Why do we care about inequality? The classical economists thought that capital accumulation was the key to growth, and since world capital markets were closed during their time, and since the rich did all the saving (even on the margin), inequality was good for growth. In contrast, when the neoclassical economists staring writing, the first global century was in full swing—world capital markets were integrated and domestic savings no longer constrained accumulation: inequality didn't matter as much for growth. When Moses Abramovitz and Robert Solow showed us in the 1960s that total factor productivity advance—the residual—was far more important than capital accumulation, economists lost interest in inequality entirely. But a little later, human capital and mass education came to dominate thinking about growth, and the classical economists were turned on their heads: inequality was bad for growth. About two decades ago, this position was clinched when neo-institutional thinking began to dominate our views of long-run development. Now, income distribution gets center stage again, since we believe that economic inequality breeds political inequality, and that the latter breeds policies and institutions that favor rent-seeking and disfavor growth, including mass education. It is not by chance that one of the leading examples of recent neo-institutional thinking comes from both economic historians and from Latin America, although there have certainly been others plowing the same field.Footnote 1
There are two big facts out there that have attracted special attention to the region: first, Latin America exhibited a disappointing growth performance across the twentieth century; and second, Latin America had (and still has) the most unequal income distribution of any region in the Third World. Correlation invites a search for causation.
Ewout Frankema's Has Latin America Always Been Unequal (hereafter Unequal) deals with that connection across what he calls the long twentieth century, 1870–2000. Unequal was defended in March 2008 at the University of Groningen as the author's Ph.D. thesis, but it sure reads like much more: it is a mature, thoughtful, and important book. True, others have also written recently about Latin American inequality in the very long run, but nobody has done it with quite the depth and breadth offered by Unequal.Footnote 2
One of the great strengths of this book is that it places Latin American experience in comparative perspective from the Introduction onwards. Here the author compares late twentieth-century Latin American inequality with the rest of the world before giving the reader an analytic overview. Like the rest of the book, that overview is not technical but it is very effective in organizing thinking. In particular, the following three important building blocks are laid: first, the late nineteenth century was all about labor and unequally held land, and the commodity terms of trade drove relative returns to them (e.g., inequality); second, the twentieth century was more about unequally held human capital; and third, that unequally held land at the start bred unequally held human capital at the finish. With this framework in place, the author launches in to Part One (Chapters 2–4). Chapter 2 offers a fine survey of the rise of colonial institutions favoring rents of the landed elite, and why those institutions persisted long after independence. The next chapter explores land inequality in postcolonial Latin America with better evidence and analysis than I have seen before. Chapter 4 shifts the focus to the twentieth century and schooling attainment. Mass education started later in Latin America than in the English-speaking New World, Europe, and Japan, and it was of lower quality. But education inequality was gradually reduced in the post-World War II decades, accelerating in the 1990s. This break with the past was likely an important prerequisite to what has followed in the first decade of the twenty-first century—a fall in inequality (to be discussed below). After that exciting first half, Part Two starts with a rather slow survey of the literature regarding long-run inequality (Chapter 5), but the author picks up the pace again in Chapter 6 which shows with impressive evidence and argument the connections between population growth, rural-urban migration, urban informal sector expansion, and inequality from 1870 to 2000. It also highlights the heterogeneous experience across Latin America and why that was so. Chapter 7 documents the twentieth-century rise in urban wage inequality predicted by the previous chapter. The book then concludes.
I like Unequal, and admire its sweep and empirical care. But to establish credibility, a critical reviewer should report some flaws. I am hard pressed to do so, but I'll try two. First: While the author motivates so much of Latin American growth and inequality experience by appealing to the recent political economy (neo-institutional) literature, he fails to bring it to bear at the micro level. Others are doing so as I write, and even while he was writing. Second: Unequal did not prepare us very well for the amazing inequality leveling which has taken place over the past decade or so.Footnote 3 For me, economic history must speak to the present, and Unequal missed that opportunity. Still, Frankema's book was published in 2009, before most of these new findings hit the academic scene.
Anyone interested in inequality, Latin America, or both, should read this excellent book.
