Even though Arnold Sommerfeld and his school are commonly regarded as major contributors to the formation of quantum theory, little has been written on the origins, development and impact of Sommerfeld's brand of theory-making. Suman Seth's Crafting the Quantum aims at filling this gap with much attention to the cultural conditions and the diversity of practices in the then-emerging theoretical physics.
Seth defines Sommerfeld's approach as a ‘physics of problems’ in which well-defined rules and sound mathematics are applied to a great variety of specific problems, with much attention to phenomenological and computational details. Seth nuances this picture by bringing in Sommerfeld's early attachment to the electromagnetic world view, his ideal of a complete unified theory of microphysical phenomena, and the aesthetic dimension of his quantum numerology.
Seth regards Sommerfeld's mature style as the resultant of his threefold background in mathematics, technical mechanics and physics. Sommerfeld originally saw himself as a mathematician bringing his skills to the service of applied mechanics and physics, in the spirit of his mentor Felix Klein's cross-disciplinary projects. After a few years of teaching technical mechanics at the Technische Hochschule in Aachen, he obtained the chair of theoretical physics in Munich, from which he trained a large number of theoretical physicists of the following generations.
Seth explains this enormous success by diverse characteristics of Sommerfeld's teaching: his lively mode of exposition, his frequent appeal to figures and mechanisms, the place he gave to elementary considerations, his dwelling on unsolved problems, sessions of supervised problem solving in parallel with the course, and a personal acquaintanceship with the students. Sommerfeld also benefitted from the contemporary surge of theoretical physics owing to the financial difficulties of experimental physics in the impoverished Weimar Republic. As proofs of this evolution, Seth cites Lenard's and Stark's famous attacks, and what he wittily dubs the ‘discovery of the Pauli effect’, namely the multiplication of stories of the perturbation of experiments by the mere proximity of the proudly pure theorist Wolfgang Pauli.
Seth judiciously contrasts Sommerfeld's physics of problems with the ‘physics of principles’ of two contemporary theorists, Max Planck and Niels Bohr. By physics of principles, Seth sometimes means any theoretical physics that has the philosophical ambition of providing firm and general foundations. He occasionally means something more similar to Poincaré's physique des principes: a theory defined by means of general principles of empirical origin, and not by the constructive combination of hypothetical elements. The latter definition applies to Max Planck, who sought a via media between Mach's positivism and the rising theoretical microphysics of Ludwig Boltzmann, Hendrik Lorentz and others. As Seth explains, Planck applied the principles of thermodynamics to ideal processes performed on coarsely defined systems. He did not require the experimental realizability of these processes or the experimental accessibility of the finer details of the systems. Seth finds this view embodied in Planck's early works on the thermodynamics of solutions and continued in his later works. In early quantum theory, Planck sought to determine the quantum structure of phase space through thermostatistical considerations that blurred the kinematics of individual atoms and molecules. In contrast, Sommerfeld quantized the motion of individual electrons and intertwined his analysis with aspects of the rising experimental microphysics.
In another illuminating contrast, Seth opposes Sommerfeld's quantum pursuits around 1920 to Bohr's principles of correspondence and mechanical transformability. He emphasizes the flexible and global character of these principles, contrasting them with the local and rigid character of Sommerfeld's rules for extracting quantum regularities. Despite his early success in quantizing the multiperiodic motion for the relativistic Kepler model of the hydrogen atom, Sommerfeld gradually came to renounce most modelling in favour of a narrow quantum numerology based on Ritz's combination rule and on selection rules. In contrast, Bohr long persisted in relating empirical spectra to properties of the orbital motion of intra-atomic electrons. Sommerfeld disliked this correspondence-based approach for involving what he saw as a vague, unwarranted analogy between quantum theory and classical electrodynamics. As Seth forcefully argues, Wolfgang Pauli was being very Sommerfeldian when he reduced the construction of the periodic table of elements to a quantum-numerological principle (the exclusion principle) that no longer appealed to the orbital model.
Seth's analysis of the theoretical practice of Sommerfeld, Planck and Bohr is limited to aspects that did not imply advanced mathematics. Whereas it is accurate and lucid in this register, it is only allusive and sometimes inaccurate when it comes to higher mathematical physics (there are errors in equations on pp. 34, 101, 146, 167, 195; notation is not always defined; there is a wrong statement of Liouville's theorem on p. 157). This limitation is regrettable because much of Sommerfeld's work implied a creative use of advanced mathematics, of which we see nothing, because Andrew Warwick's idea of ‘technical unity’ in theory-making, which Seth evokes, would need to be fleshed out by identifying Sommerfeld's preferred techniques, and because for a while the quantization of multiperiodic systems was an essential component of Munich-style quantum theory.
Attention to the latter point leads to a somewhat different view of the opposition between Copenhagen and Munich styles. It was not only about the usefulness of modelling the intra-atomic motion. It also was about the kinds of models employed. Bohr's model of the atom was made of a set of electrons orbiting around the nucleus, it was meant to be realistic (Bohr never called it a model), it was not computable except for hydrogen and helium, and its construction largely rested on the correspondence principle. In contrast, Sommerfeld and followers (Heisenberg, Landé and Pauli) sought multiperiodic systems that replaced Bohr's model for a limited purpose. True, Sommerfeld came to dislike even this limited sort of modelling around 1922, and so too did Pauli in 1923. But its importance in the history of Sommerfeldian quantum theory cannot be underrated.
Despite some limitations, Seth's study goes very far in illuminating Sommerfeld's role in shaping the early history of theoretical physics. Seth's excellent scholarship will no doubt serve future biographies of Sommerfeld and provide much useful background for the writing of fuller histories of quantum physics.
