Interest in Cicero's Philippics has surged considerably in recent years following the publication of a series of modern commentaries on the speeches. The collection of studies by Stevenson and Wilson, arising from a conference in Auckland in 2003, crowns the efforts of modern editors of the Philippica to bring the once famous set of political oratory back to the consciousness of Ciceronian scholarship and begin a process of unbiased reinterpretation. The seventeen studies help unravel much of the fine rhetorical, historical and ideological complexity in the seemingly daunting series of deliberative speeches against the purported hostis patriae Antonius from 44–43 b.c. The contributors succeed in providing a clearer picture of the Philippics as intricate acts of persuasion adapted to a highly contingent political scene during the final crisis of the Republic as opposed to viewing them merely as a monotonic row of invectives obfuscating political realities (as some historians might argue pace Syme). As its title suggests, the collection aims primarily at offering a broad new perspective on the Philippics from various angles through historical, literary, rhetorical and ‘ideological’ analysis. However, an attentive reader would find a number of studies that go beyond the area circumscribed by the title words and deal with questions of publication, composition, connections with Stoic virtue ethics and forms of Roman ritual and their Nachleben in declamation. The task of editing a book that gives justice to a number of neglected aspects of the Phillipics was not easy. One merit of the book is that it strikes a healthy balance between studies focusing on key themes in the whole collection and the detailed analysis of argument in individual speeches. The editors' brief introduction to the book sensibly combines a brief survey of historical and scholarly issues with the speeches, justification for the project, and a preview of all studies.
The contributors include some heavyweights in Philippics-studies, although the geographic distribution of authors is slightly uneven with twelve from Australia and New Zealand and only five from Europe. The topics are varied and aim to cover a large field, so only some significant points can be highlighted here. The first two studies do not in a strict sense belong to the remit of the book, although they discuss the important issues of publication and composition. Kelly looks at the practice of distributing forensic and deliberative speeches before and during 44–43 b.c. and argues that a rapid publication of speeches was a powerful weapon for Cicero in the media war after Caesar's assassination. Manuwald provides strong support for Stroh's thesis (which she supported in her commentary to Phil. 3–9) that Cicero's publication of the Philippics included only 3–14 to mimic the original Demosthenic cycle. However, throughout her argument one misses a better explanation for the inclusion of Phil. 1–2 in the present composition, assuming that Stroh's theory is true.
A number of studies deal with the techniques, effectiveness, and political or social background of Ciceronian invective. Evans, for example, surveys the real and rhetorical connections Cicero sets up between Catiline, Clodius and Antonius as a means to reaffirm (with an eye to posterity?) his persona as a consistent defender of the Republic. Elucidating another key aspect of the often deplored Ciceronian harangues, Stevenson contrasts the conflicting images of the tyrant and the parens patriae in the historical and literary background of the Philippics. He shows that Cicero's use of antagonistic phrases is not simply the result of empty rhetorical embellishment but arises from the necessity to win the media battle by warring political factions after Caesar's assassination. A less well-known side of Cicero's oratorical tour de force in the Philippics, the use of praise for Brutus and Cassius as a means to justify his political position, also receives a welcome treatment from Dawes.
The largest consistent set of studies deals with the rhetorical use and abuse of key political values, such as clementia, beneficium, libertas or felicitas, used by Cicero in his desperate fight to salvage the crumbling ideological façade in an opposition to the pretended public enemy Antonius. The results show that Cicero consciously used traditional political and ethical values as fundamental premises in his arguments. His apparent aim was to reinforce, through the whole series of speeches, the concept of the commonwealth of the good men sharing specific values that would allow him to claim legitimacy for his unconstitutional political initiatives and delegitimize his enemy.
Two engaging studies deal with a close analysis of Ciceronian persuasive strategies in individual speeches. Steel maps out Cicero's sophisticated manoeuvring in a contio before the Roman people in Phil. 6 to regain firm ground for future argumentation after his proposition to declare war against Antony was crushed. In one of the most intriguing analyses of the whole book (despite its negative conclusion), Hall describes unique evidence of an ad-hoc (and apparently not very successful) oratorical argument in Phil. 12 that shows, in a series of seemingly inconsistent passages, how he had to face and struggle with the immediate and often debilitating reactions of the senators sitting as his audience. It is a nice and rare example of Cicero trying ‘to have his cake and eat it’ to avoid a humiliating participation in the planned embassy to Antonius at Mutina.
The average standard of individual studies is good with some unevenness, so a tighter selection could have served the intended audience better. The book nevertheless achieves its aim of offering a more subtle and objective interpretation of the Philippics as historical source, literary composition and rhetorical performace through a variety of approaches. Overall, it is a stimulating read that will hopefully attract a modern audience from a wide range of interest, even beyond the realm of Classics.
