In terms of the collective violence embedded in Turkey's past in general and the Ottoman Empire in particular, the case of the Armenian Genocide, which reached its height during the events of 1915–17, often eclipses all other instances of collective violence and destruction that have unfortunately been experienced by other groups including, but not limited to Assyrian Christians. This is due not only to the mere scale of the Armenian Genocide, where 1.5 million Ottoman Armenian subjects were massacred, but also to its larger geographical spread throughout the empire. In terms of proportion, however, the Assyrian Genocide was just as destructive; the 300,000 Assyrians who lost their lives comprised a significant proportion of their total population. The Assyrians too lost their ability to sustain and reproduce their lives on their ancestral lands comprising Hakkari, Bohtan, Tur Abdin, Midyat, Mardin, Diyarbakir, Urfa (Ourahi), Nusaybin, Mosul, and the Nineveh Governorate.
Given the destructive intergenerational impact of the trauma of genocide, it has taken a long time for the affected communities to start expressing their emotions and sharing their experiences. The academic literature on the Armenian Genocide, first appearing in the 1970s, gradually acquired a position in the social sciences and the humanities, coming to prominence forty years later. In comparison, the academic literature on the Assyrian Genocide has been slower to develop. It is in this context that Joseph Yacoub's study makes such a significant and welcome contribution to the field of genocide studies. In combination with David Gaunt's Massacres, Resistance, Protectors: Muslim–Christian Relations in Eastern Anatolia during World War I (Piscataway, NJ: Gorgias Press, 2006), Yacoub's book establishes a very strong foundation to the academic study of the Assyrian Genocide in English.
Yacoub commences by dedicating his book to a long list of family members whose stories succinctly capture the collective violence experienced by the Assyrians in the Ottoman and Persian Empires, an experience that unfortunately continued during the rules of the succeeding nation states. The narrative commences with witnesses’ articulation of the Assyrian Genocide in chapter 1, moves to scenes and acts in chapter 2, and to the strategy and methodology of eradication in chapter 3. Chapter 4 then highlights how the tragedy continued after 1915 when the Assyrian Genocide, similar to the Armenian Genocide, was staunchly denied by the perpetrating states. Assyrians have continued to survive but still suffered immensely in Iraq, as we all helplessly witnessed most recently, under ISIS rule.
Yacoub's account of the Assyrian Genocide is impressive, almost encyclopedic in its mastery of contemporaneous sources, where the memoirs of prominent Assyrians figure heavily. It is unfortunate that the bibliography does not provide the full reference for the 400 notes within the book, choosing instead to feature only “works of importance on the genocide, the diaspora and the Assyrian question” (245). A full bibliography would have been helpful to scholars who wanted to further explore the genocide in history.
The book clearly establishes the manner in which the Assyrian Genocide was decided by the Young Turk government of the Ottoman Empire and executed by paramilitary groups and the local Muslim Turk and Kurd populace. What is missing, and what I am sure will comprise the next step, is contextualization of the Assyrian Genocide within the larger empirical framework. In addition, it will also be important to academically articulate the Assyrian Genocide's eerie similarities with, and subtle differences from, the Armenian Genocide. It was striking to this reviewer who knows the Armenian Genocide much better to observe the similarity in the nature of violence, not only in witnesses, scenes, and acts, but also in the strategy and methodology of eradication. I think it is time for area scholars to join forces to articulate once and for all the inherent trajectories of violence and the culpability of contemporary nation-states, not only in planning and executing collective violence, but also in denying them to this day.
