In the case of Re-creating Japanese Men, it is possible to judge a book by its cover: this work presents some of the multiple, fluctuating tropes of masculinity adopted by Japanese males from the Edo period through modern times. Arranged into three sections, the book's thirteen articles are not bound together by any one theory or methodology. Rather, it is “the malleability of men, manhood, and masculinity” (p. 16), particularly during periods of sociocultural crisis, that unites these articles.
The cases presented in Section I, “Legacies of the Samurai,” address the relationship between masculinity and militarism. Anne Walthall's “Do Guns have Gender?” places this in context by examining the role of Edo-period guns as signifiers of both (male) gender and (primarily elite) status. Luke Robert's “Name and Honor,” an examination of a seventeenth-century merchant's memoir, might at first seem out of place, but the merchant's self-image was tied directly to his incorporation of a “concern for honor, violence, and desire for renown in martial prowess with little to distinguish it from that of the samurai” (p. 55). Because of this, political necessities required that the seventeenth century become “an era of the taming of masculinity” (p. 65) of all men, regardless of their status group affiliation.
“Empowering the Would-be Warrior” by Michele Mason addresses the way that the so-called indigenous Japanese philosophy known as Bushidō has been co-opted, manipulated, and reinterpreted by alienated nationalists (here, the authors Nitobe Inazō, Mishima Yukio, and Hyōdō Nisohachi) to validate not only the inherent superiority of the Japanese people, but these authors’ personal masculinity as well. Similarly, Sabine Frühstück's “After Heroism” examines how members of Japan's Self-Defense Forces have reconceptualized just what is “heroic action” (e.g., humanitarian missions), something that enables them to continue to support and/or promote militarized masculinity.
The articles of Section II, “Marginal Men,” address the self-perceived manliness of men on society's periphery, i.e., those males who fail to meet, or outright reject, the state's hegemonic definition of manhood or “mature masculinity.” “Perpetual Dependency” by Sakurai Yuki examines the career stages experienced by Edo-period shop clerks, whose masculinity was predicated upon “accumulation of masculine capital represented by clothing and accessories” (p. 133). Christopher Gerteis's “Losing the Union Man” ties the ebbing appeal of union membership for young blue-collar males to the unions’ failures to protect them from unequal pay practices and mass layoffs. Their increasing inability to provide their families with the markers of the middle class lifestyle has led to a sense of emasculation, or what has been has been called “a national crisis of masculinity” (p. 149). As Susan Napier contends in “Where Have All the Salary Men Gone?” this crisis has been exacerbated by the abandonment and/or rejection of the “Salary Man” as the embodiment of true manhood, without the adoption of a new hegemonic masculine trope. She does this through deconstruction of the popular television (book and film) series, Densha Otoko (“Train Man”), which chronicles the struggles of an otaku (a techno geek-nerd) to demonstrate his masculinity in contemporary Japan's alienating society. Through his struggles to “win the girl,” he displays that the traditional, so-called samurai traits of perseverance, masochism, and self-sacrifice remain linked to the concept of manhood. Some of these same characteristics appear in the self-images of homeless males chronicled in Tom Gill's “Failed Manhood on the Streets of Urban Japan.” For these men, however, their self-reliance (more or less) and independence (again, more or less) are the most crucial signifiers of their masculinity.
The chapters comprising Section III, “Bodies and Boundaries,” consider the role of the physical in the configuration of the mental. In “Collective Maturation,” Nagano Hiroko links membership in Edo-period village youth groups to the inculcation of socially sanctioned masculinity, one aspect of which appears to have been the sexual domination of the village's single females (including widows). Wolfram Manzenreiter's “Climbing Walls” starts with the premise that the sport of free climbing provides gender neutrality for its participants and ends with the conclusion that it in fact does not. The “normative” gender and age hierarchies of Japanese society remain entrenched, for as the author notes, “homosociality, ideas of domination, and the ethical appreciation of pain, work toward the reproduction of a hegemonic sporting masculinity” (p. 237). Even given this, however, he concludes that “[a]lternative sports do not produce only hegemonic but … alternative forms of masculinity” arising from the “social and emotional amenities” free-climbers derive from this sport (p. 237).
Teresa Algoso analyzes the fate of hermaphrodites under the wartime state in “Not Suitable as a Man?” State concern over the martial capabilities of its soldiers led to a conscription examination policy that, backed by medical theories about the intelligence and mindset of those deemed in any way “abnormal,” privileged physiology over gender self-identification. There was no room in Japanese society for three sexes nor for three genders, at least in the minds of officials; such a scenario could only lead to destabilization of the body politic, for males had legal rights not accorded to women. Ian Condry's postmodernist “Love Revolution” deals with a similar—though more abstract—conundrum by deconstructing the 2008 case of a male otaku who petitioned online for “legal recognition [of] the right to marry an anime character” (p. 262). He draws upon the theory that equates masculinity with consumption and splices onto it the condition of moe (roughly, a “warm and fuzzy” internalized emotion for that which can never reciprocate the feeling) to explain otaku as individuals who engage in “affective consumption as a legitimate expression of masculinity” (p. 281). For Condry, wider acceptance of diverse masculinities may lead to a kinder, gentler political sphere for all. Jennifer Robertson appears less optimistic. In her work “Gendering Robots,” she interpolates the ramifications of (primarily male) scientists’ creation of robotic “life” in keeping with society's theoretical norms. Essentially, these specialists are replicating “conventionally embodied male and female gender roles and the patriarchal family” (p. 304).
Theories about what constitutes or signifies masculinity are as varied as the agendas of their creators. Therefore, the editors Frühstück and Walthall have employed an eclectic, interdisciplinary approach to the problem, one that makes Re-creating Japanese Men a stimulating read, accessible to nonspecialists as well as Japanologists.
