My thanks to Rebecca L. Volpe and Erica Rangel Salter for their response to my commentary.Footnote 1 There is no greater tribute than to be read closely and intelligently critiqued. I never liked the adversarial dynamic that can occur in responses to letters to the editor, especially when there is a sense that the debate is most likely being conducted with interlocutors with whom there is more agreement than disagreement.
So with this wariness duly registered, let me respond. My intent in writing “The Humanities and the Future of Bioethics Education”Footnote 2 was not to pass judgment, as Volpe and Salter allege in their provocative title, but rather to be sure that we do not undermine the humanities by mistaking preprofessional or technical training in bioethics for more original, open-ended, and speculative scholarship.
When I wrote, I felt that the humanities were under siege by scholarly fashions that prized reductionism over more expansive sorts of inquiry and that prefer discussions of numbers over that of values. This remains the case, and that is why I sought to defend the humanities.
My concern was not one of “quick judgment,” but rather an impression developed and sustained since my earliest days as a visiting scholar at the Hastings Center in the late 1980s while still a medical resident. At the center, I saw a methodology of shared discourse and engagement that was—and continues to be—immensely successful in elucidating broader social trends. Over the years such scholarship has served as a leading edge of inquiry that later resulted in empirical studies as well as ongoing studies of a more fundamental nature. This is the innovative role that humanities scholars and the humanities, writ large, can and should play in bioethics.
But it is difficult work to do. It requires a critical mass of talented and motivated scholars who can engage in broad discussions across disciplinary lines. This often requires preparation in multiple fields.
It can also take a considerable amount of time. Aristotle reminds us in the Nichomachean Ethics that leisure is necessary for philosophy,Footnote 3 and this remains true for all who pursue original scholarship. Whether the discipline is basic science or a humanities discipline, the quest for discovery can be slow. These challenges can easily become disincentives to the pursuit of original work. It can siphon students into preprofessional studies with more predictable time courses.
In response, I hoped to rally our interdisciplinary field to do what it could to bolster original scholarship in the humanities while reminding the bioethics community of our collective debt to these constituent disciplines. This indebtedness dates from our founding as a field and continues to our present-day reliance on talented graduates of doctoral programs in the humanities.
To be clear, I voiced concern not about all graduate programs but rather about preprofessional ones, with a more derivative focus. I did not critique doctoral programs in the medical humanities anywhere in the article. I specifically voiced concerns about “bioethics Master’s and Ph.D. programs.” Contrary to my critics’ read of my article, I am supportive of the medical humanities and believe it critical to distinguish such programs with more preprofessional offerings in bioethics. To conflate these graduate programs is to make a category error.
Nonetheless, for all the reasons I have enumerated in my article, I remain convinced that more traditional training in a discrete humanities discipline is a better place to begin one’s career. This is the advice about graduate school I would give—and have given—to students who want to become independent scholars. I admit it is one man’s view. Nonetheless, I am comforted that our disagreement is about means, not ends.
