Even before completing his dissertation in 2004, Charles Hiroshi Garrett had emerged as a rare figure striving to explore the disciplinary identity of American music studies—a field whose “central problem,” in the words of Richard Crawford cited in Garrett's introduction, “has been, and continues to be, to define the range and scope of the subject” (5). The term American music, problematic in itself, here denotes music of the United States, but, in the course of Garrett's explorations, its nature as a field of scholarly inquiry gets debated and enriched, if, thankfully, not resolved.
The book that reports those explorations, Struggling to Define a Nation: American Music and the Twentieth Century, caps a period of several years in which Garrett has developed, tested, and refined his ideas in conference papers and a major article in the flagship journal of the American Musicological Society (AMS), the organization representing Garrett's principal scholarly identity as a musicologist. That he won national awards from the AMS and the Society for American Music as he pursued this work testifies to his impact even before the book's publication.
The book, although expanding on Ph.D. research, does not read like a dissertation because of its large scope, its bold but carefully defended interpretations, and a writing style marked by unusual clarity and fluency. Perhaps many readers have already heard or read versions of Garrett's chapters as conference papers or articles, but now, with the book in hand, they may be struck for the first time by the consistency, coherence, and musical and intellectual richness of the whole. Although the five case studies focus chiefly on the first three decades of the twentieth century, they are designed to resonate into the twenty-first. Fascinating in their own right, the chapters coexist to develop an approach that trains a spotlight on cultural contestation as a defining feature of the field. Garrett notes that his approach itself is not new in musicology—he cites the work of Robert Walser (heavy metal) and David Ake (jazz) as models in this regard—but applying it to the broader historiography of American music marks his original contribution. Garrett's perspective thus reinforces and enlarges an emergent paradigm that signals a new-found security and confidence in a field whose pioneering figures—such as Sonneck, Lowens, Chase, Hitchcock, Hamm, and Crawford—struggled (a word as apt for scholars as for their subjects) to take the subject from the margins to the center of musicological discourse.
Garrett's work both confirms the disciplinary identity and centrality of American music studies and challenges its boundaries. Reviewing earlier work that conceived the field holistically, Garrett detects a tone of advocacy and celebratory pluralism that, in his view, suppresses the often contested nature of musical life in the United States. By using the work of recent scholars in disparate fields linked by their interest in critical analysis, Garrett brings power struggle to the center of his narrative in a more explicit way than any other musicologist has attempted, while also warning against a knee-jerk sociology that locates musical value within a resistance-to-oppression frame. In the process, Garrett confronts many persistent and outdated assumptions, including four woven into this review: (1) the tendentious artifice of a hierarchical high–low conception of musical idioms, (2) the related tendency to seek expressions of national identity in “classical” (allegedly “high”) music genres such as concert music and opera, (3) the persistence of American exceptionalism, that is, the belief that the American story in music is unique and can be told chiefly within the borders of the continental United States, (4) and the acceptance of advocacy as American music historiography's prevailing tone, adopted within a musicological community that was once suspicious of the field's validity.
More than two decades after Lawrence Levine's Highbrow/Lowbrow Footnote 1 located U.S. cultural values in the eyes of the beholder and not in the thing beheld (whether Shakespeare, opera, symphonic music, or visual art), “high” and “low” continue in some quarters to be terms used to describe artworks, with “high” supposedly connoting works of enduring value and “low” connoting evanescence and vulgarity. (“High” and “low” remain useful only when historicized and considered in relation to the person using the terms.) Garrett's target is bigger than that old bromide, however. As he challenges the artificiality of a high–low conception of American musical categories, he also warns against Pollyanna pluralism, or, in his words, “a historiographical model that prizes diversity without accounting for relations of power” (8). Garrett brings such concept thinking down to the level of actual music making. Thus, when contesting musical styles come together in a single place, such as the gospel hymns and ragtime in Ives's Four Ragtime Dances or the blues and “Spanish tinge” in Jelly Roll Morton's “New Orleans Blues,” Garrett argues, “the point, it seems, is not that varied musical practices are meeting on common ground, sharing space equally, and learning to get along perfectly, but that they are crossing over and colliding, bumping up against one another, struggling to be heard above the commotion, even as they participate in the process of trying to work things out” (45).
That statement summarizes Garrett's view of scholarship as well as of music history, as he asks of Ives's piece: “Are we to understand this work as a progressive step toward racial understanding or as a perpetuation of unequal race relations?” (43). Such social questions, Garrett demonstrates, require engagement in musical details to an extent that proves the need for musicological credentials to provide a sensible answer. Grounding his Ives analysis in the complementary but conflicting interpretations of J. Peter Burkholder (emphasizing the musical and aesthetic resonance of Ives's borrowings) and Lawrence Kramer (emphasizing the social, racial, and ethical dimensions), Garrett historicizes Ives's notions of ragtime and its racial implications as he shows that Ives's staged collision of gospel hymns and ragtime is a drama that remains purposefully “unable to reach a decisive resolution” (45). The answer to his question about the piece is “both.”
Garrett highlights such unresolved clashes in his other case studies as well—all of which stand outside the so-called classical tradition that Ives represents. He announces his focus on Jelly Roll Morton in chapter 2, for example, as part of an effort “to counteract the tendency to focus discourse about American identity on concert music and to avoid framing the story of popular music strictly in terms of its relationship to the concert music world” (49). In particular, Garrett highlights an aspect of Morton's music that has been long recognized but not analyzed or placed in the kind of rich historical context found here: the “Spanish tinge.” This term Morton himself used to describe the musical foundation for many of his compositions and performances, including habanera and tresillo rhythms that characterize the composer-pianist's left-hand patterns. For Garrett, demonstrating Morton's lifelong commitment to the “Spanish tinge” accomplishes many tasks: it challenges the French emphasis in discussions of Morton's (and other jazz musicians') mixed, Creole identity as it also breaks down simplistic black-white oppositions and U.S. exceptionalism that, in his view, saturate jazz historiography and other areas of American music research. With close analysis of several pieces, Garrett insists not only on the pervasiveness of the Spanish tinge in Morton's entire life and work, but also on using the Spanish tinge as “a symbol for the broad diversity and international pedigree of jazz history” (80)—a theme much more pronounced in the history of jazz after 1945 than during Morton's lifetime.
Subsequent chapters reinforce Garrett's case for mining a variety of vernacular idioms as the most promising avenue for considering his subject's boundaries and scholarly thrust. Each one focuses on a single piece through which Garrett can explore a wide range of historiographical issues. In a chapter on Louis Armstrong, Garrett interprets the classic recording “Gully Low Blues” as a “densely compressed migration narrative” (107) in which Armstrong articulates and answers, both as singer and trumpet player, questions about the place of African Americans in the urban north. Garrett asks: “Is it possible to hear the sound of Chicago in Armstrong's music of the 1920s?” (84), and the entire chapter—sprinkled with a significant number of speculative “would haves” and “might haves”—explores his convincing notion that the answer is a “qualified yes.” The final two chapters take up Tin Pan Alley songs as exemplars of ways in which race, ethnicity, and identity—specifically Asian American and Hawaiian—have been defined in song and repeatedly redefined in performance. The chapter on “Chinatown, My Chinatown” is a tour de force that charts the famous song's “dynamic and mutable” musical orientalism (128) across a century from its first performance in 1910 to recent incarnations in films and video games. The chapter had a special, if somewhat uncomfortable, resonance for me, because the song had been performed in the high school boys' glee club in which I sang with my best friend, Wonsuck Kim, the son of Korean immigrants. With the exception of work by handful of musicologists, such songs have barely registered on the discipline's radar screen, but after Garrett proves the resilience of “Chinatown, My Chinatown” in U.S. culture, it is hard to argue with his claim that it, and other ethnic novelty songs of its era, “must be regarded as central to Tin Pan Alley, vital to the development of American music” (164). An earlier version of this chapter appeared as a 2004 article;Footnote 2 here, slightly revised, it takes on greater force as it is woven into the book's larger plan. The final chapter on Hawaii's role in the American musical imagination brings the long-exoticized islands from the geographical and intellectual rim to the historiographical core of Garrett's project and reinforces his view that Tin Pan Alley song offers rich material for exploring a variety of crucial issues in the study of the music of the United States.
The book invites some reflection on its place in the scholarly pantheon, for I believe it will prove useful and illuminating for years to come. In overall conception and in specific details, the book bears the marks of what might be called the “UCLA School” of Americanist musicology. Beyond citing Robert Walser and David Ake (both of whom Garrett encountered at UCLA) as models, the book reveals its orientation in an explicit effort to synthesize historical musicology with critical and ethical engagement—in short, with the politics of scholarship. Like other work in this “school,” it also reveals a commitment to the close reading of musical texts (scores and recordings), while perhaps placing less importance on exhaustive immersion in primary source material. (For key claims in the Morton chapter, for example, Garrett relies chiefly on the sheet music of “New Orleans Blues,” which remains a problematic and simplified source of the piece—or any jazz for that matter—and cannot be viewed as an authoritative representation of Morton's thinking.) This approach, moreover, favors a book-conception that constructs several disparate case studies to illustrate a more general theme and to offer an alternative, revisionist historiography. It eschews advocacy for its subjects in favor of an analysis of the dynamic power relationships that musical works encode. In striving to make its truth known, such an approach, in less capable hands, has appeared to some observers to be incautious and lacking in scholarly rigor. But that is not Garrett's style. His writing features a blend of precision and modesty reminiscent of yet another scholar he cites as a model: Mark Tucker. Indeed, Garrett's work reflects his absorption of, and respect for, a variety of musical and scholarly styles. More than a product of any one “school,” then, Garrett actually carries on the tradition of pioneering figures in the field with his capacious interest in the whole—that is, like the earlier generation of scholars on whose work he builds, he conceives “American Music Studies” as a coherent, if contentious, field.
Garrett writes in full awareness that his picture remains necessarily and happily incomplete, and that several other, entirely different, books with the same title surely could be written that place more emphasis on oral traditions (the book, despite two jazz-oriented chapters, leans decisively toward the printed score); on Jewish and Native American identity; on gender and sexuality; on politics; on religion; on media such as recording, radio, and film; and on developments in the postwar era—indeed most of the major musical developments since about 1930. Garrett's case studies fall within a narrower range than his title suggests: the “twentieth-century” examples are largely confined within that century's first three decades, and the “struggling to define a nation” plays out here chiefly as a clashing and bumping together of a few representative races and ethnicities—European American, African American, Creole, Chinese, and Hawaiian. Their implications continue to resonate today, however, and the book stands as a kind of how-to manual for anyone seeking to move “notions of tension and debate from the sidelines to the center” (8). Indeed, the book stands as a thrilling challenge to others, as well as an accomplishment in its own right. For if the book's “struggle” has been cast as one among musicians and musical idioms in the past, it also promises that, for scholars of “American” music, the struggle in the future is also our own.
