This ambitious book is intended as an introductory text; it assumes no previous knowledge about Southeast Asia. The author offers ‘a decentered world regional history’ focusing on Southeast Asia, with such a strong emphasis on the links between this region and East Asia that some such term as ‘East-Southeast Asia’ is called for to encompass it. South Asia and the Indian Ocean are frequently alluded to, but ‘it was China through its age-old Tributary Trade Networks that provided the essential stability and continuity enabling a brilliant age of commerce’ (p. xiii).
The author inveighs against the domination of Asian history by a focus on the nation, and ‘situates [his book] within a new genre of writing on zones between nations’, instead advocating the study of Asian hybridities (p. xiv). Broad-brush history books can be fun if, like this one, they identify new building blocks and assemble them in different ways, challenging one's assumptions about the relative importance of particular variables and the nature of their relationships. Some major blocks in this volume include: the influence of bullion, ceramics, and silk on the course of economic development; Southeast Asia's links with Japan, Ryukyu, and Korea, as well as China; the tributary trade system; and the formation and influence of diasporic communities. The volume is nicely structured; each chapter begins with a list of questions, most of them stimulating, and ends with a clear conclusion.
The introduction asks whether the region experienced an ‘age of commerce’ beginning around 1450. Geoffrey Gunn notes Geoff Wade's suggestion that an earlier age of commerce began as early as 1000, and ‘suggests a bold revision of Reid's celebration of the late 15th century as signalling the arrival of an ‘age of commerce’ in Southeast Asia’ (p. 21). Chapter two mainly consists of a narrative history of Southeast Asian ‘charter’ kingdoms which owes much to Victor Lieberman, with linguistic and archaeological additions. Chapter three examines the rise of Islamic sultanates in order to shed light on ‘the world-historical incorporation of these scattered polities but, in the process, highlight their separate and collective historical trajectories in the making of a global region outside of powerful, rationalising national histories and discourses.’ Chapter four contains a brief but excellent characterisation of the tributary trade system (p. 104), though it may give the impression that this was a unique relationship, whereas it can be considered a special case of the ‘port of trade’ system common throughout the Indian Ocean.
Chapter five explores indigenous monetary systems in Southeast Asia. The next three chapters chart the progress of the Portuguese and Spanish, the Dutch and English, followed by an interesting discussion of the Japanese Nihon-Machi. Chapter nine follows the work of other economic historians in exploring the importance of silver from c.1500, and the effects of imported metal on Southeast Asia. Chapter ten refreshingly focuses on the formation and development of trade networks devoted to another important but often neglected commodity: pottery. This chapter could have been strengthened by reference to Zhao Rugua or Wang Dayuan, who gave detailed guidance for Chinese exporters on the goods, including ceramics, which were in demand in dozens of Southeast Asian ports. The book's conclusion is that ‘a coherent East Asian community existed, in which many people, ethnicities, and creeds participated. Out of this community emerged myriad hybrid associations that render many essentialist notions of state and race questionable’ (p. 316).
The author of any large-scale synthesis is no doubt prepared to be challenged on various points. Among the book's premises which could be debated is the importance of the tributary trade system, which forms a basic component of the overall work. On a lower level of importance, the sections on pre-1500 Southeast Asia contain numerous contestable statements. The statement (p. 40) that ‘Old Malay or kawi was also written with an adapted Sanskrit script’ confuses scripts with languages. ‘Pangakalan Bujung’ (correctly Pengkalan Bujang) could not have been attacked and destroyed by the Chola in 1025 (p. 43). The artefacts at the site are mainly from the twelfth and thirteenth century; the shrines there are mostly Hindu, and therefore probably built by the Chola. Mahmud Shah's reign in Melaka is given incorrect dates (p. 87), as are the Zheng He voyages (p. 104).
Totok and Peranakan are not synonyms but antonyms (p. 116). Parameswara does not appear in the Sejarah Melayu (p. 85). The dates given for the Belitung shipwreck (p. 272) are a century too late. The Yuan were overthrown by the Ming in 1368, and consequently could not have been responsible for the reoccupation of Vietnam in the early 15th century (p. 272). No Hizen ware has been found in Singapore (p. 285). Yang Bin is wrongly alphabetised under Bin in the bibliography. Sheldon Pollock's surname is consistently spelled ‘Pollack’. Prambanan is spelled ‘Prambangan’ (p. 42). Further examples can be cited.
The book can be praised for its tight structure and stimulating choice of themes. It is unfortunate that many of the historical details are incorrect, which lessens its value as a text for introductory students. Perhaps a revised edition could eliminate these small, but important problems.
