Placing women’s religious performances in a transcultural context, Sarah Weiss conducts a meta-ethnographic study of women’s ritual practices of world religions, including Christianity, Hinduism, and Islam. Beginning with a thorough review of the contesting discourses surrounding the literature of spiritual practices from around the world, Weiss’ study, on both theoretical and methodological levels, reflects on the various performance deployments of “world religion,” a theological term defined accordingly to its varying usage in the modern science of religion since the 1870s in Europe. Noting a totalising tendency towards the classification of varied spiritualised cultural and material practices, Weiss questions the problematic distinctions between the binary conceptual categorisation of “ethnoreligions” and “universalizing religions” (9) in adjacent disciplines. Veering towards the inclusive capacity of world religion that holds key terms and concepts in common, Ritual Soundings emphasises the general process of ritual practices for sharing traits in divergent performance realities across the world.
Chapter 1 traces the history of the comparative paradigm for the study of ethnomusicology, from its disciplinary ancestor, “comparative musicology,” to the shift to “ethnomusicology” in the mid-1950s, to the comparative techniques in present-day American ethnomusicology. Weiss considers comparative perspectives valuable opportunities for probing the problematic dilemma between universals and local interpretations. Methodologically, Weiss proposes an intersectional approach as a fundamental frame, upon which gender differences offer a cross-cultural, nuanced category for comparable analysis of varied themes and expressive methods, as well as world-wide access to ethnographic materials. She examines women’s performance practices through a meta-ethnographic lens to highlight the expressive dynamic in localising knowledge of world religions and the performative adeptness in creating a liminal state for women’s agency.
Considered local expressions of established world religions, women’s ritual practices and experiences thereby present such intersectionality, permeating within which diverse but constructive responses to the norms of universalism across the transcultural communities who share a particular belief system. Cutting across nationality, class, race, ethnicity, and gender, intersectionality binds individual practices to given specific conditions on shared ground. In Weiss’s study, women constitute such accessible intersectional position for observing the abundant productions and practices of local knowledge among diverse cultural locations. The logic of intersectionality facilitates a comprehensive understanding of the ways that localised ritual performances could possibly become commensurate with a particular centralising or institutionalising source of authority.
Linking ethnomusicology, gendered studies of religion, and religious music studies, Ritual Soundings is organised around two lines of inquiry to recast a panoramic view of women’s localised ritual performances of world religions. First, focusing on similar phenomena occurring in different cultures, religions, and historical periods, Weiss performs a cross-religious comparison of women’s performances that articulate their emotional anxieties during dramatic upheaval. Examples in Chapter 2 rely on ethnographic data documenting wedding lamentation in case studies from the United Kingdom, Greece, Russia, Finland, India, and Italy, among various media that include documentary film, literature, and song. Chapter 3 bridges women’s expressive genres by tracing the power of expressed emotions way back to the mythological Demeter and Persephone; the women performers at the ancient Greek Thesmophoria festivals held across Greece, Italy, and Asia Minor; and to the Potomian funeral lamenters. Continuing the examination of transgressive verbal and physical acts in narratives, Chapter 4 addresses women’s uses of mockery and ridicule in prenuptial performances, including Hindu Trinidadians and Biharis, Canadian-Moroccan and Bulgarian-Israeli Sephardic Jews, Romanian Orthodox Christians, and professional Muslim Tuareg smith praise singers.
The second line of inquiry explores how women use religiously sanctioned public performance as a cover for actions normally considered inappropriate. Instances include the poetic wedding performances of Muslim Berber girls in Riffian communities in rural Morocco (Chapter 5) and two manifestations of the tarantella tradition in Catholic southern Italy (Chapter 6). Protected by the liminality constructed through performance, those women mediate the ambiguity of their social positions not only to negotiate but also to garner their agency to effect prospective alternatives that might challenge and in the meanwhile confirm given communal order. Through examination of those intersecting aspects of women’s activities in shaping local variants of world religions, Ritual Soundings intently addresses such mutually constitutive relationship of local practices and overarching universals.
Weiss’s detailed reexamination of women’s ritual performances from selected ethnographic literatures offers critical comparisons and interpretations of world religions in diverse practices within various cultural contexts. Highlighting the global connections among performance locations of world religions, Ritual Soundings endorses “comparative ethnomusicology” as it encourages a contemporary resonance among previous ethnographic and historical research, which not only embraces cross-cultural perspectives but also offers deep scientifically descriptive insights. Such a comparative paradigm presents a useful interdisciplinary model, from a macro ground of sharedness for meta-ethnographic enquiry in various local productions of meanings and differences across cultures. Aimed to search for localised meanings of human universals, Weiss’s comparative ethnomusicology sheds a helpful light on contemporary religious conflicts. For readers interested in learning about world religion with regards to individual practices from a comparative perspective, this book will be an excellent reference.
