This is a study of tribal government activity in state and local political venues. Treating tribal governments as both governments and pressure groups (p. 22), Laura Evans focuses on delineating the relationships between policy successes and “institutional niches,” defined as “source[s] of outside support that can provide small but meaningful subsidies for the cultivation of expertise” (p. 6). Institutional niches help tribes develop expertise in particular policy or program areas. Over time, greater expertise pays off in shrewder agenda setting, smarter networking, and more efficient policy success.
Evans examines the activities of 12 tribes from the Pacific Northwest, the Southwest, and the Upper Plains, primarily in the 1990s, combining quantitative and qualitative analysis of a variety of local, state, federal, and tribal documents. The first three chapters of Power from Powerlessness establish a context for the analysis. Evans begins by describing as “surprising” the tribes' “degree of participation and of successful influence in regional affairs” (p. 4). The opening chapter examines the reasons why we should expect “marginalized groups” to have less impact than is demonstrated by many of the tribes in question. Chapter 2 offers a capsule summary of the history of US–Indian relations and traces the process by which “a militarily subjugated people pushed slowly to redefine their relationship with powerholders” (p. 37). Chapter 3 describes the dynamics of institutional niches, and the ways in which tribes develop expertise slowly and incrementally.
Chapter 4 pushes the analysis into greater detail, explaining how tribes develop and utilize expertise in four key activities: Two involve tribes' analytic capacity (diagnosing and anticipating issues), and two involve tribes' capacity for action (initiating and partnering). Evans finds that “expertise matters. Ultimately, greater expertise facilitated new abilities to plan, implement, and successfully complete activities” (p. 102).
The importance of tribes' expertise as issues play out in local politics is addressed in Chapter 5. Focusing on tribal-county relations, Evans presents a detailed analysis of tribes in several different circumstances. Race and land play varied roles in encounters at this level, and she offers an interesting demonstration of the impact that lawsuits can have in diminishing and exhausting the resources of tribal governments. Chapter 6 moves the analysis to the level of state politics. The author finds that federal support aided tribal efforts at the state level. She also finds that Indian Affairs committees in state legislatures often blocked pro-tribal bills, but bills that managed to emerge from those committees often stood a good chance of eventual enactment. Overall, she writes, “[w]hen tribes had more outside support for building expertise, where committee structures allowed tribal advocates to house legislative expertise, and when tribes had experience on an issue, they improved their fate in state politics” (p. 191).
Throughout, Evans offers insights into the complexity and sophistication of contemporary tribal governance, particularly that of the Navajo Nation, and she discusses the numerous mundane interactions among tribal, county, and state governments that are like catnip to students and practitioners of everyday, nuts-and-bolts public administration. The book adds some detail to the broad outlines of intergovernmental relations, giving the reader a sense of the myriad ways in which governing bodies interact on everything from law enforcement and road maintenance to health care and education.
The book has several important flaws, however, beginning with questionable presumptions and a shaky historical foundation. The implication that tribal governments are or have been “powerless,” as suggested in the book's title, as well as the author's initial surprise at tribes' effectiveness in regional politics, suggests presumptions about tribal governments' historical efficacy that are built more in American myth than in reality. The history of US–Indian relations reviewed in Chapter 2 demonstrates that tribes have not been powerless, yet the presentation there is still rudimentary and overlooks key material. For example, Evans states that “oppression was the starting point” for relations between tribes and federal bureaucracies (p. 37), an oversimplification that glances past centuries of very complex and very diverse relationships between US agencies and native people and governments. Elsewhere, a brief setup for a discussion of the relationship of tribes to US federalism lists the three landmark Supreme Court cases known as the Marshall trilogy, but the discussion that follows (p. 26) omits discussion of Worcester v. Georgia (1832)—arguably the most relevant case among the three for the author's subject matter. The backgrounder on the Pacific Northwest region included in her case studies argues that a distinctive feature of the region's history (and an influence on its contemporary politics) is that the region “never had a fierce military resistance or an iconic figure of military resistance” (p. 37). This would be news to the people involved on all sides in the Cayuse War, the Yakima War, and the Rogue River Wars, among others, and also to the iconic figures of Captain Jack, Chief Joseph, and Looking Glass.
Another difficulty is that the tribes that comprise the book's case studies are unidentified. With the exception of the parts of the work that address the Navajo Nation, the other tribes remain anonymous. In principle, this is a problematic choice in any work about specific governments and public administration. In certain circumstances, anonymity may be understandable, and Evans argues that she has made this choice out of deference to the wishes of some of her study's subjects and out of concern that naming the tribes would encourage scholars and policymakers to forget that the universe of intergovernmental relations extends beyond the analysis in her book (pp. 46–48). The choice not to identify the tribes in the case studies, though, renders the practical usefulness of much of the book very limited. It is difficult to evaluate Evans' evidence, coding, and analysis independently, and the anonymity lends to the study a high level of imprecision and abstraction. As noted, some of the best parts of the book are in the narratives of tribes working out various issues in cooperation with state and local governments. In the Navajo cases, this is fascinating and almost tangible. In the other cases, the narrative is interesting, yet so untethered to specific tribes, times, or places as to be frustrating.
Problems with the book's editing only add to this frustration. Errors occur throughout the text, and especially at the end of Chapter 4, where a series of misplaced and missing endnotes garbles the connection between the main text and the author's source material.
In limited and cautious application, Power from Powerlessness serves to reinforce common wisdom about American politics and federalism: Expertise, funding, and networks matter, and incrementalism is a promising path to success. This is boilerplate stuff, but it is nice to see it examined in the context of contemporary tribal governance. The book is thus a useful step toward making sure that tribal governments become regularly included in studies of state and local government, intergovernmental relations, and federalism.
