights into political, economic, and diplomatic developments since Oslo, those studies do not provide an unmediated sense of the day-to-day lives of people in Palestine. In contrast, Amira Hass's haunting Drinking the Sea at Gaza: Days and Nights in a Land Under Siege (1996, published in English in 1999) and Maya Rosenfeld's Confronting the Occupation (2004) detail the coping strategies devised as the noose has tightened around the necks of Palestinians living in the Gaza Strip and in the Dheisheh camp (Bethlehem), respectively. Recent eyewitness accounts give voice to Palestinians struggling under these conditions.1
For example, Joshua Hammer, A Season in Bethlehem (2003); Muna Hamzeh, Refugees in Our Own Land: Chronicles from a Palestinian Refugee Camp in Bethlehem (2001); Wendy Pearlman, Occupied Voices: Stories of Everyday Life from the Second Intifada (2003); and Nancy Stohlman and Laurieann Aladin, eds., Live from Palestine (2003). Chronicles from the first intifada include John Collins, Occupied by Memory: The Intifada and the Palestinian State of Emergency (2004) and Helen Winternitz, A Season of Stones: Living in a Palestinian Village (1992)
The harsh realities are central to Laititia Bucaille's hard-hitting portrait of young people who lived through the sharp disappointments and setbacks of the late 1990s and the early 21st century. She focuses on three young men from the Balata refugee camp (Nablus) who gained a sense of purpose and enthusiasm as teenage activists during the first intifada, were hardened while in jail with other political prisoners, and turned to armed violence in 1991, only to be deported in 1992. They supported the peace process and returned to Nablus in late 1995 but were quickly disillusioned with the reassertion of power by the urban elite families, the corruption within the Palestinian Authority, Israel's continued de facto occupation, and their own inability to find productive roles and careers. Lacking education and connections, unable to establish stable family lives, they remain nostalgic for the intifada and, not surprisingly, return to violence in the 2000 intifada despite their dream of “a country without war and without weapons” (p. 112). Bucaille vividly depicts their acute sense of being trapped: with no future in Palestine and no way to get out, death becomes a way—perhaps the only way—to “escape … from pain and disappointment” (p. 120). They nonetheless are shocked at their younger siblings' preoccupation with becoming “hero-martyrs” (p. 139). Those teenage brothers have even narrower horizons, have never had any humanizing contact with Israelis, and have no hope for the future. Self-sacrifice as “human bombs” (p. 134) becomes their sole means “to regain control over their lives” (p. 137).
Bucaille, an assistant professor of sociology at the University of Bordeaux II, authored Gaza: la violence de la paix (1998) and published the French original of this book in 2002. The text has been slightly updated for the English edition. Her sociological and political analyses, although not as unique as the personal vignettes, reinforce the “sense of imprisonment and suffocation” (p. 87) in the supposedly liberated territories, the profiteering by Palestinian Authority leaders, the crushing and paralysis of the economy, and the forcing of people's lives to turn in on themselves. She clearly delineates the class conflicts within Palestinian society—evident at the time of the first intifada—which were exacerbated by the actions of the “returnee” political elite, by the Islamist challenge, and by the territorial fragmentation: “These special, social, and ideological divisions reacted with one another and grew harder and harder to manage” (p. 57). Although Bucaille sees some hope in the election of Mahmoud Abbas to the presidency, his interest in integrating “the Islamists into the political arena” (p. 162), and the subsequent conditional agreement by Hamas and Islamic Jihad to halt attacks on Israel, her overall analysis is profoundly pessimistic. Politicians and analysts who bandy about terms like “;terrorists” should examine Bucaille's findings in order to come to grips with the spatial, social, and psychological realities that entrap Palestine and the Palestinian people.
