A tourist visiting Dodge City, Kansas, in the early twentieth century hoping to see that town's famous Boot Hill Cemetery would have left disappointed: an abandoned school sat on the site of the famous graveyard. Yet, a half century later, well over a quarter million people were visiting the revitalized and restored Boot Hill Cemetery annually. In Tombstone, Deadwood, and Dodge City: Re-Creating the Frontier West, Kevin Britz and Roger L. Nichols address the question of how Western tourism became big business over the course of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
This new book is based on a University of Arizona dissertation written by Britz, who passed away in 2011, and revised into a manuscript and monograph by his former advisor, Nichols. The result is a breezily written, yet still scholarly and well-argued, addition to the historiography of American Western culture and tourism. By looking at the late nineteenth- and twentieth-centuries’ histories of Tombstone, Arizona, Deadwood, South Dakota, and Dodge City, Britz and Nichols emphasize the importance of each town's faltering economies to their re-creation as sites of Western authenticity. “In all three [towns] the local efforts grew out of pressing, even desperate economic circumstances,” they argue, with “both Deadwood and Tombstone fac[ing] ruin” at the beginning of the twentieth century (8). Local boosters and politicians latched onto a vision of the violent and romantic West, which was growing increasingly prevalent in popular culture as a means of reviving sagging economies formerly based on extractive capitalism.
Building on work by scholars of Western tourism such as Hal Rothman, William Philpott, and (though uncited) Elaine Nelson, Britz and Nichols center the concept of authenticity as crucial to each town's development as a Western tourism site. Authenticity, slippery idea as it is, can be found in this book at the intersection of local history (such as the murder of Wild Bill Hickock in Deadwood), popular cultural representations (such as the many films based on the shootout at Tombstone's OK Corral), and popular memory and memorialization (like the changing meanings and importance of Dodge City's cemetery). Britz and Nichols describe a dialectic: tourists visited Western towns wanting to see authentic Western attractions, and those towns, eager for tourism dollars, changed to fit tourist ideas about just what an authentic Western town was. “Americans traveled to these three towns … looking for remnants of the Old West,” the authors write, “[but] their expectations … depended largely on images … embellished and dramatized by outsiders. Town leaders responded quickly … to match potential visitors’ expectations” (9). In American Western tourism, authenticity lay in the eye, and in the wallet, of the beholder.
Among the most novel and interesting sections of the book is Chapter Seven, “Movies, Television, and Tourism,” which uses media analysis and popular cultural history to see how broader trends in American cultural life played out locally in the three towns under study. While at the start of the book's chronology, politicians and citizens in each of the three towns were somewhat resistant to embracing a violent, lurid, late nineteenth-century version of the past as a civic identity, the importance of television and film media and the dollars they promised soon changed minds. “By repeating stories about colorful heroes … set against the backdrops of saloons, gambling dens, street violence, and prostitution, popular literature, movies, and later television made these images central in the process of defining the Old West,” Britz and Nichols argue (9). Once these elements of the West became engrained in the popular imagination as central to what a Western place should be, each of the three towns slowly “accepted these images as integral parts of their identity,” though memorial sites, reenactments, public celebrations, and on-site film shoots (9). The promise of economic stimulus and the irresistible force of popular visual media overcame boosters’ reservations at associating their towns with sin and bloodshed.
Tombstone, Deadwood, and Dodge City is a pleasure to read, well-written and full of excellent quotes, anecdotes, and evidentiary examples. There are nonetheless several omissions that will stand out to scholars of the American West. There is no discussion of the three town's varied environmental settings and the importance of landscape to their claims at Western authenticity. Arizona's deserts, the pine-covered mountains of the Black Hills, and the expansive prairies of west-central Kansas all likely assisted in giving these towns legitimacy as quintessentially Western places, but there is no discussion of the nonhuman world in the book.
Perhaps more distressing is the lack of discussion surrounding the importance of race and Native people to the images these towns presented to tourists. There are openings where one might expect such an analysis to take place: the death of a celebrated Tombstone restauranteur Quong Kee for instance, where the authors briefly note that “at one time the [Tombstone] cemetery included both Chinese and Jewish sections” but fail to analyze further (105). Native people are similarly incidental to the story Britz and Nichols tell. “Some two hundred Sioux Indians from Pine Ridge” were central to the 1925 edition of Deadwood's “Days of ‘76” pageant, they claim, but why Native people chose to participate, or why pageant organizers thought their inclusion would aid in their quest for authenticity, remains unexamined (142).
These flaws are unfortunate but not ruinous. The story the authors tell will be of interest to cultural historians, historians of travel and tourism, and scholars of the West broadly, as well as to laypeople interested in the history of these three iconic Western towns. Tombstone, Deadwood, and Dodge City is a worthy contribution to the historiography of the cultural American West.
Together, Britz and Nichols have written a fine piece of scholarship.
