Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T06:18:11.974Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Dynamics of the velocity fluctuations in sedimenting suspensions of rigid fibres

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 January 2026

Alessandro Chiarini*
Affiliation:
Complex Fluids and Flows Unit, Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University , 1919-1, Tancha, Onna-son, Okinawa 904-0495, JapanDipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano , via La Masa 34, 20156 Milano, Italy
Emanuele Gallorini*
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano , via La Masa 34, 20156 Milano, ItalyUMR 9014 - LMFL - Laboratoire de Mécanique des Fluides de Lille - Kampé de Fériet, Univ. Lille, CNRS, ONERA, Arts et Métiers Institute of Technology, Centrale Lille, F-59000 Lille, France
Marco Edoardo Rosti*
Affiliation:
Complex Fluids and Flows Unit, Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University , 1919-1, Tancha, Onna-son, Okinawa 904-0495, Japan
*
Corresponding authors: Emanuele Gallorini, emanuele.gallorini@polimi.it; Alessandro Chiarini, alessandro.chiarini@polimi.it; Marco Edoardo Rosti, marco.rosti@oist.jp
Corresponding authors: Emanuele Gallorini, emanuele.gallorini@polimi.it; Alessandro Chiarini, alessandro.chiarini@polimi.it; Marco Edoardo Rosti, marco.rosti@oist.jp
Corresponding authors: Emanuele Gallorini, emanuele.gallorini@polimi.it; Alessandro Chiarini, alessandro.chiarini@polimi.it; Marco Edoardo Rosti, marco.rosti@oist.jp

Abstract

We use direct numerical simulations to investigate fluid–solid interactions in suspensions of rigid fibres settling under gravity in a quiescent fluid. The solid-to-fluid density ratio is $\mathcal{O}(100)$, while the Galileo number ($ \textit{Ga}$) and fibre concentration ($n\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$) are varied over the ranges $ \textit{Ga} \in [180, 900]$ and $n\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 \in [0.36, 23.15]$; $\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}$ denotes the fibre length and $n$ the number density. At high $ \textit{Ga}$ and/or low $n\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$, fibres cluster into gravity-aligned streamers with elevated concentrations and enhanced settling velocities, disrupting the flow homogeneity. As $ \textit{Ga}$ increases and/or $n\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$ decreases, the fluid-phase kinetic energy rises and the energy spectrum broadens, reflecting enhanced small-scale activity. The flow anisotropy is assessed by decomposing the energy spectrum into components aligned with and transverse to gravity. Vertical fluctuations are primarily driven by fluid–solid interactions, while transverse ones are maintained by pressure–strain effects that promote isotropy. With increasing $ \textit{Ga}$, nonlinear interactions become more prominent, producing a net forward energy cascade toward smaller scales, punctuated by localised backscatter events. Analysis of the local velocity gradient tensor reveals distinct flow topologies: at low $ \textit{Ga}$, the flow is dominated by axisymmetric compression and two-dimensional straining; at high $ \textit{Ga}$, regions of high fibre concentration are governed by two-dimensional strain, while voids are associated with axisymmetric extension. The fluid motion is predominantly extensional rather than rotational.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Summary of the numerical simulations conducted in this study. Here, $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$ denotes the dimensionless fibre concentration, $\varPhi _V = V_{\kern-1pt f} / V_t$ is the volume fraction and $\varPhi _M = (\rho_{\kern-1pt f} V_{\kern-1pt f})/((\rho_{\kern-1pt f} - \rho ) V_{\kern-1pt f} + \rho V_t)$ is the mass fraction. The aspect ratio is defined as , where $\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}$ and $d_{\kern-1pt f}$ are the fibre length and diameter, respectively. The Galileo number is $ \textit{Ga} = u_g \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f} / \nu$, with the buoyancy velocity $u_g = \sqrt {|\rho_{\kern-1pt f} / \rho - 1| \, \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f} g}$. The quantity $\langle {w}_f \rangle _f$ denotes the mean settling velocity of the fibre midpoint in the vertical ($z$) direction; here, $\langle \boldsymbol{\cdot }\rangle _f$ indicates an ensemble and time average over all fibres. The Kolmogorov length scale is defined as $\eta = (\nu ^3 / \varepsilon )^{1/4}$, where the dissipation rate is given by $\varepsilon = 2 \nu s_{\textit{ij}} s_{\textit{ij}}$ with the strain-rate tensor $s_{\textit{ij}} = (\partial u_i/\partial x_{\kern-1pt j} + \partial u_{\kern-1pt j}/\partial x_i)/2$. Also, $E$ denotes the kinetic energy of the fluid phase, and $\langle \boldsymbol{\cdot }\rangle$ represents an average over realisations, time, and the three homogeneous spatial directions.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Settling velocity of the fibres. The filled symbols refer to the suspension of fibres with $N=10^4$. The empty symbols refer to the terminal velocity of single fibres settling in the same conditions. These velocities are obtained by running additional simulations with the same grid resolution and same domain size, but with $N=1$. Here and in the following, circles refer to cases where streamers are not formed or are rather weak, while squares refer to the cases where the streamers are evident and strong.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Effect of the Galileo number on streamer formation for $n\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3=2.89$. Fibres are coloured according to the vertical velocity of their midpoints: blue indicates downward motion (negative velocity), red indicates upward motion (positive velocity), and black corresponds to zero vertical velocity. From (a–f): $ \textit{Ga} = 180$ ($w_{f,\textit{min}} = -0.6335\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.3156\,u_g$), $ \textit{Ga} = 450$ ($w_{f,\textit{min}} = -1.4282\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.4251\,u_g$) and $ \textit{Ga} = 900$ ($w_{f,\textit{min}} = -1.2117\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.5019\,u_g$).

Figure 3

Figure 3.Effect of concentration $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$ on streamer formation for (a–c) $ \textit{Ga} = 180$ and (d–f) $ \textit{Ga} = 450$. Fibres are coloured according to the vertical velocity of their midpoint Lagrangian point: blue indicates negative velocity, red indicates positive velocity and black corresponds to near-zero velocity. From left to right, the concentration is $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 0.36$, $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3=2.89$ and $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 23.15$. For $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3=0.36$, $w_{f,\textit{min}} = -1.3549\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.2906\,u_g$ at $ \textit{Ga}=180$ and $w_{f,\textit{min}} = -2.0396\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.1505\,u_g$ at $ \textit{Ga}=450$. For $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$, $w_{f,\textit{min}} = -0.6335\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.3156\,u_g$ at $ \textit{Ga}=180$ and $w_{f,\textit{min}} = -1.4282\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.4251\,u_g$ at $ \textit{Ga}=450$. For $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 23.15$, $w_{f,\textit{min}} = -0.4025\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.1302\,u_g$ at $ \textit{Ga}=180$ and $w_{f,\textit{min}} = -0.4527\,u_g$, $w_{f,\textit{max}} = 0.1767\,u_g$ at $ \textit{Ga}=450$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Effect of $ \textit{Ga}$ and $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$ on the (left) RDF and (right) probability density function of the local concentration. Panel (a) shows variation of $ \textit{Ga}$ at fixed $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$. Panel (b) shows variation of $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$ at fixed $ \textit{Ga} = 180$ (top) and $ \textit{Ga} = 450$ (bottom). Symbols follow the convention in figure 1, where squares indicate cases with streamer formation, and circles indicate cases without.

Figure 5

Figure 5.JPDF of fibre concentration $C$ and fibre velocity $w_f$ for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$, illustrating the effect of Galileo number. Panels (a–d) correspond to $ \textit{Ga} = 180$, 450, 675 and 900, respectively. Maximum JPDF values are $\text{JPDF}_{{max}} = 30.59$, 16.94, 16.48 and 12.91 for $ \textit{Ga} = 180$, 450, 675 and 900.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Distribution of the alignment of the fibres with the $z$ direction. When fibres align with the $z$ direction $\cos (\phi )=1$. When fibres are perpendicular to the $z$- direction $\cos (\phi )=0$. $(a)$ Influence of the Galileo number on the distribution of $\cos (\phi )$ at $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$. $(b)$ Influence of the concentration $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$ on $\cos (\phi )$ at $ \textit{Ga}=180$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Dependence of mean flow quantities on $ \textit{Ga}$ and $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$. Blue symbols are for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}= 0.36$, red symbols for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and green ones for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 23.15$. Circles/squares indicate the absence/presence of the streamers. (a): Energy of the fluctuations $E$. (b): Viscous dissipation $\varepsilon$. (c): Kolmogorov length scale $\eta$. In the central panel, the dashed line indicates a $ \textit{Ga}^{1/2}$ power-law scaling. In the right panel, the dashed line indicates a $ \textit{Ga}^{-1}$ power-law scaling. The vertical bars refer to the root mean square values of the time evolution of the three quantities. (d,e): Dependence of (left) $\langle \varepsilon \rangle$ and (right) $\langle \eta \rangle$ on $ \textit{Ga}$ and $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$. Symbols follow the convention in figure 1, where squares indicate cases with streamer formation, and circles indicate cases without.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Visualisation of the fluctuating velocity field for (left to right) $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 0.36$, 2.89 and 23.15, at (top) $ \textit{Ga} = 180$ and (bottom) $ \textit{Ga} = 450$. Shown are isosurfaces of kinetic energy $E = 0.05 u_g^2$, coloured by the vertical velocity component $w$: red indicates positive $w$, and blue indicates negative $w$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.(a,b): Energy spectra (a) $\mathcal{E}_{3c}^\parallel$ and (b) $\mathcal{E}_{3c}^\perp$ as functions of $ \textit{Ga}$ for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$. (c,d): Values of (c) $\mathcal{E}_{3c}^\parallel$ and (d) $\mathcal{E}_{3c}^\perp$ as functions of $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3$ for $ \textit{Ga} = 450$. The black dashed and dash-dotted lines indicate $\kappa ^{-5/3}$ and $\kappa ^{-4}$ scaling, respectively. All spectra are normalised such that $\int _0^\infty \mathcal{E}_{3c}^{\parallel ,\perp } / \langle E \rangle \mathrm{d} \kappa _{\parallel ,\perp } = 1$. The $\kappa _{\parallel ,\perp } = 0$ mode is excluded due to the logarithmic horizontal axis; $\mathcal{E}_{3c}^\perp (0)$ is larger in cases exhibiting streamer formation, owing to their strong vertical coherence.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Anisotropy of the velocity fluctuations in the $\kappa _\parallel$ ($a$, $c$) and $\kappa _\perp$ ($b$,$d$) wavenumber space for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and $ \textit{Ga}=180$ ($a$,$b$) and $ \textit{Ga}=900$ ($c$,$d$). The coloured solid lines are for $\mathcal{E}_{1C}$, the coloured dashed lines for $\mathcal{E}_{2C}$ and the coloured dotted lines for $\mathcal{E}_{3C}$. The black dashed line indicates $\kappa ^{-5/3}$, while the black dashed–dotted one indicates $\kappa ^{-4}$.

Figure 11

Table 2.Ratios of $\mathcal{E}_{1c}^\parallel / \mathcal{E}_{2c}^\parallel$ and $\mathcal{E}_{1c}^\perp / \mathcal{E}_{2c}^\perp$ at selected wavenumbers $\kappa _\parallel$ and $\kappa _\perp$ for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$, comparing $ \textit{Ga} = 180$ (left) and $ Ga = 900$ (right).

Figure 12

Figure 11.Panels (a) and (b) show two-dimensional spectral maps of (a) $\mathcal{E}_{1c}(\kappa _\parallel ,\kappa _\perp )$ and (b) $\mathcal{E}_{2c}(\kappa _\parallel ,\kappa _\perp )$ for $ \textit{Ga} = 180$. The white-to-black colour map represents $\log(\mathcal{E}_{\cdot c}/E)$. Panels (c) and (d) show relative difference maps of $\mathcal{E}_{1c}/\mathcal{E}_{2c} - 1$ in $(\kappa _\parallel ,\kappa _\perp )$ space, for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$, at (c) $ \textit{Ga} = 180$ and (d) $ \textit{Ga} = 900$. The dashed black lines indicate the fibre wavenumber $\kappa _\ell = 2\pi /\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Scale-by-scale energy transfer balance for $n\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and $ \textit{Ga}=180$. (a): Budget for $\mathcal{E}_{1c}^\parallel$. (b): Budget for $\mathcal{E}_{1c}^\perp$. (c): Budget for $\mathcal{E}_{2c}^\parallel$. (d): Budget for $\mathcal{E}_{2c}^\parallel$. All quantities are scaled with the averaged dissipation in the box $\langle \varepsilon \rangle$.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Scale-by-scale energy transfer balance for $n\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and $ \textit{Ga}=900$. (a): Budget for $\mathcal{E}_{1c}^\parallel$. (b): Budget for $\mathcal{E}_{1c}^\perp$. (c): Budget for $\mathcal{E}_{2c}^\parallel$. (d): Budget for $\mathcal{E}_{2c}^\parallel$. All quantities are scaled with the averaged dissipation in the box $\langle \varepsilon \rangle$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Scale-by-scale energy transfer balance for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ in the two-dimensional $(\kappa _\parallel ,\kappa _\perp )$ space at $ \textit{Ga} = 180$: $(a)$$\mathcal{F}_{1c}$, $(b)$$\mathcal{F}_{2c}$, $(c)$$\mathcal{P}_{1c}$, $(d)$$\mathcal{P}_{2c}$, $(e)$$\mathcal{D}_{1c}$, $(f)$$\mathcal{D}_{2c}$. All quantities are scaled with the averaged dissipation in the box $\langle \varepsilon \rangle$. The black thick line denotes the zero value and separates sink and source regions.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Probability distribution function of the $\varPhi$ fluxes for the $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ cases. Panels ($a{,}c{,}e$) show the distribution of $\varPhi /(\langle \varepsilon \rangle r)$. Panels ($b{,}d{,}f)$ show the distribution of $\varPhi /\varPhi _{\textit{rms}}$. From top to bottom: $r/\ell_{\kern-1.5pt f} \approx 0.25$ ($a{,}b$), $0.76$ ($c{,}d$) and $1.5$ ($e{,}f$).

Figure 17

Figure 16.Isosurfaces of the dissipation, $0.03 \langle \varepsilon \rangle$ for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ at ($a$) $ \textit{Ga}=180$ and ($b$) $ \textit{Ga}=900$. The colour is for the vertical velocity of the fluid phase, with blue colour denoting negative values and red colour positive values. For small $ \textit{Ga}$ the dissipation is confined in the near-fibre region, while for large $ \textit{Ga}$ large values of the dissipation are observed away from the fibres’ surface.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Distribution of $s^*$ for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and different $ \textit{Ga}$.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Joint probability distribution function of $s^*-w$ for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and ($a$) $ \textit{Ga}=225$, ($b$) $ \textit{Ga}=450$, ($c$) $ \textit{Ga}=675$ and ($d$) $ \textit{Ga}=900$. A linear spacing of $4.15 \times 10^{-3}$ is used between isolines.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Distribution of the cosine of the angle between the vorticity and the eigenvectors of the strain-rate tensor for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and different $ \textit{Ga}$.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Influence of $ \textit{Ga}$ on $\mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}$ and $\mathcal{P}_{s^2}$ for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$. $(a)$ Distribution of $\mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}$ (solid line) and $-(4/3) \mathcal{P}_{s^2}$ (circles). $(b)$ Distribution of $\mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}/\! \langle {\mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}} \rangle \!$. In the inset the dependence of $\! \langle {\mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}} \rangle \!$ on $ \textit{Ga}$ is shown. (c,d) Joint probability distribution between $-(4/3) \mathcal{P}_{s^2}$ and $\mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}$, for $(c)$$ \textit{Ga}=180$ and $(d)$$ \textit{Ga}=900$. The $10$ isolines correspond to probability values between $1 \times 10^{-6}$ and $1 \times 10^{-2}$, distributed on a logarithmic scale.

Figure 22

Table 3.Contributions of $\! \langle { \mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}^\alpha } \rangle \! \equiv \! \langle { \omega ^2 \alpha \cos ^2(\boldsymbol{\omega } \hat {\boldsymbol{e}}_\alpha )} \rangle \!$, $\! \langle { \mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}^\beta } \rangle \! \equiv \! \langle {\omega ^2 \beta \cos ^2(\boldsymbol{\omega } \hat {\boldsymbol{e}}_\beta )} \rangle \!$ and $\! \langle { \mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}^\gamma } \rangle \! \equiv \! \langle {\omega ^2 \gamma \cos ^2(\boldsymbol{\omega } \hat {\boldsymbol{e}}_\gamma )} \rangle \!$ to the average vortex stretching $\! \langle { \mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2} } \rangle \!$ for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and different $ \textit{Ga}$.

Figure 23

Figure 21.The $\mathcal{P}_{\omega ^2}-w$ JPDF for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$ and ($a$) $ \textit{Ga}=180$, ($b$) $ \textit{Ga}=900$. The $12$ isolines correspond to probability values between $3 \times 10^{-4}$ and $0.1$, distributed on a logarithmic scale.

Figure 24

Figure 22.JPDF maps in the $Q{-}R$ (panels a,c) and $Q_S-Q_W$ (panels b,d) planes for $n \ell_{\kern-1.5pt f}^3 = 2.89$, at $ \textit{Ga} = 450$ (a,b) and $ \textit{Ga} = 900$ (c,d). The 10 isolines in the left (right) panels correspond to probability values between $3.16 \times 10^{-5}$ and $10^2$ ($10^{-4}$ and $1$), distributed logarithmically. The Kolmogorov time scale is defined as $\tau _\eta = \sqrt { \nu / \langle \epsilon \rangle }$. The case with $ \textit{Ga} = 450$ is representative of the behaviour observed at lower $ \textit{Ga}$.